Summary:
Dr. Suresh Neethirajan joins host Jesse Hirsh to explore how artificial intelligence, bioacoustics, and digital twin technology are transforming livestock farming from a transactional model into biological co-creation. Together, they discuss bridging the gap between traditional farmer intuition and objective data to improve animal welfare, farm resilience, and food security across Canada.
Show notes:
In this episode of The Future Herd, host Jesse Hirsh sits down with Dr. Suresh Neethirajan, an agricultural engineer and research chair in digital livestock farming, to examine how cutting-edge technology intersects with animal agriculture. The central question of the conversation is how the agri-food sector can move past urban-centric technology strategies and black-box AI models to embrace multidisciplinary, context-aware tools that serve both livestock and producers. Dr. Neethirajan shares his unique perspective on why biology must anchor engineering and computer science, arguing that successful innovation requires respecting the complex, five-sense intuition that experienced farmers bring to their barns every single day.
Dr. Neethirajan unpacks the emerging concept of digital twins in livestock agriculture, explaining how multi-modality data—from continuous environmental metrics and computer vision to bioacoustic vocalizations—allows researchers to build virtual avatars of animal husbandry systems. Unlike static dashboards that only show historical data, digital twins enable farmers and researchers to run complex "what-if" simulations regarding feed supply chain disruptions, heat stress mitigation, and methane emission reductions without placing animals under external stress. This capability represents a monumental shift from reactive management to proactive, predictive stewardship that directly supports net-zero goals and operational sustainability.
The conversation also tackles the vital realities of data ownership, open-source research, and interoperability across both small-scale and large-scale farming operations. Dr. Neethirajan emphasizes that technology must be designed as a pull rather than a push, ensuring that farmers retain ultimate decision-making authority and are never burdened with prohibitive licensing costs or chaotic, proprietary data silos. By focusing on non-invasive computer vision and accessible mobile applications that translate animal vocalizations, his research team demonstrates how tiny operational adjustments—such as optimizing ventilation timing or slightly shifting poultry production cycles—can yield dramatic improvements in animal welfare and recovery resilience.
Ultimately, this episode challenges listeners to rethink the foundational philosophy of animal agriculture by advocating for a transition from transactional farming to biological co-creation. As Dr. Neethirajan explains, technology should act as an empathetic bridge between the human and animal kingdoms, fostering harmony, shared prosperity, and robust food security during tumultuous global times. For Canadian producers, policymakers, and technologists alike, this conversation provides a visionary roadmap for integrating artificial intelligence with deep biological respect to secure the future of our food systems.
Topics: Artificial Intelligence, Digital Twins, Precision Livestock, Bioacoustics, Animal Welfare, Data Interoperability, Agri-Food Policy, Biological Co-Creation
Hi, I'm Jesse Hirsh.
Jesse Hirsh:Welcome to the Future Herd.
Jesse Hirsh:As a livestock farmer, I spend a lot of time thinking about how our
Jesse Hirsh:relationship with animals is evolving.
Jesse Hirsh:In fact, I'm happiest when I'm out with my goats on the back part of our property,
Jesse Hirsh:kind of free ranging, and I kind of imagine myself going back in time as if
Jesse Hirsh:I'd been doing this practise for hundreds and hundreds of years for generations.
Jesse Hirsh:Farming has relied on intuition experiences and the five senses
Jesse Hirsh:when stepping into a field or returning to the barn.
Jesse Hirsh:But what happens when you take that deep human wisdom, that kind of ancient
Jesse Hirsh:sensibility that I feel when I'm with my goats and combine it with cutting edge
Jesse Hirsh:ai, bioacoustics, even digital twins?
Jesse Hirsh:Are we looking at a future where technology distances us from our
Jesse Hirsh:livestock, or can it actually help us build a deeper, more empathetic
Jesse Hirsh:understanding of animal wellbeing while still securing the prosperity
Jesse Hirsh:and profitability of the farm?
Jesse Hirsh:To help us deal with this question today, we've got a fantastic guest, CSH Raja,
Jesse Hirsh:a bioengineer and research chair in digital livestock farming from Dalhousie
Jesse Hirsh:University, who splits his time between animal science and computer science.
Jesse Hirsh:CSH is one of those rare researchers who doesn't just look at technology as
Jesse Hirsh:a tool to boost efficiency, but as a bridge to rethink how we care for animals,
Jesse Hirsh:how we manage our operations, and most importantly, protect our food security.
Jesse Hirsh:Again, I feel that we have this real opportunity to use technology
Jesse Hirsh:not as an either or, but a yes.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and there is something really profound in the way in which as
Jesse Hirsh:farmers, we connect with non-human intelligences, AKA animals, and
Jesse Hirsh:lo and behold, we're describing AI as another non-human intelligence,
Jesse Hirsh:which is why I am so enthusiastic, so curious about what happens when AI and
Jesse Hirsh:agriculture intersect and my new friend Ssh, certainly doesn't disappoint.
Jesse Hirsh:In provoking, in moving the conversation forward to not only imagine a a,
Jesse Hirsh:a new world of agriculture, but to actively help make it happen.
Jesse Hirsh:Alright, let's tune in.
Jesse Hirsh:I. Suresh, welcome to the Future Herd.
Suresh Raja:Thank you, Jesse.
Jesse Hirsh:Now I have to say I am particularly excited to talk to you today,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, not just because I am an avid learner of ai, but I'm also a livestock farmer.
Jesse Hirsh:And so you're really the first person that I've met who so brilliantly
Jesse Hirsh:connects those two domains.
Jesse Hirsh:But the first question that I ask all guests who come onto the podcast, and
Jesse Hirsh:there's no wrong answer, it's really an intuitive kind of gut question,
Jesse Hirsh:what does the future mean to you?
Suresh Raja:Like future in the sense of adaptation of, um, uh, artificial
Suresh Raja:intelligence or future of the animal agriculture forming here in Canada?
Suresh Raja:Uh, yeah.
Suresh Raja:It's going to be multifactorial how we can, um, everything is interconnected
Suresh Raja:in a way, so it has to be context aware when decisions are being made.
Suresh Raja:We cannot just, uh, jump and look through a small window and try
Suresh Raja:to make a decision out of it.
Suresh Raja:We need to have a little more effort in, um, comprehensively
Suresh Raja:understanding the whole landscape from multifactorial multiple point of view.
Suresh Raja:And then, um, we, uh, go about it.
Jesse Hirsh:Right on a, a very technical answer.
Jesse Hirsh:Again, there's no wrong answers.
Jesse Hirsh:It's always curious to see kind of how people respond.
Jesse Hirsh:Now, the second question I like to ask people really gets into their
Jesse Hirsh:kind of origins or backgrounds and, and I try to make it kind specific
Jesse Hirsh:and abstract at the same time.
Jesse Hirsh:And when I researched your background, both kind of intellectual and
Jesse Hirsh:professional, the the question that really came out at me, given the
Jesse Hirsh:range of interests you have, and at the same time I suspect a range of
Jesse Hirsh:opportunities that have come your way.
Jesse Hirsh:Why biology?
Jesse Hirsh:I can understand why agriculture, I can understand why technology or
Jesse Hirsh:engineering or even computer science and artificial intelligence, but why biology?
Jesse Hirsh:What was it about biology that drew you in and kind of kept your interest?
Suresh Raja:So just to be, uh, you know, um, as a disclaimer, I'm a classically
Suresh Raja:trained agricultural engineer, all three degrees masters in PhD in ag engineering.
Suresh Raja:Uh, nowadays they call it bioengineering.
Suresh Raja:Um, so a bird or an animal, if you look at a cow or a pig or a swine, or a horse
Suresh Raja:or a sheep or a poultry, or a duck or a Turkey, it's a biological entity.
Suresh Raja:So, naturally biology takes precedences, as I use the word interconnected.
Suresh Raja:Um, biology alone cannot provide the solution.
Suresh Raja:So we bring in the multidisciplinary field, uh, aspects of engineering,
Suresh Raja:aspects of computer science, uh, in biology, along with data analytics to
Suresh Raja:provide, uh, ish quality, quality of life for the animals, but at the same time
Suresh Raja:offer ways for sustainable profitability for the producers and farmers.
Suresh Raja:So it's truly multidisciplinary in that angle.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and that's what fascinates me.
Jesse Hirsh:Because on the one hand, most of the people in my life that I've
Jesse Hirsh:encountered who are in the engineering side, in the technology side,
Jesse Hirsh:they have no interest in animals.
Jesse Hirsh:They, they often have no interest in human beings.
Jesse Hirsh:but you approach this not just as an interest in animals, but to your point,
Jesse Hirsh:you're looking at their wellbeing, you're looking at the sustainability
Jesse Hirsh:while also looking at prosperity and the profitability of an operation.
Jesse Hirsh:I guess as a follow up still in, in the context of, you know, where you're
Jesse Hirsh:coming from intellectually, did you come to such a well-rounded perspective?
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, often researchers and intellectuals, they tend to
Jesse Hirsh:really specialise and, and kind of hone in on stuff.
Jesse Hirsh:But to your point, you're, you come at this very multidisciplinary, but
Jesse Hirsh:even more so there's an ethics or a philosophy to your work that also
Jesse Hirsh:seems to be coming at things from as many perspectives as possible.
Suresh Raja:Yeah, indeed.
Suresh Raja:Um, you know, uh, if you look at my employment, I'm currently,
Suresh Raja:uh, joint appointed between the faculty of agriculture and Truo
Suresh Raja:campus, uh, within the department of Animal Science and pop culture.
Suresh Raja:And then the 50 percentage of our appointment is in the Halifax main campus
Suresh Raja:within the faculty of computer science, uh, artificial intelligence, um, focus.
Suresh Raja:So, um, you know, when a farmer, uh, he or she, they are them, they walk and then
Suresh Raja:they park their car just maybe half a, uh, 500, 300 metres away from the barn.
Suresh Raja:As soon as they park their vehicle, a car, they use all of the five
Suresh Raja:senses to yoke and to make a, um, assessment of what's going on.
Suresh Raja:Oh, there is something iffy today.
Suresh Raja:There is an anomaly.
Suresh Raja:Something is not right today.
Suresh Raja:So how do they do it?
Suresh Raja:They use all their five senses.
Suresh Raja:They smell it.
Suresh Raja:Sometimes they hear sound.
Suresh Raja:Uh, if there is a, a based on the wind flow of it touches their
Suresh Raja:skin, they use all of these tools, uh, sometimes their own intuition
Suresh Raja:based on decades of experience to say meaningful critical statement.
Suresh Raja:Very often those statements are true, and then once they enter, it's exactly
Suresh Raja:the way they have, um, uh, perceived.
Suresh Raja:But at the same time, maybe a city kid or someone who is not familiar when
Suresh Raja:they go, they may make lots of mistakes.
Suresh Raja:So there is a lot of, uh, subjectivity and intuition is involved.
Suresh Raja:So how do we go about converting the subjective to objective with the help of
Suresh Raja:technology through a comprehensive way?
Suresh Raja:So we can't really make statements decision making in the livestock,
Suresh Raja:agriculture using one modality, one way of approach, because
Suresh Raja:everything is interconnected.
Suresh Raja:How do we actually move the needle from reactive to predictive through
Suresh Raja:proactive approaches with the help of this multidisciplinarity, with the help of a
Suresh Raja:lens that can see through the different thread that is connected to be able to
Suresh Raja:come to, uh, judgement and assessment and evaluation that can help the lives
Suresh Raja:of the animals at the same time, the decision making capacity of the farmer.
Jesse Hirsh:Absolutely brilliant.
Jesse Hirsh:That, that was such a great answer because it of connects the need to
Jesse Hirsh:have the intuitive level with, of the farmer, with the data-driven needs of
Jesse Hirsh:the researcher and the kind of systemic level awareness that, that, that affords.
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, I, I, I could keep with my questions building up a kind of narrative,
Jesse Hirsh:but I, I kind of want to jump to one of the bigger questions I wanted to talk to
Jesse Hirsh:you about, which is digital twins and, and the rise of digital twin technology.
Jesse Hirsh:Because what you just described in that answer was on the one hand,
Jesse Hirsh:a a lot of really human stuff like senses and intuition, also
Jesse Hirsh:a lot of complicated systems and, and that rely upon a lot of data.
Jesse Hirsh:So assume that many of our listeners right now have never heard of
Jesse Hirsh:the concept of a digital twin.
Jesse Hirsh:So if you could first kind of introduce it and then describe how it applies
Jesse Hirsh:to livestock and, and the way in which you, you use it yourself,
Jesse Hirsh:or you've seen digital twins be applied to livestock agriculture.
Suresh Raja:So for the livestock forming, digital twin is actually very new.
Suresh Raja:There is absolutely no commercial products available yet out there.
Suresh Raja:Uh, but when we look at the evolution of digital twin and other sector, it
Suresh Raja:was, uh, introduced like 40 years ago by NASA for space related applications.
Suresh Raja:Some, some recently in biomedical manufacturing applications.
Suresh Raja:So when we look at the word twin, so if we have, you know, twin babies born,
Suresh Raja:one is more or less similar to the other, uh, in terms of the behaviour,
Suresh Raja:in terms of how they express themselves.
Suresh Raja:So it's more like an avatar, uh, or a, uh, simulation.
Suresh Raja:Uh, we could say from the um, uh, animal forming animal agriculture perspective,
Suresh Raja:when we use the word digital twin.
Suresh Raja:So it is, uh, a soluble physical system so we can, uh, interconnect
Suresh Raja:it with multiple sensors.
Suresh Raja:For example, when we deploy different cameras, different sound recording devices
Suresh Raja:and other hardware, and collect these multimodality data, sound data, just like
Suresh Raja:audio or vocalisation from the animals, temperature and humidity related data,
Suresh Raja:environmental data of the animal husbandry system, and also the physiological data,
Suresh Raja:maybe the respiration rate, the blinking and the biological health related data.
Suresh Raja:If there are some video cameras that, um, measures movement and motility
Suresh Raja:and action of these, um, uh, birds or, um, cows, how do they move around?
Suresh Raja:How long they make different steps, how, what tie what side of the body, the cow
Suresh Raja:lies is the right side or the left side.
Suresh Raja:All of these complex, different data continuously collected.
Suresh Raja:Uh, and then we use artificial intelligence to build an avatar,
Suresh Raja:a metaverse that can mimic the exact nature of these animals
Suresh Raja:or the animal husband resistant.
Suresh Raja:And we go about making decisions.
Suresh Raja:So right now, dashboards are super common.
Suresh Raja:You walk into a barn, you can see multiple dashboards.
Suresh Raja:People are also using mobile applications to, uh, in a real time fashion to look
Suresh Raja:at, Hey, what's going on in my barn in terms of temperature and humidity?
Suresh Raja:Uh, they can even, uh, see the calling of the cows, et cetera.
Suresh Raja:That's, uh, most of the time it's what happened before in the past.
Suresh Raja:But twin is a slightly different concept.
Suresh Raja:The idea here is can we be able to run what if scenarios, what will happen
Suresh Raja:in the future if a change something?
Suresh Raja:Uh, so we could, uh, do a variety of simulation based experiments
Suresh Raja:without subjecting the animal to go through certain external stressor.
Suresh Raja:For example, as a country here in Canada, we rely on a different country
Suresh Raja:for, um, a inflow of supplement for our feed for the animals, if there
Suresh Raja:is a delay or a hiccup in terms of the supply chain and logistics,
Suresh Raja:what will happen in about 45 days.
Suresh Raja:So I don't have to, um, uh, uh, completely run the scenario and use my physical,
Suresh Raja:biological resources to do that.
Suresh Raja:Digital tune can do the whole thing with a fraction of cost
Suresh Raja:in a smaller amount of time.
Suresh Raja:Like that we can run a lot of, um, uh, uh, what if scenarios can be run.
Suresh Raja:So there are many advantages to it, even from the sustainability
Suresh Raja:net zero perspective.
Suresh Raja:Uh, if I am a diary former producing milk, can I be able to go about in
Suresh Raja:determining, um, to, for me as a farmer who have a hundred cows, for me to
Suresh Raja:pro, to be able to produce one lit of milk, how much of methane I'm emitting,
Suresh Raja:what does the methane equivalent emission per lit of milk right now?
Suresh Raja:It's a very complex formula.
Suresh Raja:It's really a tricky to arrive at that number.
Suresh Raja:But digital twin provides a more holistic way of deriving that information.
Suresh Raja:So is the case with YAG form for me to produce a dozen yag How much of
Suresh Raja:kilogramme of carbon dioxide or methane my particular pal tree or Turkey form is
Suresh Raja:emitting so I can run and understand these scenarios in a much more easy manner?
Suresh Raja:There are also welfare aspects to it.
Suresh Raja:For example, you might have heard of the terminology deep fake.
Suresh Raja:Uh, so it's a deep fake.
Suresh Raja:Some politicians who are not real politicians, they suddenly appear
Suresh Raja:on a very big screen in a bigger meeting and then make statements,
Suresh Raja:uh, pretend to make statements.
Suresh Raja:But those are not real politicians.
Suresh Raja:That statements may have very serious consequences.
Suresh Raja:So technology has been used for, uh, wrong purposes, but the same
Suresh Raja:technology can be put for good use.
Suresh Raja:For example, if the mother cow is being sent to slaughter houses for
Suresh Raja:some reasons, can we be able to use the defect technology via metaverse
Suresh Raja:virtual reality, uh, to ate biologically, physically create that, uh, twinning
Suresh Raja:of the cow so that the cow can appear suddenly and help to suit the baby call?
Suresh Raja:So there are different elements and different application scenarios possible
Suresh Raja:with the help of the new technologies.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and, and let me ask two questions that kind of dig a little
Jesse Hirsh:deeper into what you were describing.
Jesse Hirsh:And you know, the first is, where is the data to enable all
Jesse Hirsh:that simulation coming from?
Jesse Hirsh:Because, because you gave a, a, a range of examples that in and of
Jesse Hirsh:themselves are kind of fascinating.
Jesse Hirsh:And I suspect this gets into the research that you've been
Jesse Hirsh:engaged in for your entire career.
Jesse Hirsh:But the other question to that is, are there some animals?
Jesse Hirsh:Are there some livestock that there is more data available than others
Jesse Hirsh:and therefore it's easier to create twins for those kinds of animals?
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, dairy cows for example, strike me as one that would
Jesse Hirsh:have a lot of data available.
Jesse Hirsh:What are the animals that we need to be collecting more data where we need to be
Jesse Hirsh:working more closely, maybe with, with farmers to be collecting that data so
Jesse Hirsh:that we can enable these kinds of twins?
Suresh Raja:Sure.
Suresh Raja:Yeah.
Suresh Raja:So that also opens up the question of, uh, the small scale farmers
Suresh Raja:versus, uh, large scale farming.
Suresh Raja:Uh, you know, somebody who is subscribing to certain, uh, solutions where lely or
Suresh Raja:deal level or a bigger company, uh, in terms and all the cows are having some
Suresh Raja:wearable sensors, uh, around the neck.
Suresh Raja:So they collect these movement related data.
Suresh Raja:Uh, so most of the forms nowadays, they have this automated robotic
Suresh Raja:systems for milking and diary systems.
Suresh Raja:But the small scale forms, no, they still rely on partial manual based milking.
Suresh Raja:So the axis and the data availability is much more limited.
Suresh Raja:That also decides in terms of the quality of the twinning we can develop.
Suresh Raja:Uh, at the same time when we enter into a poultry barn or a broiler or a laying hand
Suresh Raja:interest quality system, the model changes because we typically make decisions, not
Suresh Raja:peral, it's per floor group of boats.
Suresh Raja:And then decisions are made based on those group based intervention strategies,
Suresh Raja:uh, on form daily management systems.
Suresh Raja:So the, um, uh, access to data also changes dramatically.
Suresh Raja:Uh, typically environmental data built conveyor number of ygs, of
Suresh Raja:course feed and water are continuously available for all the animals.
Suresh Raja:Uh, but to be able to quantify per animal feed even in the diary system and we walk
Suresh Raja:into it, we drive a tractor, and we, uh, basically provide feed on both sides.
Suresh Raja:There is no way we quantify how much each cow is actually consuming.
Suresh Raja:There are different back, uh, calculations based on the chewing capacity, the colour
Suresh Raja:sensor, the kind of approximately try to guess, but that's never accurate.
Suresh Raja:So there is a trend in terms of adopting what we call a non-invasive.
Suresh Raja:Without touching and prodding the animal, can we be able to collect more data?
Suresh Raja:So the computer vision systems are gaining a lot of momentum.
Suresh Raja:We instal different kinds of cameras at specific locations.
Suresh Raja:They capture, um, uh, uh, the movement of the cow.
Suresh Raja:They also look at how often the cow consumes based on
Suresh Raja:their different, uh, biometric profiling and morphometric future.
Suresh Raja:We can actually measure, uh, not only the body weight of the cow, the
Suresh Raja:lameness, but also the consumption rate.
Suresh Raja:So more of a individual precision diary.
Suresh Raja:Uh, consumption and nutrition assessment is possible.
Suresh Raja:So the, the availability of data is very heterogeneous.
Suresh Raja:It depends on a number of factors, the availability of the sensors and so on.
Suresh Raja:So yes, so that is directly proportional to the quality of the twinning we are
Suresh Raja:looking at, uh, uh, uh, developing.
Suresh Raja:So the more the sensors, the more the heterogeneous data, the quality of the
Suresh Raja:data, the better for the twinning model.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and, and I'm fascinated by what you said about the
Jesse Hirsh:computer vision, because certainly having cameras or installing cameras,
Jesse Hirsh:WW within operations, large and small is, is becoming increasingly accessible.
Jesse Hirsh:But I I'd also love to hear you elaborate on kind of the, the research process.
Jesse Hirsh:Like the way in which, you know, you work with students, you work with farms.
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, how, how are you able to kind of develop these types of
Jesse Hirsh:methods and gather this kind of data and what are the limitations
Jesse Hirsh:and does open source play a role?
Jesse Hirsh:And, and I'm kind of, uh, I'm, I'm not really coming up with a clear question.
Jesse Hirsh:I'm kind of throwing out thoughts as I go through this.
Jesse Hirsh:But you raised a really interesting point when talking about the difference
Jesse Hirsh:between large and small producers.
Jesse Hirsh:it possible to start empowering small producers to be collecting
Jesse Hirsh:data and being able to participate in some of these larger research
Jesse Hirsh:projects and, and larger simulations?
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, again, to extend that benefit as widely as possible?
Suresh Raja:Yeah, indeed.
Suresh Raja:So how do I go about collecting the data and, you know, manage, supervise,
Suresh Raja:uh, the students and mentor them?
Suresh Raja:So my primary appointment is research, uh, position.
Suresh Raja:Um, so I do a little less teaching and more research based
Suresh Raja:on the nature of my employment.
Suresh Raja:I also hold what they call as, um, research chair in
Suresh Raja:digital livestock forming.
Suresh Raja:This means my pri uh, lot of, um, distribution of efforts is
Suresh Raja:primarily geared towards research.
Suresh Raja:And also personally, I'm very passionate about, um, research.
Suresh Raja:So this makes me take, so we have a really nice group here.
Suresh Raja:I get to supervise students from computer science background as
Suresh Raja:well as animal science background for the past three years.
Suresh Raja:Every year, few weeks, we put all of these students in two big vans
Suresh Raja:and then drive across Atlantic Canada, stay in multiple regions
Suresh Raja:in Sussex County and New Brunswick.
Suresh Raja:Some in PEI, we stay for a few days to a week, um, instal different, um,
Suresh Raja:hardware components and collect data.
Suresh Raja:We have been to more than I would say, probably a dozen, uh,
Suresh Raja:forms, um, this past year alone.
Suresh Raja:So we do a lot of interactions, engagements in terms of field data
Suresh Raja:collection, uh, and then, um, through different data sharing agreements
Suresh Raja:with milk testing companies, uh, and also these bigger, uh,
Suresh Raja:companies which provide variables.
Suresh Raja:Uh, we li uh, uh, share and collect data via their own API application programming
Suresh Raja:interface or a PA as they call it.
Suresh Raja:And we collect the data when we enter the bond.
Suresh Raja:Sometimes there are multiple providers.
Suresh Raja:They provide different kinds of, uh, services and systems.
Suresh Raja:So it's not only one particular company.
Suresh Raja:Milk testing is provided by a different company.
Suresh Raja:The variables entirely a different company.
Suresh Raja:Uh, the robotic milking system, they belong to typically two or
Suresh Raja:three companies in the world.
Suresh Raja:Those are the bigger companies, uh, rotary Milking Parlour or the
Suresh Raja:robotic milking, uh, missions.
Suresh Raja:So like that.
Suresh Raja:And then if there is a veterinary record or wet health, those services
Suresh Raja:are provided through a different system.
Suresh Raja:So the data itself is very multifaceted and, um, complex and heterogeneous.
Suresh Raja:So we make an effort to, um, uh, collect all of those data.
Suresh Raja:So, um, irrespective of a small scale to large scale farmers, we collect them, even
Suresh Raja:if it's a small scale farmer, depending on the interaction and even a small
Suresh Raja:whiteboard based records they write.
Suresh Raja:And, uh, we take snapshots and some of those handwritten
Suresh Raja:records, we collect those data.
Suresh Raja:So all of these data are pooled into to be able to develop the twinning.
Suresh Raja:Uh, almost all of our research, if you look at, uh, we publish all the
Suresh Raja:mathematical models, algorithms, codings, everything is published for free.
Suresh Raja:Uh, because we believe strongly in open source.
Suresh Raja:How do we bring down the cost?
Suresh Raja:Can we be, for example, a few years ago, uh, uh, both the ca Canadian
Suresh Raja:and the American friends, US and European, uh, they passed a lot.
Suresh Raja:Hey, you have multiple different mobile phone companies.
Suresh Raja:You have USBC type.
Suresh Raja:There is a different way of charging your phone.
Suresh Raja:Why there are so many cables, you are confusing the public now they made it.
Suresh Raja:US BBC is the only way all the phones can be charged.
Suresh Raja:So that's the idea behind it.
Suresh Raja:Can we be able to create a common standards rather than
Suresh Raja:everybody beat their own drums?
Suresh Raja:Uh, is there a common way we can create a consensus so that there is a unified way
Suresh Raja:of providing solutions for the farmers?
Suresh Raja:Can we be able to narrow down the adoption pathway for the producers and farmers?
Suresh Raja:Can we be able to bring down the cost of technology?
Suresh Raja:It does not matter whether you have 60 cows or 300 cows, but still you
Suresh Raja:pay proportionally less based on the number of animals you have.
Suresh Raja:You don't have to sign up for a larger licencing fees for the
Suresh Raja:specific technology you want to adapt.
Suresh Raja:All of these considerations go into in terms of the technology
Suresh Raja:development as well as the validation.
Suresh Raja:So we pay enormous attention and care in the, uh, design development as well
Suresh Raja:as the validation of the technology.
Suresh Raja:And then when we go to the, we also have a nice form in the campus.
Suresh Raja:We have about 65 cows within in the Truro campus.
Suresh Raja:We work almost on a daily basis.
Suresh Raja:So we do a smaller scale, um, trial validation, and then we do the
Suresh Raja:second scalability at the commercial forms, which is about 250 cows.
Suresh Raja:So, um, this is the nature and the scope in terms of the way we work.
Suresh Raja:We get things done in technology development for the adoption pathways.
Jesse Hirsh:Right on.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and two thoughts that kind of, or two questions that kind
Jesse Hirsh:of directly come out of that.
Jesse Hirsh:One is, you know, you mentioned the different kinds of data that when you come
Jesse Hirsh:into a barn or you come into an operation, is interoperability a growing concern?
Jesse Hirsh:And, and I say this, 'cause one assumes that those sources of
Jesse Hirsh:data will continue to increase.
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, equipment is increasingly a source of data.
Jesse Hirsh:You mentioned the environment.
Jesse Hirsh:There might be multiple operations or multiple facilities at a single operation.
Jesse Hirsh:And then the, the second issue is, is kind of the notion of the
Jesse Hirsh:commons itself or, or a data sharing.
Jesse Hirsh:'cause on the one hand we're talking about using data to create a digital twin.
Jesse Hirsh:on the other hand, maybe different people have different twins.
Jesse Hirsh:Maybe a different advisory company or a different financing company,
Jesse Hirsh:or a different insurance company has a different twin and therefore
Jesse Hirsh:a different view on the marketplace or a different view of risk.
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, to what extent should we all be sort of going off the same page and to
Jesse Hirsh:what extent do we need to be anticipating the interoperability, the ease by
Jesse Hirsh:which not just researchers, but farmers and governments and regulators being
Jesse Hirsh:able to kind of see the big picture.
Jesse Hirsh:Or am I getting ahead of myself?
Jesse Hirsh:Are, are these concerns we should be thinking about?
Jesse Hirsh:Or is, is it premature to be concerned about this sort of thing?
Suresh Raja:Yeah.
Suresh Raja:Yeah.
Suresh Raja:Um, just so you are right, because we have already thought through
Suresh Raja:this, there are many, uh, folks, um, have, uh, given a clear thought.
Suresh Raja:There is also an agency in the EU icar, uh, specifically related to
Suresh Raja:direct cloud data sharing forum.
Suresh Raja:So, um, um, when we create a standardised protocol, for example, you go to an
Suresh Raja:electronic store, let's say Best Buy, and then you buy a laptop, and then it comes
Suresh Raja:with what we call as figures of merit, which means this laptop will work from
Suresh Raja:this temperature to this temperature.
Suresh Raja:If the temperature goes below plus five degrees CEL Celsius,
Suresh Raja:automatically the battery will drain.
Suresh Raja:This is the normal operating conditions.
Suresh Raja:So this figures of merit, irrespective of the brand, uh, we
Suresh Raja:buy, they are pretty much the same.
Suresh Raja:Same like cars.
Suresh Raja:It does not matter what model car we buy.
Suresh Raja:They have a specific unique standards with which they have to operate.
Suresh Raja:There is a regulating body that oversees that.
Suresh Raja:IP uh, like a international electrical electronics, uh, authority.
Suresh Raja:They oversee some of those similarly for the diary cow,
Suresh Raja:as well as for the twinning.
Suresh Raja:Um, right now, as of now, there is really no biological or,
Suresh Raja:uh, uh, animal forming related standardisation protocols available.
Suresh Raja:There is nothing available, but people are wrapping around their head, coming
Suresh Raja:together to be able to create a consensus.
Suresh Raja:So, again, as you rightly, um, put it, you know, if there is a finance
Suresh Raja:company or an insurance company or a veterinary health service provider,
Suresh Raja:if you have everybody beat their own drum, then it'll create more chaos and
Suresh Raja:unnecessary burden for the, um, farmers.
Suresh Raja:Farmers does not need a lot of, um, very shiny dashboards.
Suresh Raja:They want to know insights.
Suresh Raja:Can it help to bring down the time to results?
Suresh Raja:Um, uh, can they make decisions in a very much more, uh, sophisticated
Suresh Raja:manner without spending lot of effort from their side?
Suresh Raja:Can the needle be moved from reactive to predictive through a proactive way?
Suresh Raja:For example, on a Tuesday morning, if there is an anomaly, uh, if it
Suresh Raja:takes two to three hours to come to a conclusion, can they bring down
Suresh Raja:the time to maybe within 10 minutes, all of the input are being fed into
Suresh Raja:it with a very limited energy spent and time spent from the farmers?
Suresh Raja:Can they arrive at the conclusion within, uh, a reasonable amount of time?
Suresh Raja:If the technology can offer that, then there is more of a pull of
Suresh Raja:the technology from the sector.
Suresh Raja:If not, it's basically a push.
Suresh Raja:I developed this tool, that platform, and we try to push to
Suresh Raja:the farmers and make them adopt.
Suresh Raja:So in terms of technology development, that need to be a clearer consensus,
Suresh Raja:clearer understanding, uh, of, of the unified standardisation protocols
Suresh Raja:among multiple stakeholders.
Suresh Raja:That also opens up, Hey, who owns the data?
Suresh Raja:Eventually the animals are being managed by the producers.
Suresh Raja:Farmers.
Suresh Raja:Farmers, uh, pay certain services.
Suresh Raja:Sometimes they have subscription model.
Suresh Raja:At the end of the day, some companies basically allow the
Suresh Raja:farmers to provide certain data.
Suresh Raja:They may withhold a large amount of data.
Suresh Raja:So that's also being thought of from the government perspective, from the, um,
Suresh Raja:farm, like, uh, we have Diary Farmers of Canada and different, uh, marketing boards
Suresh Raja:and the co-op societies here in Canada.
Suresh Raja:So from their perspective also, uh, the end of the day, the data
Suresh Raja:belongs to the farmer and of course the animals themselves.
Suresh Raja:So, uh, uh, we are, as a researcher, we act as a liars and we act as a bridge,
Suresh Raja:as a catalyst to provide solutions.
Suresh Raja:But it has to be a genuinely impact creation.
Suresh Raja:Genuinely value is added at a reasonable manner.
Suresh Raja:It's not like a particular company makes money, um, uh, without
Suresh Raja:specific, um, uh, a value addition.
Suresh Raja:So those are some of the guards that have been thought through in
Suresh Raja:terms of how do we enable this?
Suresh Raja:What are the things we need to take care of in actually bringing the technology?
Suresh Raja:So again, some of these boundary conditions may not be applicable, uh,
Suresh Raja:universally between different species.
Suresh Raja:So those would vary depending on the context and the type of,
Suresh Raja:uh, uh, livestock or the, uh, bird based farming that happens.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and I appreciate your point about sort of push and
Jesse Hirsh:pull that often there's different dynamics in terms of whether it's
Jesse Hirsh:the industry itself wanting a technology or external pressures.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and for me a great example of that of course is disease transmission.
Jesse Hirsh:And, you know, avian influenza, for example, is something that
Jesse Hirsh:I know the, the poultry industry has, has been very concerned with
Suresh Raja:Yeah.
Jesse Hirsh:has this technology, where has disease mitigation, disease,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, tracking and, and traceability.
Jesse Hirsh:Where has that played in fostering both, uh, industry adoption, but
Jesse Hirsh:also the evolution of the technology?
Jesse Hirsh:'cause a few times you've sort of alluded to the ways like, you know, the point
Jesse Hirsh:about the, the using video and, and, and imaging, to what extent is the need to
Jesse Hirsh:understand the health of the animals and the larger health of society, how much of
Jesse Hirsh:that is starting to drive, uh, uh, some of this smarter and, and some of the data
Jesse Hirsh:collection that we've been describing?
Suresh Raja:So, yeah, it's a very important, uh, uh, focus.
Suresh Raja:Uh, I was a faculty at the University of Gulf many years ago for about eight years.
Suresh Raja:So we developed few technologies for point of care diagnostics
Suresh Raja:of our avian influenza.
Suresh Raja:So we take a swab, put it in a little, um, small, um, uh, tube, and then
Suresh Raja:we know the results right away then and there within, uh, five minutes.
Suresh Raja:So as of now, this gold standard is the PCR.
Suresh Raja:We send a sample, either bled or faecal or oral swab to a centralised laboratory,
Suresh Raja:do PCR, and then we know the results via email or phone call, uh, if there is a
Suresh Raja:high pathogenic, um, uh, hemagglutinin present in the virus, uh, uh, samples.
Suresh Raja:So the goal for, at that time our project was how do I bring
Suresh Raja:down the time to results?
Suresh Raja:Can I avoid, uh, shipping the samples so we know the results then and there?
Suresh Raja:So that was the focus.
Suresh Raja:We also got a couple of us patented technologies and
Suresh Raja:signed some licencing agreement.
Suresh Raja:Right now, with the help of artificial intelligence and also in
Suresh Raja:the, um, realm of digital twinning, it becomes more and more clear.
Suresh Raja:For example, uh, we have access to, um, different weather patterns.
Suresh Raja:We also know what will happen in the next, uh, uh, week or so, in term
Suresh Raja:more or less, in a much more accurate manner, the changes in the, uh, weather
Suresh Raja:conditioning of that particular region.
Suresh Raja:So that is known, uh, uh, from the epidemiological perspective.
Suresh Raja:Also from the pro, we have this pro action, uh, within Canada, we, uh,
Suresh Raja:have a certain way of, um, doing trick and trays and track where
Suresh Raja:the animals are moving, when it is expected to move from a governance
Suresh Raja:perspective, from the, uh, Canadian Food Inspection Agency, agriculture,
Suresh Raja:Greenfoot, Canada, uh, perspective, we have a, a satellite eye view of
Suresh Raja:what's going on, what kind of movement of, uh, different animals happening.
Suresh Raja:So there is a different set of data.
Suresh Raja:We also have certain records constantly or periodically, if not in a, a
Suresh Raja:continuous fashion, um, um, with some discreet data points available between
Suresh Raja:multiple forms across the country.
Suresh Raja:So those data can also be taken into account.
Suresh Raja:So all of these data, when we pool together, even though there are some
Suresh Raja:missing data point with the help of deep learning, we may be able to, um,
Suresh Raja:um, say with the much more clearer probability that, you know, this is
Suresh Raja:the incidents level in terms of your epidemiological, uh, decision making
Suresh Raja:and also, uh, making statements in terms of the possibility of, uh, that
Suresh Raja:going in epidemic or a pandemic nature.
Suresh Raja:So the ai digital twinning really comes in handy in terms of predicting
Suresh Raja:the particular incident or even, even before that happened with the help
Suresh Raja:of multi-data, uh, in a, because of the ability to compress data and also
Suresh Raja:the, uh, irrespective of the data volume just a decade ago was very
Suresh Raja:difficult because the data volume is humongous To be able to process all
Suresh Raja:of the data we need few weeks now, the few weeks have become few minutes.
Suresh Raja:Actually within few minutes a large volume of data can be processed,
Suresh Raja:competitionally, uh, efficient to uh, provide critical insightful
Suresh Raja:predictive values based on that.
Suresh Raja:So there is also a way of incorporating much more, what I
Suresh Raja:would call as non-tangible data.
Suresh Raja:Maybe there is a certain, um, uh, somebody is tweeting a certain, uh,
Suresh Raja:keyword and that is kinda creating an anomaly that can be picked up by
Suresh Raja:a web browser or a, um, robot that's constantly scanning the internet.
Suresh Raja:Oh, there's a certain fluke.
Suresh Raja:Maybe there is a possibility.
Suresh Raja:Oh, it's a 0.5 percentage possibility.
Suresh Raja:Then we can factor that into it.
Suresh Raja:So like that we can create much more complex way of modelling to be able
Suresh Raja:to come up with more precise and accurate way of, uh, track and trace
Suresh Raja:and offering value, uh, from the governance and safety perspective.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and, and let me kind of take two questions and, and
Jesse Hirsh:fold them into one, which the natural response to that is, you know, how do you
Jesse Hirsh:communicate that to the decision makers?
Jesse Hirsh:How do you communicate that to the farmers in the sense that if you
Jesse Hirsh:know a pandemic or if you know an epidemic is going to happen a week
Jesse Hirsh:away or even days away, that may not be enough to reach some people, right?
Jesse Hirsh:It, it, it can be difficult to, you know, uh, get people to pay
Jesse Hirsh:attention to something that they may not want to pay attention to.
Jesse Hirsh:then the, the second part of that that I'm, I'm kind of curious about is,
Jesse Hirsh:know, the, the broader notion of, of health and wellbeing of the animals.
Jesse Hirsh:Because on the one hand we're talking about reacting to a bad situation,
Jesse Hirsh:but a lot of your research is kind of on the preventative side.
Jesse Hirsh:It it's looking at how do we kind of create better welfare, better
Jesse Hirsh:environmental conditions, a better life for these animals, not just because that
Jesse Hirsh:ends up benefiting the producer as a whole, but because it ends up creating
Jesse Hirsh:all sorts of better solutions right.
Jesse Hirsh:Through the value chain.
Jesse Hirsh:How, how have you been approaching that?
Jesse Hirsh:What, what, what is your argument here and, and what role does the technology
Jesse Hirsh:and data play in either helping to do the knowledge translation, explain to
Jesse Hirsh:people what may be coming, or on the flip side, help, you know, improve
Jesse Hirsh:the, the, the life, how improve the wherewithal of the animals as a whole?
Suresh Raja:So, uh, in the year 2025, just a year ago, we
Suresh Raja:launched four mobile applications.
Suresh Raja:Those are freely available in both the iOS Apple store and
Suresh Raja:also in the Google Play Store.
Suresh Raja:Two of them for diary sec, uh, sector one is called Diary Ya or Diary at Canada.
Suresh Raja:The second one is Moog.
Suresh Raja:The two are for PAL tree sector, CL talk and cl.
Suresh Raja:So, uh, these out of these four mobile applications, three are based
Suresh Raja:on what we call as bioacoustics.
Suresh Raja:We listen to the vocalisations, the sound of the animals based on the sound.
Suresh Raja:We try to assess the mental makeup of these, um, animals.
Suresh Raja:Um, um, are they, if is the cow going through heat stress?
Suresh Raja:Uh, is the bonding between the mother cow and the cough good enough so that they
Suresh Raja:are happy, um, uh, in terms of welfare?
Suresh Raja:Is there a specific delay in access to the feed when they queueing
Suresh Raja:up in front of the automated, uh, milking machine for milking?
Suresh Raja:Um, um, or is it too much queue?
Suresh Raja:Is the waiting time much more longer than actually it's necessary?
Suresh Raja:Uh, if they are standing for longer time, sometimes even I have seen personally
Suresh Raja:the, um, of the cow starts losing milk and the milk goes on the ground.
Suresh Raja:Um, so, uh, uh, that's a clear, uh, uh, you know, uh, impediment
Suresh Raja:in terms of the welfare.
Suresh Raja:So some of these technologies look at these smaller telltale signs.
Suresh Raja:Sometimes we brush it off and we look at from a larger perspective, small little
Suresh Raja:changes can provide, uh, a bigger impact in terms of the wellbeing of the animal.
Suresh Raja:So by optimising, uh, we can actually provide the energy quality of life, uh,
Suresh Raja:in terms of the resource optimization, net zero and carbon credit pathway.
Suresh Raja:If I go and tell the farmer, Hey, you instal the solar panel in all
Suresh Raja:your roof, they will push me back.
Suresh Raja:Who is going to pay the capital cost?
Suresh Raja:Uh, that's an expensive proposition idea.
Suresh Raja:I am, uh, giving to them.
Suresh Raja:But at the same time, if I tell a poultry farmer, Hey, you know what?
Suresh Raja:You do the cleaning of your poultry farm every 53 weeks.
Suresh Raja:All I am suggesting is that move from 53 to 47 weeks.
Suresh Raja:Because based on the number of birds you have in the poultry barn, the y
Suresh Raja:production, the amount of the different volatile organic components in the
Suresh Raja:gas, um, the vocalisation sound and the movement of the bolts, uh, these are
Suresh Raja:the certain anomalies that's happening.
Suresh Raja:I'm not asking you to do every quarter, I'm just asking you to
Suresh Raja:move the needle from 53 to just six or seven weeks in front.
Suresh Raja:It.
Suresh Raja:It may not really cause a bit, uh, bigger impact, but it'll have a drastic changes
Suresh Raja:in the quality of the life of the boats.
Suresh Raja:The more you keep the boats happy and healthy, the obviously you will
Suresh Raja:see a production, uh, increase.
Suresh Raja:And also if they fall into a certain sickness or a health related challenges,
Suresh Raja:the recovery would be much quicker.
Suresh Raja:We call this is resilience or the adaptation capacity, and
Suresh Raja:they go to a certain disease.
Suresh Raja:How it much, how long it takes for the animal to go to the ground
Suresh Raja:state, the zero health state.
Suresh Raja:Normal health state, the faster, the better, the longer, which
Suresh Raja:means we need to tune and to tweak and optimise the operating.
Suresh Raja:So by paying.
Suresh Raja:Uh, and when we look at the ventilation system in a pal barn,
Suresh Raja:or even the fan that, uh, kicks off when there is a heat related,
Suresh Raja:uh, incident, heat days, hot days.
Suresh Raja:So we provide suggestions.
Suresh Raja:Okay, you do it exactly 30 minutes and this is the exact PPM for
Suresh Raja:your conditions, um, in terms of rotation of the blades of the fan.
Suresh Raja:So small little changes, not much.
Suresh Raja:There is a screwdriver change here, there, there, small make tiny little
Suresh Raja:changes, but it gives a drastic, a bigger impact down the road.
Suresh Raja:So it is not practically possible to look at these smaller changes,
Suresh Raja:uh, when we look through the lenses of traditional research.
Suresh Raja:So artificial intelligence and twinning can also provide value for small
Suresh Raja:scale farmers in terms of enabling the quality of, uh, enrichment of
Suresh Raja:the life of these animals at the same time without sacrificing the
Suresh Raja:profitability or creating burdensome in terms of operations of the farm.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and you just gave a great example of sort of the livestock
Jesse Hirsh:equivalent of precision agriculture, of, of understanding how to fine tune
Jesse Hirsh:processes, operations and facilities.
Jesse Hirsh:I, I'm curious from your perspective as a researcher, uh, when a lot of people talk
Jesse Hirsh:about adoption of precision agriculture, they mostly are looking at crops.
Jesse Hirsh:To what extent are livestock producers, not just in Canada, but around the
Jesse Hirsh:world, starting to adopt precision practises when it comes to managing their
Jesse Hirsh:herds, managing their, their livestock?
Suresh Raja:Yeah, in, uh, I used to be a faculty in for four and a half years.
Suresh Raja:I was a professor in Netherlands, so I have visited many forms.
Suresh Raja:Uh, recently we were in the United Kingdom travelling crisscrossing,
Suresh Raja:uh, different parts of the UK as part of the Canada UK Livestock,
Suresh Raja:uh, innovation Exchange programme.
Suresh Raja:A bunch of us, they put us in a bus in uk and we were really, uh,
Suresh Raja:travelling the full country, had a better understanding of the landscape
Suresh Raja:of a diary innovation ecosystem.
Suresh Raja:So in terms of the precision livestock forming, uh, it's
Suresh Raja:very similar UK and, uh, Canada.
Suresh Raja:But, uh, some of the western, uh, European countries like Germany, a little bit
Suresh Raja:of France and Netherlands, uh, they are very quick in terms of adopting this
Suresh Raja:precision animal forming or precision livestock forming in terms of the, um,
Suresh Raja:uh, deployment of different technologies.
Suresh Raja:For example, there are some companies, uh, now we can even actually assess
Suresh Raja:the weight of the broiler without touching the broiler just by scanning
Suresh Raja:and collecting videos and images.
Suresh Raja:Um, there are also different ways of assessing, uh, uh, the swine industry
Suresh Raja:health, uh, using camera based, uh, technologies, uh, here in North America.
Suresh Raja:Um, the way, uh, because it's very big, huge, uh, in terms of the, uh,
Suresh Raja:number of animals we handle, uh, um, by land also the distance with
Suresh Raja:the forms are also very, very big.
Suresh Raja:So, um, our way of forming is slightly different compared to,
Suresh Raja:um, some of the western countries.
Suresh Raja:Although in terms of breed, in terms of some of the feeding
Suresh Raja:conditions, it's pretty much similar.
Suresh Raja:We follow same style and same protocols in rearing those animals
Suresh Raja:in terms of production, et cetera.
Suresh Raja:So there are certain, uh, uh, compare and contrasts and analogies we can do.
Suresh Raja:Uh, but uh, the technology slowly evolving.
Suresh Raja:Um, uh, you are very much correct.
Suresh Raja:The uptake of precision agriculture is very high in the crop side,
Suresh Raja:but it is, uh, picking up in the animal side, animal forming.
Suresh Raja:Uh, but it'll continue to grow.
Suresh Raja:I would say.
Jesse Hirsh:Right on.
Jesse Hirsh:And you know, one of the things we try to do here on the Future Herd Podcast is
Jesse Hirsh:get into the realm of policy and kind of ask guests the kind of policies or the
Jesse Hirsh:kind of regulations that they think will, uh, uh, enable innovation and prosperity.
Jesse Hirsh:And ironically, one of the reasons I encountered your work was I, uh, saw
Jesse Hirsh:a post, an article you wrote about Canada's AI strategy, kind of criticising
Jesse Hirsh:it for being too urban focused.
Jesse Hirsh:So I'd love to hear you elaborate on that and talk about potentially the way which,
Jesse Hirsh:not just AI policy, but agricultural policy could kind of work together to
Jesse Hirsh:enable some of the, uh, outcomes that you've been describing in today's episode.
Suresh Raja:Yeah, sometimes I get a bit frustrated when I see those policies that
Suresh Raja:are mostly geared towards city folks.
Suresh Raja:And, for example, even cybersecurity.
Suresh Raja:Uh, people think that, um, uh, cybersecurity means, uh, only
Suresh Raja:finance or bank or hospitals.
Suresh Raja:But cybersecurity can also happen in a poultry bond or a diary bond
Suresh Raja:when a certain attack happens in a, uh, you know, food production
Suresh Raja:system or a milk processing system, uh, it can have a HAC in terms of
Suresh Raja:supply chain in terms of accessing to the food security of our country.
Suresh Raja:Um, so, uh, when we look at the dual use technologies, I think that for the past
Suresh Raja:few weeks, that's kind of hot buzzword.
Suresh Raja:Everybody talks about dual use technologies, defence and et cetera.
Suresh Raja:I say agro defence comes first because we need to, if there is an attack
Suresh Raja:in agriculture, it is an attack in the country's food security attack
Suresh Raja:in the country's infrastructure.
Suresh Raja:So please do not treat agriculture as an afterthought or a second
Suresh Raja:thought, give it a priority along with the major infrastructure such
Suresh Raja:as finance and hospitals and human health, et cetera, has to receive the
Suresh Raja:same level of deserving attention.
Suresh Raja:So that's what, that's what triggered me to write this, uh, article in policy
Suresh Raja:options and, um, asking for the attention of the policy makers, Hey, you know.
Suresh Raja:Uh, bit more, uh, focus is needed in agriculture area.
Suresh Raja:Uh, especially, you know, when we, we have a very good supply chain management
Suresh Raja:for both in diary and the poultry system.
Suresh Raja:How do we create a resilience?
Suresh Raja:We get hit from all the time from other countries and so on,
Suresh Raja:but how do we provide a value?
Suresh Raja:How do we create a resilience in the system?
Suresh Raja:Are there things that we could do so that there is a sustainable, um, uh,
Suresh Raja:shared abundance and prosperity among all the stakeholders within the country?
Suresh Raja:Can technology play a role from the policy perspective?
Suresh Raja:What are the things we could do to, um, enable make that happen?
Suresh Raja:So even, for example, data sharing, when artificial intelligence is being,
Suresh Raja:uh, constantly used for development of tools, platforms, and technologies, I
Suresh Raja:always propose, hey, do not develop a black box model at the end of the day.
Suresh Raja:Former has to have a say.
Suresh Raja:You know, it has to be a grey model.
Suresh Raja:So farmers can say, you know, over supersede the AI model.
Suresh Raja:No, I don't need you to perform this action.
Suresh Raja:They should have that, um, freedom, independence to completely, um, uh,
Suresh Raja:um, be the final decision making authority in terms of the adoption
Suresh Raja:and deployment of the technology.
Suresh Raja:So during the whole technology development adoption process, how do we infuse and
Suresh Raja:make the farmers as the owners, uh, uh, that need to be considered when
Suresh Raja:we develop these governance models and technology development pathways
Suresh Raja:from the government perspective?
Jesse Hirsh:Right on.
Jesse Hirsh:Absolutely.
Jesse Hirsh:E especially your point about the governance, just on the user level of the
Jesse Hirsh:user being empowered to override what, what, what the system's recommending.
Jesse Hirsh:I think what you've demonstrated, uh, so brilliantly today is the
Jesse Hirsh:way in which agriculture is at the forefront of a lot of, not just
Jesse Hirsh:the development of AI technology, but its deployment, its iteration.
Jesse Hirsh:what I'd like to do as a kind of closing for guests is encourage
Jesse Hirsh:them to essentially do a shout out, like who are the researchers?
Jesse Hirsh:Who are the people that you're following, either in Canada or around the world
Jesse Hirsh:that you would like to see the rest of us kind of plug into or pay attention to?
Jesse Hirsh:You know, where are you getting your inspiration from?
Suresh Raja:Um, I read quite a bit.
Suresh Raja:I also follow, um, different disciplines, not necessarily in agriculture.
Suresh Raja:Um, um, you know, I, um, look at some folks from Oxford University,
Suresh Raja:Marion Dawkins, who does a little bit of welfare re related research.
Suresh Raja:Some people in the United States, my fellow faculty colleagues, uh, some
Suresh Raja:policy makers in, uh, Western Europe.
Suresh Raja:But they also, um, when we meet in conferences and we have
Suresh Raja:conversations, I derive inspirations from them and get new ideas and
Suresh Raja:new directions for my own research.
Jesse Hirsh:Right on.
Jesse Hirsh:And you know, a final question that I kind of have to ask for my own selfish
Jesse Hirsh:purposes, your kind of next interest?
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, on the one hand, I suspect that you are absolutely up to your eyeballs
Jesse Hirsh:in the current research projects you have all of which are fascinating.
Jesse Hirsh:But I'm kind of curious as to whether someone like yourself is anticipating
Jesse Hirsh:what comes next and what that might be.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, what would be the kind of research interests or research
Jesse Hirsh:projects that you see on your kind of medium to long-term horizon?
Suresh Raja:Yeah, so we have a plan for five years.
Suresh Raja:So for the next five years, we know exactly what we are going to do.
Suresh Raja:Uh, so it's more of a computational interconnected systems.
Suresh Raja:So for, uh, modern animal forming, um, how do we bring down the time to results?
Suresh Raja:How do we improve the quality of life?
Suresh Raja:Can we be able to enhance the interactions between the animal and
Suresh Raja:the animal caretaker and the farmer in terms of bonding, in terms of empathy?
Suresh Raja:Can we be able to move the needle from transaction based relationship to
Suresh Raja:co-creation based relationship more often?
Suresh Raja:Sometimes when we look animal forming, we like, Hey, you know what?
Suresh Raja:I give you food or feed.
Suresh Raja:I give you shelter, you give me back yag, you gimme milk, you gimme meat.
Suresh Raja:So it's more of a transaction based.
Suresh Raja:Yes, it's indeed it's needed.
Suresh Raja:We are 9 billion people growing and growing.
Suresh Raja:We need to feed protein and all the people, but at the same time
Suresh Raja:can be infused the values of human, uh, in terms of this co-creation
Suresh Raja:possibility with the animal.
Suresh Raja:Uh, I belong to a human kingdom.
Suresh Raja:You belong to animal kingdom.
Suresh Raja:We have both have short lives.
Suresh Raja:Can we create a harmony synergy through which we can use the
Suresh Raja:technology as a bonding way, as a, um, bridging way to coexist and
Suresh Raja:co-create and travel in this journey?
Suresh Raja:So those are some of the elements we have been looking at.
Suresh Raja:How do we create shared prosperity and abundance for everyone, um, um,
Suresh Raja:as we navigate this tumultuous times.
Jesse Hirsh:Wonderful.
Jesse Hirsh:What, what a great way, uh, to end what has been a, a really,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, uh, enjoyable and in my case, educational episode, uh, Resh.
Jesse Hirsh:Thank you very much and I, I hope you can come back.
Jesse Hirsh:We're only just scratching the surface of what's possible, especially to
Jesse Hirsh:your point of thinking about it as co-creation, that we are working with
Jesse Hirsh:our animals to help feed the planet.
Jesse Hirsh:Thank you so much, Siresh.
Suresh Raja:Thank you, Jesse.
Jesse Hirsh:One of the things I find so frustrating about
Jesse Hirsh:contemporary public discourse is everything seems to be an either and.
Jesse Hirsh:One of the things I find so frustrating about contemporary public
Jesse Hirsh:discourse is everything seems to be an either or rather than a yes.
Jesse Hirsh:And what I absolutely enjoyed about my conversation with Suresh today is
Jesse Hirsh:it not only adds a level of nuance to conversations around animal farming
Jesse Hirsh:conversations around the use of ai, but it also suggests that there's an
Jesse Hirsh:incredibly important role for empathy, for centering the concept of care, of
Jesse Hirsh:co-creation, of really thinking about not just our relationship with animals,
Jesse Hirsh:but our relationship with each other, with nature, with the world as a whole.
Jesse Hirsh:Too often we focus on the conflicts.
Jesse Hirsh:We focus on our differences rather than finding our commonality, rather
Jesse Hirsh:than finding our passion, our empathy, our desire to make the world a better
Jesse Hirsh:place, and that is one of the main motivators I have for the future herd
Jesse Hirsh:is food is one of those places where people tend to open their minds.
Jesse Hirsh:They tend to indulge in a certain level of curiosity, try new
Jesse Hirsh:things, entertain new ideas.
Jesse Hirsh:And that's where I do find that there's this interesting intersection between
Jesse Hirsh:ai, animal farming, animal welfare, and the concept of intelligence itself,
Jesse Hirsh:let alone its most, uh, pressing application, which is intuition, which
Jesse Hirsh:brings me back to me and my goats.
Jesse Hirsh:One of the things I love experiencing and exploring when I take them on
Jesse Hirsh:our walks is our combined intuition.
Jesse Hirsh:On the one hand, I'm trying to read the group, 'cause
Jesse Hirsh:fundamentally I don't control them.
Jesse Hirsh:We're out beyond the fences, out at the edge of the property where
Jesse Hirsh:they could just run onto the road and get hit by a truck or something.
Jesse Hirsh:And at the same time, they're enjoying themselves.
Jesse Hirsh:They're enjoying the experience.
Jesse Hirsh:So there is both a level of communication and a level of intuition that if I could
Jesse Hirsh:combine that with the kind of technology, uh, that CSH described, and I sort of
Jesse Hirsh:already am in the sense of the videos and the observations and the, uh, kind of
Jesse Hirsh:anthropological, is that the right word?
Jesse Hirsh:No zoological observations that I'm engaged in.
Jesse Hirsh:But again, to actually turn this into research, to turn this into
Jesse Hirsh:data would allow me to take my skills, my herd, to the next level.
Jesse Hirsh:And that is really the opportunity, the potential that some of this
Jesse Hirsh:technology offers, as long as it's accessible, as long as it's open source.
Jesse Hirsh:And in that sense, uh, uh, uh, we will be returning here on the future herd
Jesse Hirsh:to the subject of ai, to the subject of animal welfare, farm welfare, farmer
Jesse Hirsh:welfare, plant welfare, and open source.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, a preview of the future.
Jesse Hirsh:Yes.
Jesse Hirsh:And a opportunity for us to end this episode.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, thanks again for listening.
Jesse Hirsh:The future, her.ca is the website, uh, your friends are
Jesse Hirsh:who you should share this with.
Jesse Hirsh:And until next time, I'm Jesse Hirsch.
Jesse Hirsh:We'll talk to you soon.