Here’s the 411 on why hiring the right editor makes all the difference; since choosing the wrong book editor lowers book quality, which I've witnessed with clients who hired two professional editors, yet their books showed little to no editing.

The right editor must be well-practiced in your genre, never use AI for editing since traditional publishers, including the big five, pull contracts for any AI use due to copyright infringement liability, understands your target audience expectations, has experience with similar books, and maintains communication styles. They also must be open to working collaboratively.

Test editors by requesting industry-standard 500-word free samples rather than unprofessionally demanding full chapter edits creating "Franken editing" when authors collect chapter edits from multiple editors producing incoherent results. After reviewing free samples from your shortlisted editors, pay two or three editors to edit a chapter or 2000 words, determining fit before committing to full manuscripts.

Critical questions include how many books in your genre they've edited, their process and timeline, what's included in packages, revision rounds, and how they handle follow-up questions.

Major red flags include editors claiming they can do everything since real professionals specialize, refusing client contact until books are finished, working only part-time without industry experience, being friends or English majors rather than professional editors, pricing significantly below market, having unclear pricing, offering no contracts or unlimited revisions creating cycles, and being dismissive while unable to articulate editing philosophy.

Self-editing is not professional editing, and Amazon's algorithm identifies low-quality unedited books downranking them, making professional editing an investment protecting your reputation. Working relationships matter since you'll collaborate closely for weeks or months, requiring personality compatibility, good chemistry, clear communication, and professional yet personable combinations where trusting instincts about compatibility proves reliable.

Keep writing, keep dreaming, and keep creating. Your book is waiting to be born!

Ready to write your authority-building book? Book a Path to Publishing Discovery Call and take the next step to moving one step closer to writing and publishing your book!

Choosing the wrong editor lowers the quality of your book. I have seen this in practice many times; I have worked on clients' books where they said they hired two professional editors, but upon reading them, the books did not even look edited. I am going to give you some tips on how to avoid that so you choose the right editor for your book.

First, you want an editor who is well practiced in your genre and subject matter. Grammar is not the only factor; tools like Grammarly can assist with that. However, one of the things you must ensure is that your editor does not use AI. This is especially important if you are aiming for traditional publishing. Some of the "Big Five" traditional publishers have been known to pull contracts if they discover AI was used in the editing or writing process because it creates liability for copyright infringement.

Seasoned professionals can tell the difference between a book written with AI and one that is not. Even if you try to clean it up, the AI origins often remain apparent. If you plan on going with a traditional publisher, you cannot use AI. Always verify if your editor uses AI tools for developmental or line editing. While using Grammarly for basic spelling and grammar checks is generally acceptable, for developmental and line editing, you want a professional who relies on their own experience and knowledge.

Your editor needs to understand who your target audience is and what their expectations are. They should have experience with books similar in purpose and scope. Furthermore, they need to have a communication style that matches your preferences. You want an editor who works with you, not against you. If an editor is overly pushy, it might not be a good fit.

You can "taste test" an editor by asking for a free sample. The industry standard is around 500 words. Never ask an editor to edit a full chapter for free, as that is unprofessional. In the publishing world, this is sometimes called "Franken-editing," where authors send different chapters to multiple editors for free samples and end up with a disjointed, poor-quality manuscript. Instead, give the exact same 500-word sample to every editor you are considering so you can accurately compare their work.

If you like an editor's free sample, you can ask to pay them to edit a single chapter. Professional editors typically charge by the word rather than by the hour. Asking for a per-word price for a single chapter allows you to see their work on a larger scale without making a huge initial investment. If they fight you on your voice or style, you will know early on that they aren't the right fit. It is better to shortlist five or six editors for a 500-word sample and then pick two or three for a paid sample.

Ensure your editor has professional credentials or belongs to organizations like the Editorial Freelancers Association (EFA). They should be communicative, available, and willing to answer your questions. There are four stages of editing that should be done in order: developmental editing, line editing, copy editing, and proofreading. You want to start with developmental editing first, as starting with grammar or copy editing is inefficient if you later have to rewrite sections of the book.

Self-editing is not a substitute for professional editing. Algorithms on platforms like Amazon can often detect low-quality, unedited books and may downrank them. Your book is an investment in your reputation, and it is very difficult to repair a reputation after releasing a poor-quality book. Some authors look for editors who have worked on bestsellers, but being a bestseller is often more about marketing and connections than just the editing. A great editor should provide quality work regardless of whether they are on a bestseller list.

When interviewing potential editors, ask how many books in your genre they have edited and what their process and timeline look like. They should be able to give you a detailed walkthrough. Editing demand goes through cycles, so availability varies. Ask what is included in their package, such as the number of revisions, editorial letters, or style guides.

Avoid editors who claim they can "do it all." Most professionals specialize in specific types of editing. For instance, someone might excel at developmental and line editing but not copy editing. Additionally, be cautious of editors who say they won't contact you until the job is halfway done or finished. You should be able to communicate with them reasonably throughout the process. Another red flag is an editor who only does this part-time as a "side hustle" without significant industry experience, as they may lack the specialized knowledge required for your specific type of book.

So you want to make sure that you have a editor that

Ensure your editor is a native speaker or highly fluent in the language of your book. They should be able to communicate with you naturally and understand the nuances of the language. Do not rely on friends or family members just because they were English majors years ago; professional book editing is a distinct skill. Always ask for references from other authors and follow up with them to ask about their experience, particularly if the editor maintained their voice and style.

Some editors claim they didn't edit "too much" to preserve your voice, but a good editor can perform a heavy edit while still retaining your unique style. Ask potential editors how they handle revisions and follow-up questions. A standard approach often includes two rounds of revisions. Ensure there is a clear customer agreement or contract that outlines deliverables, revision policies, and expectations.

Trust your instincts when evaluating an editor. If you feel a personality mismatch or see red flags—such as a lack of questions about your goals, a vague process, or an inability to provide samples—it is better to find someone else. It is worth paying for a sample early on to ensure compatibility. You will be collaborating closely with this person for weeks or months, so having good chemistry and clear communication is essential for a smooth experience.