An online debate considering the recent Supreme Court case of 'For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers' which was handed down on 16 April featuring Aidan O’Neill KC (Scot.), KC (E&W), BL (Ireland) who appeared for For Women Scotland. In the discussion Aidan reflected on his experiences of the case, the judgment and participate in a debate of the issues it raises going forward. This was followed by a response from Dr Lena Holzer, and then a question and answer session.
141.The 'For Women Scotland' judgment - An academic discussion: CELS Webinar
01:00:01
140.The Future of the European Union: Socio-Economic and Political Challenges to its Legal-Constitutional Framework: CELS Seminar
00:36:23
139.'Digital Empire or Fiefdoms? The Role of 'the EU' as a Digital Power': CELS Seminar
00:38:00
138.'EU Antitrust Law's Resilience: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly': CELS Seminar
00:42:27
137.'The Familiapress Dilemma: The Horizontal Application, Horizontal Direct Effect and Horizontal Enforcement of the Free Movement Provisions': CELS Seminar
00:31:20
136.'The 2023 Franco-German Proposal on Reforming and Enlarging the EU – A Conversation': CELS Seminar
00:43:57
135.'Of Hijabs and Shechitah/Halal – Does the CJEU (and perhaps even the ECtHR) have a Blind Spot about Non-Christian Religions?': CELS Seminar
00:52:41
134.'EU, UK and the World: Reflecting on Challenging Times': CELS Seminar
00:39:24
133.'The CJEU, its legal reasoning, and its interaction with its Advocates-General': CELS Seminar
00:42:08
132.'UK-EU Relations: How can they be Improved?': CELS Seminar
00:41:23
131.'Decoding CJEU Judgments': CELS Seminar
00:46:11
130.'Language and the CJEU': CELS Seminar
00:48:51
'The impact of Russia's war against Ukraine on the EU legal order': CELS/UCU Webinar (audio)
01:32:35
'Assessing Antitrust Damages in Follow-on Actions Against Cartels': 3CL Travers Smith/CELS seminar (audio)
00:33:00
CELS/CPL/LCIL webinar: Rapid response on the UK Internal Market Bill (audio)
01:57:52
LCIL/CPL Webinar: Rapid response on the proposed UK Northern Ireland Protocol Bill (audio)
00:59:38
CELS Lunchtime Seminar: 'Defending the Rule of Law in the EU, a trip to the Legal Metaverse?' (audio)
00:33:44
In Courts We Trust: Some Evidence for Law as Credibility: CELS Seminar (audio)
00:53:53
'Regulating for Digital Policy in the EU: A Toolkit Approach': CELS Webinar (audio)
00:42:57
'Law, Policy, Expertise: Judicial Review in EU Competition Law': CELS Seminar (audio)
00:40:44
'Non-Competition Interests in EU Antitrust Law: An Empirical Study of Article 101 TFEU': CELS Seminar (audio)
00:32:33
'The antitrust market does not exist... so why should we define one? Market definition's sense and nonsense in digital markets': CELS Seminar (audio)
00:42:45
LCIL/CELS Webinar: Rapid Response Webinar on the War in Ukraine
01:26:44
'Enforcing Passport Apartheid through EU Law: From Internal Market to the Polish Border': CELS Seminar
00:38:45
'The UK and EU Criminal Law: "... an Island, entire of itself"?' - Professor John Spencer: CELS Seminar
00:42:17
'What is EU Relations Law? The Legal Ecosystem of Brexit': Monckton-CELS webinar (audio)
01:02:54
CELS Online seminar: 'The German Constitutional Court's decision on PSPP: Constitutional earthquake?' (audio)
00:57:46
'The Populist Challenge to Constitutional Citizenship' - Jo Shaw: CELS Seminar
00:40:15
'Consolidation or Fragmentation: Is EU Accession to the ECHR (Still) Worth It?' - Tobias Lock: CELS Seminar
00:48:08
'The EU as Regulator in Private Law: A Neo-Liberal Hegemon or a Civiliser of Capitalist Enterprises' - Hans Micklitz: CELS Seminar
00:42:43
'Citizens Rights in the Brexit Withdrawal Agreement: What Rights do People Have, and How to Enforce Them?' - Steven Peers: CELS Seminar
00:38:19
'History, Institutions and Ideas of Rule of Law in Hungary' - Zoltan Fleck: CELS Seminar
00:50:19
'Reflections on Brexit - The Road to Here and the Paths Ahead' - Christopher Hobley (DExEU): CELS Seminar
00:27:54
'To Align or Not to Align? - Market Regulation after Brexit' - Kenneth Armstrong: CELS Seminar
00:43:09
'Patients' Rights Post-Brexit' - Tamara Hervey: CELS Seminar
00:24:42
'EU Environmental Law, Brexit and the Future of UK Trade Agreements' - Dr Markus Gehring: CELS Seminar
00:29:11
'The EEA Agreement and the EEA Institutions' - Professor Morten Broberg: CELS Seminar
00:37:56
'Session 1: Free Movement of Persons and Establishment' - Eleanor Spaventa: CELS Brexit Symposium
00:27:23
'Session 4: Competition Law' - Tim Ward: CELS Brexit Symposium
'Session 2: External Relations' - Markus Gehring: CELS Brexit Symposium
00:32:29
'Session 2: External Relations' - Georges Baur: CELS Brexit Symposium
00:24:03
'Session 1: Free Movement of Persons and Establishment' - Martin Steinfeld: CELS Brexit Symposium
00:28:47
'A Doctrine of Pre-Emption for the European Union' - Amedeo Arena: CELS Seminar
00:35:03
'Seventy years old: the Italian Constitution does not look her age' - Silvana Sciarra: CELS Seminar
00:41:19
'The EEA Agreement and the EEA Institutions' - Dr Georges Baur: CELS Seminar
00:49:59
'Brexit – where are we now?' - CELS Panel discussion
00:51:07
'EU Loyalty: External Relations as a Constitutional Challenge' - Christina Eckes: CELS Seminar
00:39:16
'The EU Border Crisis: Questions for International Migration Law' - Bernard Ryan: CELS Seminar
00:38:19
'The European Pillar of Social Rights: A Critical Analysis of its (Potential) Significance' - Sacha Garben: CELS Seminar
00:47:21
'The Court of Justice of the European Union as an Institutional Actor: Judicial Lawmaking and its Limits' - Thomas Horsley: CELS Seminar
00:42:18
'The French Constitution at 60: Does it still have a strong Executive?' - Jean-Bernard Auby: CELS Seminar
00:49:29
'What Next for Brexit Citizens?' - Eleanor Spaventa: CELS Seminar
00:54:26
'The Impact of EU Charter of Fundamental Rights on Equality Law' - Angela Ward: CELS Seminar
00:48:24
'EU Constitutionalism, Crisis and the Security of the European Project' - Massimo Fichera: CELS Seminar
00:44:34
'Women on Company Boards: the Value of Equality Meets the Principle of Subsidiarity' - Barbara Havelková: CELS Seminar
00:27:55
'Revisiting the ECHR's Original Intent: How Conservatives Invented the Strasbourg Court and Why it Matters Today' - Marco Duranti: CELS Seminar
00:44:34
'A Tale of Two Speeches: the UK and the EU According to May and Macron' - Michael Dougan: CELS Seminar
00:43:09
'An Ever More Powerful Court? The Political Constraints of Legal Integration in the European Union' Dorte Sindbjerg Martinsen: CELS Seminar
00:37:56
Alan Dashwood: CELS at the end of the European Communities's Golden Age (CELS 25th Anniversary)
01:22:10
Albertina Albors-Llorens: Welcome and Introduction (CELS 25th Anniversary)
00:06:29
Bill Cornish: Gearing up for a CELS (CELS 25th Anniversary)
00:32:52
John Bell: The Changing Character of Comparative Law (CELS 25th Anniversary)
00:28:01
John Spencer: Europe and Criminal Justice (CELS 25th Anniversary)
01:01:40
Kenneth Armstrong: Brexit and the Autonomy of EU Law: Causes and Consequences (CELS 25th Anniversary)
00:51:54
Richard Fentiman: Concluding Remarks (CELS 25th Anniversary)
00:09:21
'International Law Cooperation between EU Member States' Angelos Dimopoulos: CELS Seminar
00:45:43
'Institutionalising Interdependence' - Floris de Witte: CELS Seminar
00:38:13
'The Bangladesh Sustainability Compact as 'Global Experimentalist Governance'' Kenner & Peake: CELS Seminar
00:47:09
'Interpretive Twists, Argumentative Turns, and New Reference Points: Unpacking the Jurisprudential Shift in the European Citizenship Jurisprudence' - Urška Šadl: CELS Seminar
00:21:31
'Free Movement of Life and Death: Euthanasia and the Ethics of Free Movement Law' - Barend van Leeuwen: CELS Seminar
00:32:28
'European Passengers' Rights to Compensation: What are the Rights that Apply in this Area?' - Marianne Hundahl Frandsen: CELS Seminar
00:38:25
'Audiovisual Media Service Directive: Boundaries and Drift' - Lorna Woods: CELS Seminar
00:46:09
'European Cartel Criminalization and Regulation 1/2003: Avoiding Potential Problems' - Peter Whelan: CELS Seminar
00:49:16
'The "COMI" Concept in the Revision of the European Insolvency Regulation' - Dario Latella: CELS Seminar
00:27:50
'The UK's Status in the WTO after Brexit' - Lorand Bartels: CELS Seminar
00:38:12
'The UK and the EU: the Law and the Politics' - Jonathan Faull: CELS Seminar
00:30:34
EU Referendum questions: Analysing the Vote Leave Roadmap
00:14:02
EU Referendum questions: EU and UK fundamental rights
00:23:32
EU Referendum questions: EU Security and defence
00:10:25
EU Referendum questions: Data protection
00:13:45
EU Referendum questions: Deportation of EU criminals
00:05:20
EU Referendum questions: EU Competition law
00:05:36
EU Referendum questions: Intellectual Property
00:05:06
EU Referendum questions: Migrant benefits
00:08:37
EU Referendum questions: The constitutional implications of the referendum
00:13:36
EU Referendum questions: The EU political structure
00:06:35
EU Referendum questions: EU Criminal law
00:14:01
EU Referendum questions: European environmental law and sustainable development law
00:14:44
EU Referendum questions: The Danish perspective
00:05:06
EU Referendum questions: The process of leaving the EU
00:05:43
EU Referendum questions: The UK's influence in the EU
00:06:50
EU Referendum questions: Workers' rights
00:04:44
EU Referendum questions: Free movement of workers
00:04:11
EU Referendum questions: Free trade
00:03:59
CELS/CIPIL Joint seminar: 'Historic Victory or False Dawn? Analysing the EU Data Protection Regulation'
01:08:13
'The UK's future in Europe: Implications for Ireland' - Daniel Muhall: CELS Seminar
00:41:43
'(Dis)enfranchisement and the Exercise of Free Movement Rights' - Aidan O'Neill: CELS Seminar
00:36:05
'The Proposed European Public Prosecutor - from a Trojan Horse to a White Elephant?' - András Csúri: CELS Seminar
00:34:16
'Between Independence, Integration and Rights: The Challenges of Data Protection Enforcement in the EU' - Orla Lynskey: CELS Seminar
00:40:41
'Voices of Individuals Collectively Exploring Self-Determination - a New Paradigm for Legal Capacity Research' - Eilionóir Flynn: CELS Seminar
00:34:46
'How "binding" are the EU’s binding renewable energy targets and why does this matter?' - Angus Johnston: CELS Seminar
00:44:08
'Pure Perfection? The EU Alcohol Strategy – It’s Not What it Seems to Be' - Amandine Garde: CELS Seminar
00:43:43
'New Governance and the European Union: An Empirical And Conceptual Critique' - Kenneth Armstrong: POLIS Seminar
00:46:56
'European Union Soft Law: Taking Stock of the Transparency Paradox' - Oana Stefan: CELS Seminar
00:38:03
'Freedom of Contract in EU Law: from General Principle to Fundamental Right?' - Jeremias Prassl: CELS Seminar
00:31:00
CELS Panel Discussion: 'After Opinion 2/13: the Autonomy of EU Law v. ECHR Accession'
01:28:34
'Accountability through Transparency and the Role of the Court of Justice' - Marios Costa: CELS Seminar
00:35:59
'Opinion 2/13 on EU Accession to the ECHR' - Louise Halleskov Storgaard: CELS Seminar
00:36:50
'The Global Reach and Effects of EU Law: Between Methodologies and Constructs' - Elaine Fahey: CELS Seminar
00:29:51
'Variants of Harmonisation in the Internal Market' - Marcus Klamert: CELS Seminar
00:48:08
'How to Promote Regulatory Cooperation across the Atlantic? New Ideas for the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP)' - Alberto Alemanno: CELS Seminar
00:42:19
'From Balance to Conflict: European Constitutionalism after the Crisis' - Mark Dawson: CELS Seminar
00:27:54
'The Implications of the Euro-Crisis Law on the Relationship between Constitutional Courts and Legislatures in Comparative Perspective' - Christina Fasone: CELS Seminar
00:40:53
'EU Enlargement During Times of Crisis: What Future for Freedom of Movement and EU Integration?' - Rebecca Zahn: CELS Seminar
00:28:34
'Changing Policy by Changing Institutions? Austerity, Horizontal Federalism and the Strengthening of the Presidency of the European Council' - Federico Fabbrini: CELS Seminar
00:33:46
'The Internal Market Case Law: A Tax Perspective; A Critique of a "Two Country" Approach and Mutual Recognition' - Julian Ghosh: CELS Seminar
00:50:00
'Mainly Optimistic: Neil MacCormick on Politics in the European Union' - Maksymilian Del Mar: CELS Seminar
00:51:10
'The Interaction between the EU's Exernal Environmental Policy and International Environmental Law: Can the Concept of Benefit-Sharing Address Legitimacy Concerns?' - Elisa Morgera : CELS Seminar
00:40:52
'Is There a Human Right to Work?' - Virginia Mantouvalou : CELS Seminar
00:36:25
'Consumer Protection in EU Residential Mortgage Markets - Towards Common EU Rules on Mortgages in the Mortgage Credit Directive' - Tatjana Josipovic : CELS Seminar
00:52:37
'Regional and Global Unification of Contract Law' - Ingeborg Schwenzer: CELS Seminar
00:39:12
'The Role of Private Enforcement within EU Competition Law' - Dr Niamh Dunne: CELS Seminar
00:48:14
'Who’s Afraid of the Charter? The European Court of Justice, National Courts and the New Framework of Fundamental Rights Protection in Europe' - Daniel Sarmiento Ramirez-Escudero: CELS Seminar
00:36:15
'The Public Procurement Rules in Action: an Empirical Exploration of Social Impact and Ideology' - Amy Ludlow: CELS Seminar
00:33:10
'The Impact of the European Union Current Crisis on Law, Policy and Society' - Anca Chirita: CELS Seminar
00:36:02
'Practical Aspects of Negotiations among EU Institutions Under the Lisbon Treaty' - Andriana Sukova-Tosheva: CELS Seminar
00:32:32
'The EU and the Decline of European Civilisation' - Professor Philip Allott: CELS Seminar (Audio)
00:40:34
'The Legal and Institutional Consequences of the Financial Crisis in Spain' - Professor Carlos Moreiro: CELS Seminar
00:43:56
'The EU and the European Social Charter' - Urfan Khaliq: CELS Seminar
00:48:22
'Assessment of the Court’s response to a political question': Dr Michael Waibel
00:11:27
'Pringle – the German response and the ESM legality': Professor Christian Calliess
00:21:10
'Economic and monetary policy after Pringle': Professor Simon Deakin
00:31:30
'Introduction to the Pringle case and legal issues which arise from a separate Treaty': Professor Alan Dashwood and Dr Markus Gehring
00:33:29
'The Ambiguity of (De)-harmonisation in EU Environmental Law' - Maria Lee: CELS Seminar
00:38:53
'Scottish Independence: The EU and International Law Perspectives': CELS Seminar (Audio)
00:27:20
'Why Compare? A Comparison of the Use of Comparative Judicial Materials by the European Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights in Human Rights Cases' - Christopher McCrudden: CELS Seminar
00:40:32
'Common Method of Interpretation for a More Harmonized Private Law in Europe - The Challenge to Go Beyond Black-letter Rules and Commentaries' - Pascal Pichonnaz: CELS Seminar
00:52:24
'From Women and Labour Law to Putting Gender and Law to Work' - Judy Fudge: CELS Seminar
00:22:50
'From Hard to Soft: Governance in the EU Internal Market' - Vassilis Hatzopoulos: CELS Seminar
00:45:30
'Proportionality in EU Law' - Wolf Sauter: CELS Seminar
00:27:50
'The Role of the European Central Bank in the Financial Crisis' - Dr Dan Wilsher: CELS Seminar
00:44:08
'The Import of International Customary Law into the EU Legal Order: The Adequacy of the Theory of Direct Effect' - Nicolas Croquet: CELS Seminar
00:45:56
'Regulatory Competition in Contract Law: Empirical Evidence and Normative Implications' - Giesela Rühl: CELS Seminar
00:30:48
'The Citizenship Paradigm' - Professor Dimitry Kochenov: CELS Seminar
00:35:05
'The Forthcoming EU Accession to the ECHR: a Myriad of Problems, few Solutions?' - Alexander Kornezov: CELS Seminar
00:46:42
'Legal Issues of Financial Reform in the EU' - Mr Jonathan Faull: CELS Seminar
00:54:53
'Fundamental Rights and Fundamental Conflicts in the European Legal Space' - Dr Daniel Augenstein: CELS Seminar
00:37:50
'The Fight Against Terrorism, Fundamental Rights, and the EU Courts: the Unsolved Conundrum' - Dr Eva Nanopoulos: CELS Seminar
00:47:12
'Allowing the Right Margin, The European Court of Human Rights and the National Margin of Appreciation Doctrine: Waiver or Subsidiarity of European Review?' - Judge Dean Spielmann: CELS Seminar
00:42:43
'The Way to the [Esoteric] Essential Problem of Constitutional Thinking in the European Union?' - Dr Alun Gibbs: CELS Seminar
00:38:50
'Up in the Air: Aviation in the EU Emission Trading Scheme and the Question of Sovereignty' - Professor Christina Voigt: CELS Seminar