Artwork for podcast Colorado Trial Lawyer Connection
Melissa Hailey and Liz Hart – $7.6M Verdict for a Teen with Debilitating Headaches
Episode 32 • 24th September 2025 • Colorado Trial Lawyer Connection • Keith Fuicelli, Fuicelli & Lee
00:00:00 00:56:39

Share Episode

Shownotes

Their client was just 16 when a driver T-boned her vehicle, leading to years of debilitating headaches that require cutting-edge treatments every 12 weeks. In this case breakdown with host Keith Fuicelli, Melissa Hailey and Liz Hart reveal how they approached the case with meticulous pre-litigation case development, strategic big data jury research, and expert medical testimony. Jurors awarded $7.1 million in future medical costs and $500,000 in non-economic damages. Tune in for the team’s insights about limiting economic demands to maintain credibility – and about joining forces to develop a successful law practice.

Learn More and Connect with Colorado Trial Lawyers

☑️ Melissa Hailey | LinkedIn

☑️ Liz Hart | LinkedIn

☑️ Hailey | Hart on LinkedIn | Facebook  

☑️ Keith Fuicelli | LinkedIn

☑️ Fuicelli & Lee Injury Lawyers Website

☑️ Fuicelli & Lee Injury Lawyers on X, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, and LinkedIn

☑️ Subscribe Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube

Episode Snapshot

  • Elizabeth's journey from wanting to be a criminal defense attorney to becoming a plaintiff's lawyer after five years in insurance defense.
  • Melissa's unconventional path from conservation biology to environmental law to personal injury practice.
  • The lawyers envisioned a women-owned plaintiff's firm during Covid and opened Hailey | Hart in 2021.
  • Their collaborative trial approach: splitting responsibilities, with Liz handling jury selection and closing and Melissa doing opening and rebuttal.
  • In this case breakdown, they describe representing a 16-year-old client who suffered chronic migraines after a T-bone collision.
  • The client contacted lawyers three years after the crash when USAA refused to pay policy limits despite expensive ongoing neurological treatment.
  • A cutting-edge infusion medication given every 12 weeks called VYEPTI became the cornerstone of the client's successful treatment plan
  • The team used big data research to identify jury resistance points and craft strategy around potential damages objections
  • They decided to limit their economic ask to $7.1 million for only two types of treatments (VYEPTI and trigger point injections) rather than including all medications.
  • The jury awarded exactly $7.1 million in economics and zero in permanent impairment, validating their approach.

The information contained in this podcast is not intended to be taken as legal advice. The information provided by Fuicelli & Lee is intended to provide general information regarding comprehensive injury and accident attorney services for clients in the state of Colorado.

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube

More Episodes
32. Melissa Hailey and Liz Hart – $7.6M Verdict for a Teen with Debilitating Headaches
00:56:39
31. Tim Garvey and Greg Bentley – From Broken Sidewalk to $8.2M Verdict
01:01:05
30. Tim Galluzzi - Lessons from Three Back-to-Back Trials
00:54:01
29. Jared Mazzei and Jessica McBryant - $6.9M Verdict Beats Malingering Claim in Slip-and-Fall Case
00:48:02
28. Spencer Kontnik – Securing a $500,000 Verdict for a Denied Job Accommodation
00:49:15
27. Sean Dormer and Spencer Bryan – Groundbreaking $4M Verdict in Jail Suicide
00:53:58
26. Kylie Schmidt and Nicole Quintana – Landing $400,000 for Flight Paramedic's Ear Injury
00:57:53
25. Allison Pritchard and Phil Meinkoth – Surveillance, Strategy, and a $240K Slip-and-Fall Verdict
00:53:54
24. Courtney Samuel – Train Like Your Practice Depends On It
00:24:14
23. Alana Anzalone and Melanie Stuckey – Securing $2.2M for a Client with Herniated Discs
00:54:32
22. Melanie Sulkin – Turning a Low-Impact Crash into a $583K Verdict
00:55:01
21. Clay Wire and Jason Wesoky – The Contract Dispute with a “Mean Girls” Plot
00:58:06
20. Dan Lipman - $2M Verdict Redefines Physical Impairment in Sexual Assault Cases
00:51:57
19. Ross Ziev – $350,000 in Slip-and-Fall that Unfolded Like a Murder Mystery
00:50:05
18. Jason Jordan – Strategies for Winning, from Product Liability to “Felonious Killing”
00:55:48
17. Michael Born and Peter McCaffrey – Finding Fault in a High-Speed, No-Seatbelt Case
00:54:31
16. Sean Dormer and Tim Garvey – $2.51 Million Verdict After Multi-Car Crash in Denver
00:57:29
15. Jessica Schlatter, Paige Singleton, and Randy Manning–$19M Verdict on a Brain Bleed Case
00:54:22
14. Tim Galluzzi Interviews Kurt Zaner – ‘Nice Guy’ Wins $30M Verdict in Colorado Federal Court, Part 2
01:05:28
13. Tim Galluzzi Interviews Kurt Zaner – ‘Nice Guy’ Wins $30M Verdict in Colorado Federal Court, Part 1
01:01:41
12. Brad Holmes & Mike Blanton–$56M Product Defect Verdict Against Ford Motor Company
00:49:25
11. Nelson Boyle–Creating a Record and Preserving Issues for Appeal
00:44:42
10. Keith Fuicelli and John Lee – Trial Lessons Learned in Hindsight
01:01:26
9. Glenn Fair and Emily Jamieson – How to Make the Defense Expert Look Foolish
00:51:07
8. John Duguay - Triumph through Client Connection
00:57:54
7. Erin Hogan & Ben Flicker – Against All Odds: Intoxicated Pedestrian Without A Walk Signal vs. Car
00:54:53
6. Ed Lomena - Zero Property Damage to a Million Dollar Verdict
00:56:19
5. Alana Anzalone and Jerry Bowman–Navigating Adverse Facts and Addiction in a Motorcycle Collision Case
00:52:16
4. Dan D’Angelo and Tyrone Glover – The Winning Trifecta: Investigation, Voir Dire, and Vestibular Component in an mTBI Case
01:00:33
3. Kevin Cheney & Tim Galluzzi – Mastering “Impairment” Damages
01:02:25
2. Laura Browne and Sean Dormer – Mastering a $2.4M Case Against State Farm in Federal Court
00:59:50
1. Peter Anderson – Unveiling the Spirituality, Tactics, and Triumphs of a Truck Accident Trial Attorney
00:48:24
trailer Welcome to Colorado Trial Lawyer Connection
00:00:22