Rob:
00:00:02
Every conversation about AI right now asks the same
2
:
00:00:04
question: what can it do for me?
3
:
00:00:07
We want to ask a different one
today: what does it reveal about me?
4
:
00:00:12
AI doesn't hand you your values.
5
:
00:00:15
It hands you a mirror
and turns up the volume.
6
:
00:00:18
Today we're pulling in a couple of
frameworks, Notre Dame's Delta framework
7
:
00:00:22
and our own THRIVE model, to ask what
it actually looks like to lead well when
8
:
00:00:27
the tool in your hand can outrun your
team, your judgment, and even your rest.
9
:
00:00:33
This is Just AI.
10
:
00:00:34
I welcome to the 1110 Leadership podcast,
where we tackle issues at the intersection
11
:
00:00:40
of leadership, faith, and culture.
12
:
00:00:42
I'm your host Rob Shields, senior
consultant at:
1110
13
:
00:00:46
I'm joined, as always, by my faithful
co-host, founder, CEO of:
1110
14
:
00:00:52
Leadership, David Ulysses Spickard.
15
:
00:00:56
David: Oh, my goodness.
16
:
00:00:57
What in the world?
17
:
00:00:58
Rob: I don't know.
18
:
00:00:59
I just- Is it because- I thought
maybe- Is that- … we could
19
:
00:01:00
workshop different middle names.
20
:
00:01:02
I know that's not very actual
21
:
00:01:02
David: was that what…
22
:
00:01:03
Did you, did you put that into
Claude- … or ChatGPT to offer
23
:
00:01:07
a different middle name for me?
24
:
00:01:08
That's
25
:
00:01:09
Rob: exactly…
26
:
00:01:09
David: This- Is that the
27
:
00:01:09
Rob: whole idea?
28
:
00:01:10
That's it exactly.
29
:
00:01:10
This is whole…
30
:
00:01:11
This is great, 'cause that's the
kinda stuff that happens- … when
31
:
00:01:14
you just outsource your note-taking.
32
:
00:01:16
Is, is this
33
:
00:01:16
David: what it means, Just AI?
34
:
00:01:18
Rob: No, no.
35
:
00:01:19
For our listeners, that was just a joke.
36
:
00:01:21
That was not an AI delegation gone awry.
37
:
00:01:25
Welcome.
38
:
00:01:25
Just making sure you're paying attention.
39
:
00:01:27
David: I'm, I'm with you.
40
:
00:01:28
I'm on it.
41
:
00:01:31
Rob: You don't seem like a Ulysses.
42
:
00:01:32
I don't know if anybody does,
but you definitely don't.
43
:
00:01:35
That's-
44
:
00:01:35
David: Well- You're a- … I
don't know how to take that.
45
:
00:01:38
Rob: I don't know.
46
:
00:01:38
I- As a compliment.
47
:
00:01:40
It's a very antiquated name.
48
:
00:01:42
I'll ta-
49
:
00:01:42
David: Okay, I'll take it as a compliment.
50
:
00:01:44
Rob: Yeah, you should.
51
:
00:01:45
David-
52
:
00:01:45
David: Ulysses seems like- David … a
strong and powerful name, so I don't know.
53
:
00:01:49
We'll see.
54
:
00:01:49
Rob: It's just hard.
55
:
00:01:51
It's a har…
56
:
00:01:51
It's just doesn't roll off the tongue.
57
:
00:01:53
Anyway, that's not what
we're here to talk about.
58
:
00:01:55
That's…
59
:
00:01:57
We're here to talk about
artificial intelligence, David.
60
:
00:01:59
Are you ready?
61
:
00:02:00
Is anyone ready?
62
:
00:02:01
Wow.
63
:
00:02:01
Is the world ready?
64
:
00:02:02
David: No.
65
:
00:02:02
No.
66
:
00:02:03
Rob: No, we're not.
67
:
00:02:05
But we're here.
68
:
00:02:05
Yeah.
69
:
00:02:06
And we gotta- Yeah … we gotta lean in
because this is the hand we've been dealt,
70
:
00:02:09
and this is the water we're swimming in.
71
:
00:02:11
So there's really no way
around this conversation.
72
:
00:02:13
This isn't our first conversation with AI.
73
:
00:02:16
our faithful listeners of the podcast
will recall we partnered with the Denver
74
:
00:02:20
Institute for Faith and Work when they
had Andy Crouch on to their podcast.
75
:
00:02:24
And we were able to team that up for
our listeners, which really thoughtful,
76
:
00:02:27
but also it's been several years now.
77
:
00:02:29
And so we know that as much as this has
been in the, in the water, we needed
78
:
00:02:33
to revisit this topic because it's what
everyone is thinking about right now, and
79
:
00:02:37
we need to make sure that we're joining
the conversation and also helping to
80
:
00:02:42
help our listeners and leaders think
critically and well about this issue.
81
:
00:02:47
So maybe David, before we get
into all the things, maybe we
82
:
00:02:51
just start with ourselves, right?
83
:
00:02:52
We talk about- Mm … this
is holding up a mirror.
84
:
00:02:54
Let's hold up a mirror to Eleventen
and, and, and David Ulysses Spicker
85
:
00:02:59
about what he thinks- Yeah … about-
86
:
00:03:01
David: Let's see if I, let's see if I
can be more insightful with my new name.
87
:
00:03:05
Rob: That's right.
88
:
00:03:05
There's something powerful coming now.
89
:
00:03:07
When you channel that ancient energy.
90
:
00:03:09
Uh-huh.
91
:
00:03:09
But in all, jokes aside, I think our
listeners would be curious to hear how
92
:
00:03:14
you're thinking about even just your
own personal AI use right now, your
93
:
00:03:18
relationship with AI and how we are
or are not using it here at Eleventen.
94
:
00:03:24
David: Yeah.
95
:
00:03:25
Well, it's certainly a conversation
we're having together, and
96
:
00:03:28
so I'll speak for myself.
97
:
00:03:30
But also it's coming from the perspective
of how we're handling it through
98
:
00:03:34
the work that we do at Eleventen.
99
:
00:03:37
I'm usually someone who doesn't adopt
things that quickly, just in general,
100
:
00:03:42
the new trends or the new movie or,
the new song or whatever it is, or
101
:
00:03:46
in this case, the new technology.
102
:
00:03:49
And so I've been watching and observing
more in terms of my posture, but
103
:
00:03:55
that's just normal for all of what
I do with these kinds of things.
104
:
00:03:59
But as we have used AI and I've used
it, certainly personally we think
105
:
00:04:04
through the ways it can be tremendously
helpful to us in our work, my thoughts
106
:
00:04:09
about it modify over time from being
skeptical, being scared, wondering
107
:
00:04:16
about the safety of it in terms of how
quickly it's being developed and how
108
:
00:04:23
information is out there and what do we
need to make sure that we protect while
109
:
00:04:29
also understanding the efficiencies
that we can have through using it.
110
:
00:04:34
And honestly, it has the ability to do
a deeper level of analysis sometimes
111
:
00:04:41
than we're able to do, either because
it does it in less time or it's pulling
112
:
00:04:46
from things that we just wouldn't
normally think of that enable us to
113
:
00:04:51
almost have a, a partner with us.
114
:
00:04:54
And I remember we had an episode
with Jess Everhart who talked about,
115
:
00:04:58
a thought partner- is the way she
described AI at the time, that we
116
:
00:05:02
don't, completely outsource everything
to AI, but we see it as a real, boost
117
:
00:05:09
to our work where it makes sense.
118
:
00:05:12
But I think in the back of my mind,
I still have these real reservations,
119
:
00:05:17
about everything from keeping up and
as a business owner, being tempted
120
:
00:05:24
to think that we're gonna have to
really keep up and know our stuff
121
:
00:05:29
about AI in order to be competitive.
122
:
00:05:32
And so the pressure of that,
while also keeping up so that we
123
:
00:05:36
can be good counselors for the
leaders that we're working with and
124
:
00:05:41
advising them well and helping them
understand how to think about AI.
125
:
00:05:45
So there's a certain level of
expertise that we need ourselves
126
:
00:05:49
just in delivering our work.
127
:
00:05:52
But then also understanding that so
much of our work is people-centered-
128
:
00:05:57
and it's presence and it's slow and
it's deep and it's messy And that's
129
:
00:06:07
where the real value of our work is.
130
:
00:06:11
Not clean, not quick, not
efficient, not well packaged.
131
:
00:06:17
And so, when you have a tool that can
make it look like you got it all together,
132
:
00:06:24
when you realize that true north in
many ways is the journey then we have
133
:
00:06:30
a tension that we're always fighting
with when it comes to what AI is now
134
:
00:06:35
and what it's gonna be in the future.
135
:
00:06:38
Rob: Hmm.
136
:
00:06:39
Yeah, … I'm glad that we're
starting there, you talking about
137
:
00:06:41
the North Star being the journey.
138
:
00:06:43
I would add another word that
we talk about a lot on the
139
:
00:06:47
journey is the wrestling.
140
:
00:06:48
We talk about it a lot with just
leadership, is the kind of the
141
:
00:06:50
wrestling through the nuances of how
we think about a decision, how that's
142
:
00:06:55
gonna affect other people around us,
how we bring all of ourselves into
143
:
00:07:00
that decision and have the emotional
intelligence to think about, who's
144
:
00:07:03
impacted and the long-term implications.
145
:
00:07:06
That's a process that takes time to
really settle and to think well- Mm-hmm
146
:
00:07:11
… and to lean into the relationships,
which we'll get to later, about how
147
:
00:07:15
we bring our teams, into that process
thoughtfully where their voices are
148
:
00:07:19
really speaking into directing as well.
149
:
00:07:22
And that wrestling, I mean, it's
almost like a GPS of a car feels
150
:
00:07:26
like, you know, when, I used to
have a TomTom back in the day, and
151
:
00:07:28
now it's all of our phones, right?
152
:
00:07:30
But the idea of when I asked my grandad
where to go, around town, lived in a tiny
153
:
00:07:35
town, New Bern, there's not that many
streets, but he'd just tell you all the
154
:
00:07:38
streets to get somewhere because that
was his memory, right, of like, he had
155
:
00:07:44
to know all this stuff, and then it just
got shrunk down to I don't even know
156
:
00:07:47
the second street in my neighborhood.
157
:
00:07:49
I've had to explain to
my kids to get out of it.
158
:
00:07:51
And I think, so there's an atrophy
of muscle, and I almost wonder if
159
:
00:07:55
one of the things that we might lose
with AI, if we're not careful, is
160
:
00:08:00
the gift of the wrestling, if we lose
the muscles to be able to wrestle.
161
:
00:08:03
Yeah.
162
:
00:08:04
Um, because we iron out all the
wrinkles, and the wrinkles are
163
:
00:08:08
actually some of the good stuff.
164
:
00:08:10
Not all of it.
165
:
00:08:11
The data, summary an- analysis,
like you're saying is wonderful and
166
:
00:08:15
really saves us a lot of time to help
us lean into the relational more,
167
:
00:08:19
which seems like a real win for us.
168
:
00:08:21
But, it's very much a double-edged
sword that we're still thinking
169
:
00:08:24
through 'cause the information,
everything's changing so quickly.
170
:
00:08:27
It's almost like we could develop a thesis
today, and it could be outdated tomorrow.
171
:
00:08:32
David: And we need to get
this episode out quickly.
172
:
00:08:35
Because
173
:
00:08:36
Rob: it's gonna
174
:
00:08:36
David: be out of date
175
:
00:08:37
Rob: in the next month or two.
176
:
00:08:37
Yeah, it should've been
a live stream maybe.
177
:
00:08:38
That's right.
178
:
00:08:39
By this afternoon,
there'll be a new app now.
179
:
00:08:41
Claude gets an upgrade.
180
:
00:08:42
Um- Sure … but, you know, there are
people who are attempting to provide
181
:
00:08:46
frameworks for thoughtful leadership.
182
:
00:08:50
One of the ones that we've come across
recently is, , Notre Dame has an Institute
183
:
00:08:54
for Ethics and the Common Good, who's
led by Megan Sullivan and her work, and
184
:
00:08:59
they have developed something called the
DELTA framework, which is interesting.
185
:
00:09:04
It's an acronym like our THRIVE acronym.
186
:
00:09:06
DELTA stands for dignity, embodiment,
love, transcendence, and agency.
187
:
00:09:15
Dignity, everyone has inherent worth apart
from their economic value or productivity.
188
:
00:09:20
Embodiment, we're not just brains, right?
189
:
00:09:23
We embody bodies and the physical, the
relational, like we were alluding to.
190
:
00:09:28
Love, which is a Christian ethic that
is what really the engine behind Delta,
191
:
00:09:35
transcendence was this idea of , there's
something about life that gives it meaning
192
:
00:09:38
that's beyond ourselves, that this isn't
all there is, our jobs, our lives even.
193
:
00:09:43
And then agency, the idea that we need
to be, have freedom and responsibility
194
:
00:09:47
to make moral and ethical choices.
195
:
00:09:50
And they provide that kind of more as
principles for us to help to evaluate
196
:
00:09:55
how we use AI, but it doesn't really,
David, , tell leaders what to do, , on a
197
:
00:10:01
Monday morning in that team meeting when
it comes to the line they draw around AI.
198
:
00:10:07
So would love for you to just, A, react
to that framework and kind of any of
199
:
00:10:12
those threads that, you'd like to pull
on, but also just what are you seeing
200
:
00:10:15
around leadership right now and how
they're dealing and analyzing their own
201
:
00:10:21
use of AI and where the conversation and
questions are slanted more towards, right?
202
:
00:10:26
Is it more of the principles like
Delta and asking big kind of framework
203
:
00:10:32
questions, or is it more steered
towards the simple kind of practical
204
:
00:10:36
execution of the, the tool itself?
205
:
00:10:39
David: Yeah.
206
:
00:10:39
Well, I think this framework, the
Delta framework, is something we
207
:
00:10:42
certainly resonate with because it
gets after, the way we're made and
208
:
00:10:47
our souls and what's at the core of
who we are and our value, which is
209
:
00:10:53
important to have at the forefront as
we have this conversation ar-around AI.
210
:
00:10:58
I think most of the leaders that we're
working with, that we're seeing are
211
:
00:11:04
looking at it from a practical standpoint.
212
:
00:11:06
You know, they, they're looking
at it from a place of, "How is
213
:
00:11:11
this gonna make my work better?
214
:
00:11:13
Thinking through the ways in
which it impacts jobs that we
215
:
00:11:17
have and the people that we have.
216
:
00:11:20
There are many leaders that we're working
with who also have not entered this space
217
:
00:11:27
of AI, and we have some older leaders
that we work with who are our generation
218
:
00:11:32
or , I should say my generation and- The
219
:
00:11:33
Rob: Ulysses generation.
220
:
00:11:37
There
221
:
00:11:37
David: it is.
222
:
00:11:37
And, adapting to technology is not
a thing and are, they're actually in
223
:
00:11:41
a significance phase of their lives.
224
:
00:11:43
They're not paying attention as much
to how their work is going to change.
225
:
00:11:48
And to be honest, we are needing to,
help them see how much they need to think
226
:
00:11:55
about this when it comes to succession,
because the leaders coming after them
227
:
00:12:00
are gonna work in a world that's much
different than what they're used to
228
:
00:12:04
because of the influence of AI, which
goes back to what I was saying about
229
:
00:12:08
our level of expertise in this to help
counsel and come alongside these leaders.
230
:
00:12:14
So all that to say, it's more practical
whether they're using it or not, whether
231
:
00:12:19
they're experimenting with the ways in
which it can help some of their processes,
232
:
00:12:24
, whether they're using it to, everything
from streamlining email so they're not
233
:
00:12:29
underneath emails all the time, and
they're using AI to help them with that
234
:
00:12:33
to, All the things that we are learning
about every day that AI tools can use.
235
:
00:12:39
I would say less of the conversation is
about the value conversation around this
236
:
00:12:46
and what it shows us about who we are
and what we believe success truly is.
237
:
00:12:52
Which again, is a banner that we try to
hold up, with our leaders, is to keep
238
:
00:12:59
in front of them what's the main thing.
239
:
00:13:02
How do we make sure we're not deviating
from what truly is important and why
240
:
00:13:09
we do what we do that ultimately gets
back to many of the ideas that come
241
:
00:13:15
from that Delta framework, that comes
back to value and dignity and everyone.
242
:
00:13:23
Rob: Mm.
243
:
00:13:23
David: You know, all people, , those
in our communities at various
244
:
00:13:28
levels, not just our own little
microcosms in our little communities.
245
:
00:13:36
But again, if we're about rejoicing the
city, the whole city when it comes to
246
:
00:13:41
our work and what we talk about here
at:
1110
247
:
00:13:48
space for this kind of thinking as it
relates to AI and what truly we value
248
:
00:13:54
to make sure we're not letting the
tyranny of the urgent or the speed at
249
:
00:13:59
which this is going to get us off track.
250
:
00:14:02
Rob: Yeah.
251
:
00:14:03
Yeah, I think that's good.
252
:
00:14:04
And it reminds me of our work, the
whole idea of the practice of AI versus
253
:
00:14:09
the principles, you know, that we need
to be asking ourselves, does a leader
254
:
00:14:13
need to have a strategy and a strategic
plan in place and think about goals?
255
:
00:14:17
Yes.
256
:
00:14:17
But also in our work, we're encouraging
them to have a leadership philosophy
257
:
00:14:22
and a personal mission, a sense
of their own why and what their
258
:
00:14:26
beliefs are and their core values.
259
:
00:14:27
And so I think that this is a mirror
of that because AI is the same way.
260
:
00:14:31
we need to be thinking about the
practical execution of it, but we
261
:
00:14:34
also need to zoom out 10,000 feet and
say, what's our philosophy around AI?
262
:
00:14:38
What's my personal philosophy and
that aligns with my own convictions?
263
:
00:14:43
And how-- Then AI and what I do with
it is just an extension of living
264
:
00:14:47
out that why and what our company's
ultimately for, how we define success.
265
:
00:14:52
And honestly, that mirror that AI could
hold up can reveal that we actually were
266
:
00:14:56
not really clear on that to begin with.
267
:
00:14:57
AI is gonna , make it really wonky
if we lack that clarity at the very
268
:
00:15:03
top on the things that matter most.
269
:
00:15:05
So Andy Crouch, I mentioned him
earlier he's recently put out some
270
:
00:15:10
more thought leadership on this on the
Good Faith podcast, and he frames it
271
:
00:15:15
as a choice, this idea which I love.
272
:
00:15:18
He…
273
:
00:15:19
Andy Crouch is a master of just
putting things really succinctly.
274
:
00:15:22
Run AI through the lens of love
or through the lens of power.
275
:
00:15:26
So love, he talks about orders people over
profit, power orders profit over people.
276
:
00:15:34
So how does that choice actually
shape the way a leader uses AI
277
:
00:15:40
towards helping people thrive or
towards squeezing more out of them?
278
:
00:15:45
David: Yeah.
279
:
00:15:46
I think you just said it.
280
:
00:15:47
Y- you're right.
281
:
00:15:48
This framework is good.
282
:
00:15:49
So I'm for certain have not thought of
AI and looked at my motivation from a
283
:
00:15:57
place of whether it's love or power.
284
:
00:16:01
Certainly, I want to
say it's a lens of love.
285
:
00:16:05
So now that I've heard this,
I'm now thinking about that in
286
:
00:16:10
terms of what that means for us.
287
:
00:16:14
Like, how are we using it in
a way that lifts everybody up?
288
:
00:16:17
How do we use it in a way
that encourages thriving?
289
:
00:16:21
How do I let go of keeping up, this
need to keep up and stay current?
290
:
00:16:27
How do I give up this drive for
continued efficiency and productivity?
291
:
00:16:33
'Cause what I'm concerned about is that
we're gonna do things quicker, but that
292
:
00:16:37
means we're just gonna do more things.
293
:
00:16:40
And
294
:
00:16:40
Rob: the stats are already
backing that up, right?
295
:
00:16:42
Like the, the idea of people
are actually not working less
296
:
00:16:45
because of the efficiency.
297
:
00:16:46
They're actually sometimes working more.
298
:
00:16:48
David: So the idea that this is gonna
create more margin for us, we're
299
:
00:16:53
just filling up that margin with
more things to do, more desire for
300
:
00:16:58
productivity, which is again, a mirror
back on ourselves about what we truly
301
:
00:17:05
value and how we think about success.
302
:
00:17:10
If I pursue AI from a place of
love, a place of rest, a place of
303
:
00:17:16
security, a place of inherent value
that's not driven by my productivity
304
:
00:17:25
or efficiency, then I can again go
into it open-handed and really think
305
:
00:17:31
about the ways in which it's going to
306
:
00:17:36
Let all boats rise.
307
:
00:17:38
Now, as I say that, I
realize that I don't know.
308
:
00:17:44
People who are in these worlds know
all of the different complexities,
309
:
00:17:49
all of the dynamics that are coming in
the future and the what it means know
310
:
00:17:54
the challenges that are ahead and are
really dealing with the implications
311
:
00:18:02
of how it truly is gonna change the
way we live and work and view people.
312
:
00:18:09
We're gonna look back and go,
"This is just like the internet,"
313
:
00:18:11
it just changed everything.
314
:
00:18:14
So I don't wanna be naive in saying
what we're saying now, and again,
315
:
00:18:18
this may be outdated in a month.
316
:
00:18:22
Because I think there's a level of
concern and real questions of ethics
317
:
00:18:29
and safety and security that come
with all this that we need to pay
318
:
00:18:35
attention to, but also not be afraid of.
319
:
00:18:38
And again, we don't have to
be afraid of it because we
320
:
00:18:41
know where our security lies.
321
:
00:18:44
And so it's always a both/and.
322
:
00:18:47
You know, we always come back
to this in:
1110
323
:
00:18:50
with us for for a long time.
324
:
00:18:52
You know, we always come back to this
both/and nuanced piece where, yes, we're
325
:
00:18:57
gonna pursue and lean into AI, but we're
also gonna do it with a questioning heart,
326
:
00:19:02
with one that's gonna understand that the
principles and the values that we hold
327
:
00:19:08
true have to be in place, and we're not
gonna sacrifice those no matter what.
328
:
00:19:12
Rob: Hmm.
329
:
00:19:13
David: So I don't know if that's what it
means to pursue it from a lens of love
330
:
00:19:20
versus a lens of power, but it's certainly
not going all in on, keeping up with
331
:
00:19:27
the Joneses to make sure we get ahead.
332
:
00:19:31
And that's what we wanna
warn people not to do.
333
:
00:19:35
Rob: Let's stress test this a
couple ways, in ways I think
334
:
00:19:38
that will resonate with leaders.
335
:
00:19:39
Both having to do with their teams.
336
:
00:19:42
This is real life.
337
:
00:19:43
You're seeing how AI can now
do parts of jobs and sometimes
338
:
00:19:46
absorb entire jobs, right?
339
:
00:19:48
Like an entire maybe even
industries of people who are saying,
340
:
00:19:51
coders, as an example, right?
341
:
00:19:52
Of like, man, there's not really
as much of a market as - anymore
342
:
00:19:56
for entire vocations, because AI
can simply do some things so much
343
:
00:20:00
more efficiently than a person can.
344
:
00:20:03
So Dave, if you're a leader and you're
in a field where AI is making things
345
:
00:20:08
so much more efficient, and for the
business, for growth for profit, it,
346
:
00:20:15
it-- the efficiency move is to maybe
rearrange the org chart or absorb
347
:
00:20:19
roles, combine them, sunset them.
348
:
00:20:22
The rubber really hits the road around
love, power, people, profit, when
349
:
00:20:26
they feel like they both can't win.
350
:
00:20:28
What counsel would you provide
a leader asking that question
351
:
00:20:32
around what they should then do?
352
:
00:20:34
David: I wish there was a simple phrase.
353
:
00:20:35
We need Andy Crouch in to s-
help us understand it succinctly.
354
:
00:20:42
This is where it gets really complex.
355
:
00:20:45
, I think we're not gonna say, the,
the lens of love is necessarily that
356
:
00:20:51
you've gotta keep people in that
job or that you can't let people
357
:
00:20:57
go as a result of this efficiency.
358
:
00:21:02
But if that happens, you should
consider, are there opportunities
359
:
00:21:07
to retrain them in other jobs?
360
:
00:21:10
Is there a way they can
be redeployed in some way?
361
:
00:21:14
Or if we do need to exit them, how
can that be handled with real dignity?
362
:
00:21:20
I wanna say that, if we look back at
every technological advance, and I think
363
:
00:21:25
at the time that those technological
advances were happening, we all said
364
:
00:21:29
that things were gonna go away and that
jobs were gonna be lost, et cetera, and
365
:
00:21:36
there was a sense of urgency around this.
366
:
00:21:38
And I wanna say we got real creative and
found other ways for people to be engaged
367
:
00:21:45
in meaningful jobs, and that we found
opportunities to show value to people
368
:
00:21:51
without just simply disregarding them.
369
:
00:21:55
Now, that's easy for me to say.
370
:
00:21:57
There are realities where someone's
listening to this who just got laid off-
371
:
00:22:01
because their job was taken over by AI,
and they really don't know where to go.
372
:
00:22:07
And we understand, , my previous
career in Jobs for Life, understand how
373
:
00:22:14
deeply impactful it is to be without
work and how that impacts our dignity.
374
:
00:22:22
It's a really tough time.
375
:
00:22:23
So again, this is why this is complex as
leaders, because how do we care for people
376
:
00:22:30
when that can be some of the reality?
377
:
00:22:33
There may not be an easy answer for
that, but we should be asking all
378
:
00:22:37
these questions and trying to come
up with strategies that can enable
379
:
00:22:42
people to be in a place where they
can thrive as much as we can- … as
380
:
00:22:47
much as we have a responsibility for.
381
:
00:22:49
I don't know if there's
a clean answer there.
382
:
00:22:52
I think honestly, some of it is TBD.
383
:
00:22:55
We're still in the middle of it, and
we don't know all the implications,
384
:
00:22:58
and we may never know because
of how this is ever-evolving.
385
:
00:23:03
Rob: Yeah.
386
:
00:23:04
I think referencing back to the,
the D in the Delta framework
387
:
00:23:07
of dignity there, you're right.
388
:
00:23:08
Like, this is not a new question.
389
:
00:23:11
Business leaders have had to make
hard personnel choices since the
390
:
00:23:14
beginning of time, uh, due to external
factors, market changes, right?
391
:
00:23:19
Like, profit isn't what it used to be.
392
:
00:23:22
AI is just a new framework, right?
393
:
00:23:25
To say, "Oh, well, this the new
thing we have to now react to."
394
:
00:23:28
So in some ways, you just double down on
the values that you always have, right?
395
:
00:23:32
If you're aspire to be an 1110 leader,
and you're committed to people's thriving,
396
:
00:23:37
because if their job fundamentally just
doesn't need to be there anymore, right?
397
:
00:23:41
Or needs to change, it isn't loving
to just ignore that and keep them
398
:
00:23:48
around, because people want to work in
meaningful jobs where they're contributing
399
:
00:23:54
and have a high sense of value.
400
:
00:23:56
And so if that has changed, then how
do we understand what their why is and
401
:
00:24:01
what their sense of purpose is, and how
do we commit and go above and beyond to
402
:
00:24:05
help them find the new version of that?
403
:
00:24:08
Whether that's, like you're saying,
retraining or redeploying within our
404
:
00:24:11
company, or rolling out our Rolodex to
saying, "I'm gonna contact whoever I
405
:
00:24:15
need to help you find a new landing spot.
406
:
00:24:19
I don't have to do that, but I'm
committed to you more than just
407
:
00:24:22
what you can do to produce for me."
408
:
00:24:24
And that's what 1110 leaders
do, that maybe the market doesn't
409
:
00:24:27
demand, but that love does.
410
:
00:24:30
David: It's counterintuitive, but as I
hear you talking and thinking through
411
:
00:24:37
what you're saying, it highlights how
much leaders need to have that margin that
412
:
00:24:44
we've talked about on so many episodes.
413
:
00:24:47
And they really, if AI is gonna be
helpful to them, they really should take
414
:
00:24:50
advantage of the margin it gets them
because they're gonna have to double
415
:
00:24:53
down on how they care for their people.
416
:
00:24:55
Like, there's an anxiety, epidemic
that's in our culture that just is, fuel
417
:
00:25:03
on the fire with AI being added to it
because of the anxiety that comes with
418
:
00:25:10
how this impacts my job and my value.
419
:
00:25:13
And so leaders that just are gonna
say, "Well, we're gonna go for it,"
420
:
00:25:19
you know, "We're just gonna, le-
go all in on this AI stuff and be
421
:
00:25:23
motivated by that power dynamic,"
while recognizing that they're now
422
:
00:25:28
more than ever, their people need their
attention they will miss it big time.
423
:
00:25:33
Hmm.
424
:
00:25:34
Miss it big time and not recognize
what's ultimately most valuable
425
:
00:25:40
to them, which is their people.
426
:
00:25:43
And our nature is to just produce
versus truly care about our people.
427
:
00:25:53
If we care about our people,
we're wanting them to produce
428
:
00:25:58
versus truly just caring for
them for who they are and
429
:
00:26:02
understanding they are our why
430
:
00:26:06
They're why we do what we do.
431
:
00:26:08
And ultimately it's about their
thriving and ultimately our cities
432
:
00:26:13
rejoicing- … which is about
people dancing in the streets.
433
:
00:26:16
People.
434
:
00:26:17
Rob: People, yeah.
435
:
00:26:18
Not robots.
436
:
00:26:19
David: No.
437
:
00:26:19
High-fiving- … dancing,
celebration, exaltation.
438
:
00:26:24
Things we long for that fill
our souls to the deepest level
439
:
00:26:30
that we desperately need.
440
:
00:26:33
That's what we're talking about, and
we can't take our eye off the ball.
441
:
00:26:39
Rob: Yeah, that's so good.
442
:
00:26:40
And, staying with the theme of how
this relates to people thriving and our
443
:
00:26:45
people thriving, the people that we're
called to serve through our leadership
444
:
00:26:49
you know, that the Lord has brought
on our path for this place and time.
445
:
00:26:52
It's interesting right now there's
even just a lot of argument from
446
:
00:26:56
leadership experts around the best way
to utilize AI in a way that galvanizes
447
:
00:27:01
a healthy team culture, right?
448
:
00:27:04
We've seen Harvard Business Review
came out with an article recently
449
:
00:27:07
around how AI can supercharge your
strategy because it can run, thousands
450
:
00:27:11
more scenarios of what you should
do than any human mind can hold.
451
:
00:27:16
And w- which they argue is a positive
because it gives you more - options to
452
:
00:27:19
choose from, , versus maybe you and I
could, in a room, could only think of
453
:
00:27:22
four, and we just can't think of 10,000.
454
:
00:27:25
, but it also mentions that it it can
help strategy because it strips out the
455
:
00:27:28
team politics around decision-making.
456
:
00:27:31
This idea that when the leader's in a
room, people aren't really being truly
457
:
00:27:35
honest because they're weighing what
the honesty could cost them, and so
458
:
00:27:39
they may hold back on their opinion.
459
:
00:27:41
Whereas if you're running, scenarios
through AI, you're getting more
460
:
00:27:44
objective propositions because no one's
weighing how it's gonna harm their role.
461
:
00:27:49
And yet the other side of this, is the
counterargument that we're seeing too,
462
:
00:27:53
is that if a leader microwaves decisions
and is going on this journey with AI and
463
:
00:27:59
talking to it for an hour about strategy
and gets so far past their team, then they
464
:
00:28:04
actually have the conundrum of going back
to their team and trying to sell them on
465
:
00:28:08
a strategy that they weren't a part of.
466
:
00:28:11
And so now they're having to slow back
down to bring them along of how they
467
:
00:28:14
got to that decision and how it impacts
them because they need their buy-in.
468
:
00:28:20
And so this goes back to the
wrinkles, David, of like how much
469
:
00:28:22
do we get our iron out, and is the
goal to really wrinkle through all
470
:
00:28:25
of the, the inefficiencies of- Yeah
471
:
00:28:28
decision-making when it
comes- Yeah … to leadership.
472
:
00:28:30
So- Yeah … what are your reaction?
473
:
00:28:32
Where do you fall on that continuum?
474
:
00:28:34
G- give us some wisdom.
475
:
00:28:34
Well,
476
:
00:28:35
David: again, it's both/and.
477
:
00:28:37
We wanna highlight the real benefits
and the opportunities that AI provides.
478
:
00:28:42
But we have to be very careful
from eliminating pain from our life.
479
:
00:28:47
Rob: Mm.
480
:
00:28:47
David: When you hurt yourself, you
can feel it, and then you fix it.
481
:
00:28:55
If we were hurt and we didn't experience
pain and we didn't know how to fix
482
:
00:28:58
what was broken, then -- we wouldn't
know you had to fix it, right?
483
:
00:29:04
So it's, how do we keep the journey alive?
484
:
00:29:08
How do we keep the pain alive?
485
:
00:29:11
How do we go through the mess
still and bring people along?
486
:
00:29:15
Because that's where real learning
happens, and that's where ultimate success
487
:
00:29:21
takes place where you have things last
for the long haul versus the quick fix.
488
:
00:29:29
So and this is no different.
489
:
00:29:31
When we come alongside and we see a leader
is leading from a top-down mentality
490
:
00:29:36
they're not bringing people along,
they're just telling people what to do,
491
:
00:29:41
that doesn't lead to a thriving culture.
492
:
00:29:43
AI is just gonna accentuate that if
that's the kind of leader that they are.
493
:
00:29:47
It's gonna, multiply it 10 times that
kind of dynamic in their leadership.
494
:
00:29:53
So it's gonna make that worse.
495
:
00:29:56
So again, it's almost a turbocharge on
who we are, which is why we're talking
496
:
00:30:01
about this like this, this is a mirror.
497
:
00:30:05
And so all the more reason to be
self-reflective during this time to
498
:
00:30:10
understand where we need to grow in
our leadership so that any tool that
499
:
00:30:14
we use, whether it's AI or anything
else, is gonna accentuate the kind
500
:
00:30:18
of leadership that leads to thriving.
501
:
00:30:21
And we can be assured that thriving
is at the other side of pain.
502
:
00:30:27
Rob: Hmm.
503
:
00:30:27
David: Deep celebrate- Thriving isn't
504
:
00:30:29
Rob: the elimination of it.
505
:
00:30:30
Yes.
506
:
00:30:30
David: Yeah.
507
:
00:30:30
It's not elimination of it, and it
may be helpful to help us navigate it,
508
:
00:30:36
but it certainly shouldn't eliminate
it because deep celebration comes
509
:
00:30:43
through the struggle, getting through
the struggle- … of the journey.
510
:
00:30:49
And we just cannot take that out of our
experience, of our leadership, or the
511
:
00:30:55
way we walk with our teams, our people.
512
:
00:30:59
So to the extent we can do both
at the same time, and again, this
513
:
00:31:03
takes world-class leadership.
514
:
00:31:04
Rob: Yeah.
515
:
00:31:05
David: Takes people who understand
this nuance, not afraid of AI,
516
:
00:31:09
understand how it needs to happen
and lead into it and go all in on
517
:
00:31:14
our people, all at the same time.
518
:
00:31:18
High level on both.
519
:
00:31:20
Again, another element in our
world that's gonna require
520
:
00:31:24
leaders to step up their game.
521
:
00:31:26
Rob: Hmm.
522
:
00:31:28
Yeah, and this is an ongoing conversation.
523
:
00:31:31
With the, the wrestling around this is
gonna continue, and it probably will
524
:
00:31:35
pop up again uh, in our conversation
as we go on our podcast, because
525
:
00:31:40
this isn't going away anytime soon.
526
:
00:31:41
So- Mm-hmm … David, you've hit
a lot of key points here, uh,
527
:
00:31:45
that I think will really resonate.
528
:
00:31:46
But how do we land the plane and give
a bottom line around what just AI
529
:
00:31:52
looks like, and to really aspire to
be an:
1110
530
:
00:31:57
both in practice and in posture and
principle around artificial intelligence?
531
:
00:32:04
David: Yeah.
532
:
00:32:05
Well, I think if anything, a takeaway
from today for all of you who are
533
:
00:32:09
listening is to ask yourself, "Am I
approaching AI from a lens of love, or am
534
:
00:32:14
I approaching it from a lens of power?"
535
:
00:32:18
Mm.
536
:
00:32:18
Where do you land on that spectrum?
537
:
00:32:21
We don't have clean definitions
of what those two lenses are.
538
:
00:32:24
We have a sense of those definitions
based on what we've talked about today.
539
:
00:32:30
But where do you land, and
where do you wanna move toward?
540
:
00:32:33
And in light of that, how does that
a reflection on your leadership
541
:
00:32:37
so that you do, , an assessment
of where you are, because either
542
:
00:32:41
way it's gonna augment, AI's gonna
augment where you are as a leader.
543
:
00:32:46
And so, you wanna make sure that the
things that you want to be about as
544
:
00:32:51
a leader are highlighted through the
way you think about, approach, and
545
:
00:32:56
utilize AI for yourself and your team.
546
:
00:32:59
And then see what steps that then leads
you to take, some tangible one or two
547
:
00:33:04
next steps that you're intentional
about to ensure that you're leading
548
:
00:33:09
from the lens that you wanna lead from.
549
:
00:33:12
And of course, we're happy to continue
the conversation and figure this
550
:
00:33:16
out with you if you're interested.
551
:
00:33:18
Rob: All right.
552
:
00:33:18
Good stuff, my friend.
553
:
00:33:19
This is, as always appreciate your
insights and, thankful to be wrestling
554
:
00:33:24
on the journey with you through the pain-
555
:
00:33:26
David: Yes
556
:
00:33:26
… Rob: towards thriving.
557
:
00:33:28
David: Same here, Rob.
558
:
00:33:30
Now, over and out, David Ulysses Spickard.
559
:
00:33:33
Rob: There it is, dropping
the microphone right there.
560
:
00:33:36
Till next time.
561
:
00:33:38
David: Thanks, Rob.
562
:
00:33:41
Speaker: To learn more about
:
1110
563
:
00:33:44
website at 1110leadership.
564
:
00:33:45
com.
565
:
00:33:46
That's the numerals one, one,
then spelled out T E N leadership.
566
:
00:33:51
com.
567
:
00:33:52
That's one, one T E N leadership.
568
:
00:33:56
com.
569
:
00:33:58
There you'll find more resources
to equip you on the journey
570
:
00:34:00
of becoming an 1110 leader.
571
:
00:34:02
You can also get connected to
our growing leadership network.
572
:
00:34:04
If you've enjoyed this episode,
share it with a friend.
573
:
00:34:07
To help others find us, you can also
rate and review us on Apple podcasts
574
:
00:34:11
or wherever you listen to podcasts.
575
:
00:34:13
Transcripts provided by
Transcription Outsourcing, LLC.