Speaker:
00:00:08
Today's guest on
2
:
00:00:09
MeteoScientific's The Business of LoRaWAN
is Doctor Matthew Patrick,
3
:
00:00:12
a physicist, data scientist and long time
contributor to the Helium ecosystem,
4
:
00:00:17
whose work spans LoRaWAN, Meshtastic
and some truly unconventional deployments,
5
:
00:00:21
including high altitude balloons
and experimental satellite concepts.
6
:
00:00:25
In this conversation,
7
:
00:00:26
we dig into a question that comes up more
and more in the community.
8
:
00:00:29
If Meshtastic exists,
why do we still need LoRaWAN?
9
:
00:00:33
Matthew breaks down the fundamental
architectural differences between the two,
10
:
00:00:36
where each one excels
and why they're often misunderstood
11
:
00:00:39
as competing technologies
rather than complementary tools.
12
:
00:00:42
We also explore real world
trade offs around scale, battery
13
:
00:00:45
life, infrastructure,
and then get into some forward
14
:
00:00:48
looking ideas like bridging Meshtastic
and LoRaWAN for remote sensor deployments,
15
:
00:00:52
and even using Lora based networks
in stratospheric and orbital projects.
16
:
00:00:56
This episode is sponsored
by the Helium Foundation
17
:
00:00:57
and is dedicated
to spreading knowledge about LoRaWAN.
18
:
00:01:00
You can use the publicly available
global LoRaWAN and discussed
19
:
00:01:03
in this episode through the Medio
Scientific Console to try it yourself.
20
:
00:01:06
Visit metsci.show/console.
21
:
00:01:09
Now let's dig into the conversation
with Doctor Matthew Patrick.
22
:
00:01:14
Doctor Matthew
Patrick, welcome to the show, dawg.
23
:
00:01:17
Thank you very much. Thanks for having me.
24
:
00:01:19
I'm psyched to talk to you.
25
:
00:01:20
Every time I talk to you,
I learn something and be
26
:
00:01:23
I am reminded of how
well someone can teach something.
27
:
00:01:27
So I'm super excited for you
to come on here today
28
:
00:01:29
and teach us a little bit about this
Meshtastic vs LoRaWAN business.
29
:
00:01:32
Thank you for making the time.
30
:
00:01:34
Yeah. Of course.
31
:
00:01:34
Thanks for having me.
32
:
00:01:35
So, basically what I wanted to talk about
today was this comes off of a talk
33
:
00:01:39
that I gave at the helium IoT
working group a couple of weeks back,
34
:
00:01:43
and it stemmed
out of a couple of conversations
35
:
00:01:46
which are happened in community
more and more.
36
:
00:01:48
And basically
the frame of the conversation
37
:
00:01:50
is something along the lines of,
okay, we have this new project.
38
:
00:01:53
It's an open source project.
39
:
00:01:55
It's called Meshtastic.
40
:
00:01:56
Why do we care about LoRaWAN anymore?
41
:
00:01:59
And I think for a lot of reasons, the
I see why people start thinking this way.
42
:
00:02:04
And I think that fundamentally
it's a little bit misguided.
43
:
00:02:06
And so I wanted to take this opportunity
to go through a couple of,
44
:
00:02:10
couple of examples of why
different Lora based technologies,
45
:
00:02:14
they can solve similar problems
to what LoRaWAN solves,
46
:
00:02:17
but it's not always exactly
the same thing.
47
:
00:02:19
And in this case in particular,
there are drastically different use cases
48
:
00:02:23
that they cover.
49
:
00:02:24
There's also an opportunity for
some overlap here and some cool projects,
50
:
00:02:28
but at the end of the day,
it's important to know, you know,
51
:
00:02:31
if if all you have is a hammer, right?
52
:
00:02:33
Everything looks like a nail.
53
:
00:02:35
So it's important to know right tool
for the right job
54
:
00:02:37
for anyone in the audience
who's not familiar.
55
:
00:02:40
If you've been following Nick's podcast,
you know all about LoRaWAN,
56
:
00:02:43
all about the industrial applications
that at the end of the day,
57
:
00:02:46
it's the most basic level.
58
:
00:02:47
What LoRaWAN is really about
is enabling order of magnitude
59
:
00:02:51
thousands of sensors to communicate
using very low power over
60
:
00:02:56
very long distances and send infrequent
small amounts of data to the internet.
61
:
00:03:01
So we're talking things like temperature
sensors,
62
:
00:03:04
trackers, impact sensors
that kind of thing.
63
:
00:03:07
The design of LoRaWAN has always been
from the beginning to enable
64
:
00:03:11
these industrial use cases,
and it predates Meshtastic by quite a bit.
65
:
00:03:16
So what Meshtastic is, on the other hand,
is it's relatively new.
66
:
00:03:20
So we're talking maybe five years ago
or so to the first real beta
67
:
00:03:24
starting to come out personal messaging.
68
:
00:03:27
It's not really a service.
69
:
00:03:28
It's an open source firmware and software
and some devices
70
:
00:03:32
that you can use to shoot text messages
back and forth over the same
71
:
00:03:36
physical radio
that the LoRaWAN sensor series.
72
:
00:03:39
And I think this is fundamentally
where a lot of the confusion can come in,
73
:
00:03:42
because the devices that you use
when you're learning about
74
:
00:03:45
LoRaWAN are oftentimes either
similar to or literally identical
75
:
00:03:49
to some of the supported devices
that are used by the Meshtastic project.
76
:
00:03:54
And what Meshtastic original mission
was, was to go and say,
77
:
00:03:58
okay, we've got maybe five guys, ten guys
who are going skiing
78
:
00:04:01
or hiking or paragliding
or anything like that,
79
:
00:04:05
and we want to make it so that they don't
have to carry around walkie talkies.
80
:
00:04:09
We want to be able to make it
so they can send short text messages,
81
:
00:04:11
including tactical information
82
:
00:04:13
like positions in particular,
but also maybe sensor data
83
:
00:04:17
and text back and forth
without any underlying infrastructure.
84
:
00:04:21
And in order to accomplish this,
they use a mesh
85
:
00:04:25
algorithm,
basically where every node on the network.
86
:
00:04:28
So every device that there's five guys
or has
87
:
00:04:31
it could receive
and it can transmit packets.
88
:
00:04:33
And if you've got a situation
where you've got to see
89
:
00:04:36
two people who want to communicate,
90
:
00:04:38
but they don't have a line of sight
to each other,
91
:
00:04:40
maybe there's a hill in between
or something.
92
:
00:04:42
What mesh tactic does is
it bounces the signal off any available
93
:
00:04:46
intermediary node to get from A to B.
94
:
00:04:49
Well, it does this really well.
95
:
00:04:50
This is the critical difference
between Meshtastic and LoRaWAN.
96
:
00:04:54
In LoRaWAN we have these things called
gateways, which are these big radios.
97
:
00:04:58
They're connected directly to the internet
most of the time anyway, and they suck
98
:
00:05:02
in all the packets that they can receive
concurrently across multiple channels.
99
:
00:05:07
There is no relaying packets.
100
:
00:05:08
The intention is that you
send one from your sensor.
101
:
00:05:11
It goes straight to the internet.
102
:
00:05:12
Dunn sensor goes back to sleep.
103
:
00:05:14
This is done for two reasons.
104
:
00:05:16
The first is to conserve battery life.
105
:
00:05:18
You can't have in LoRaWAN
106
:
00:05:20
anyway, a whole bunch of sensors
that are just on all the time.
107
:
00:05:23
The point is, normally that you want
to put a battery in the thing,
108
:
00:05:26
and then that's the battery
for the lifetime of the device.
109
:
00:05:28
Or at the very least it's changed really.
110
:
00:05:30
The second part is that in LoRaWAN
the focus is really on
111
:
00:05:33
industrial applications.
112
:
00:05:35
So we're talking like a warehouse
that needs to track a thousand assets,
113
:
00:05:39
that kind of thing.
114
:
00:05:40
Every gateway needs to be able to service
just an absolute ton of devices.
115
:
00:05:45
And in order to do this,
you don't have this kind of inter packet
116
:
00:05:48
relay
going on that you have in Meshtastic.
117
:
00:05:50
The real limitation of a mesh system
118
:
00:05:54
is that at the end of the day,
most of the devices have to be on most
119
:
00:05:58
of the time because they need to listen
to relay the packets.
120
:
00:06:01
This is absolutely perfect.
121
:
00:06:03
If you've got,
122
:
00:06:04
you know, a scenario like I outlined,
where you've got people who are hiking
123
:
00:06:07
and they're just going to have
something in their pocket
124
:
00:06:09
which is going to be on all day,
and then they'll recharge it
125
:
00:06:11
or change the batteries at night.
No problem.
126
:
00:06:14
When we've got devices
that need to be in the field
127
:
00:06:17
for a super long amount of time,
like years, even, you can't
128
:
00:06:20
you can't do this in the increasing range
that you get
129
:
00:06:23
is outweighed by the decrease
in battery life.
130
:
00:06:27
So there's kind of a kind of a trade off
here.
131
:
00:06:29
There's one other really critical,
important difference, which is, you know,
132
:
00:06:33
I mentioned that LoRaWAN serves
thousands of devices concurrently.
133
:
00:06:37
Meshtastic.
134
:
00:06:38
The big mesh infrastructure projects
that people have been setting up
135
:
00:06:41
in their cities,
which are super cool, by the way,
136
:
00:06:43
anyone who's interested
absolutely encourage you to take a look
137
:
00:06:46
at some of the various open source,
Meshtastic maps
138
:
00:06:49
that people have been putting up.
139
:
00:06:51
The Bay area has an amazing
like multiple hundred node system,
140
:
00:06:55
and they're using different
channels. It's super cool stuff,
141
:
00:06:58
but the reason
that they're using different channels
142
:
00:07:01
is because after you hit about 100 devices
or 200 devices or so,
143
:
00:07:05
the mesh network starts to fall over
because people are just talking over
144
:
00:07:08
each other all the time.
145
:
00:07:09
You can picture being in a crowded room
if you've got ten people in there.
146
:
00:07:14
It's not so bad to pick out
different parts of the conversation
147
:
00:07:17
if people are speaking up all the time.
148
:
00:07:19
But if you go into a place
or:
1000
149
:
00:07:23
if you don't have some way
150
:
00:07:24
to coordinate that traffic, it
just none of it gets to it.
151
:
00:07:27
So the magic number for Meshtastic
is around 100 for LoRaWAN,
152
:
00:07:31
because of the fundamentally different
design sits at around:
2000
153
:
00:07:35
Those are the two main differences
between the technologies that I wanted to.
154
:
00:07:39
I wanted to kind of bring forward.
155
:
00:07:40
That being said, there are some overlaps.
156
:
00:07:43
There are some there's some definite
overlaps between the two projects.
157
:
00:07:46
One of them is that
the hardware is nearly identical.
158
:
00:07:49
A gateway is, notwithstanding,
a piece of node hardware.
159
:
00:07:52
If you're familiar with lower Ram
and you want to explore Meshtastic,
160
:
00:07:56
probably 90% of the time
you're going to be able just to drop
161
:
00:07:59
the Meshtastic firmware
straight onto that thing and have it work.
162
:
00:08:02
Check out Meshtastic.org
for a list of the supported targets.
163
:
00:08:06
The radio is the same,
so it's really just a software difference.
164
:
00:08:10
The other thing that I was hoping we could
maybe talk a bit about was how you build
165
:
00:08:14
effective bridges between, you know,
these two communities there they have
166
:
00:08:18
they have pretty different interests,
but they use the same hardware.
167
:
00:08:21
And I've found personally
that they attract, similar like minded
168
:
00:08:25
crowd of people. Right.
169
:
00:08:26
You're you're radio enthusiasts.
170
:
00:08:28
You're less on the industrial side
for Meshtastic, of course,
171
:
00:08:32
but the people who are interested in
one tend to be interested in the other.
172
:
00:08:35
And I'd be super, super interested
in your perspective on how you could maybe
173
:
00:08:40
like, from a community perspective,
how we could bring more of these guys
174
:
00:08:43
together instead of this perception
that we're fighting against each other?
175
:
00:08:47
Yeah, I do see at first glance that
176
:
00:08:51
there's like, oh, Meshtastic is better
than LoRaWAN or LoRaWAN is better.
177
:
00:08:54
Like, it's just a maybe it's
what is really needed
178
:
00:08:57
is more conversations like this.
179
:
00:08:58
We say there's sources for courses.
180
:
00:09:00
There's there's tools for jobs.
181
:
00:09:02
And in some places
182
:
00:09:03
if you don't have LoRaWAN coverage
and you're going backcountry skiing
183
:
00:09:06
and you want to talk to your five buddies,
don't bother with the LoRaWAN.
184
:
00:09:10
You know, if you're on the factory floor,
185
:
00:09:12
we don't don't really need Meshtastic
there.
186
:
00:09:14
Can you walk me through
a couple of these bridge ideas
187
:
00:09:18
that you've
you've talked about in the past?
188
:
00:09:20
Yeah. Sure thing. I'd be happy to.
189
:
00:09:22
So one of them, and I think this is
maybe the most low hanging fruit
190
:
00:09:25
is remote
sensor deployments like weather stations.
191
:
00:09:28
So one of the really cool
applications of LoRaWAN
192
:
00:09:32
that that I'm most familiar with is
you've got maybe an agricultural
193
:
00:09:35
operation, a farm or something,
or you've got a bunch of sensors.
194
:
00:09:39
To some description,
weather is a great example.
195
:
00:09:41
You put them in a super, super
remote location where there is no internet
196
:
00:09:45
nearby.
197
:
00:09:45
Most of the time this is fine
if you use a network like helium,
198
:
00:09:49
which has incredible or run coverage, odds
are you're going to hit a gateway.
199
:
00:09:53
But if you're in a situation
where you can't, then things
200
:
00:09:56
get exponentially more complicated
really quick.
201
:
00:09:59
You've gotta find a way to get that
traffic off of RF and to the internet.
202
:
00:10:04
The Meshtastic
can be really useful for this
203
:
00:10:06
because the nodes are so low power,
generally speaking,
204
:
00:10:10
that you can put a really cheap node
with a really small solar panel
205
:
00:10:13
in the vicinity of your sensor, like say,
on the top of the nearby mountain
206
:
00:10:17
or a nearby hill or a building
and relay that traffic using Meshtastic.
207
:
00:10:22
And one of the things
I think could be really useful
208
:
00:10:24
is if we could have a bridge that could
receive Meshtastic packets and say, hey,
209
:
00:10:28
I got all these mesh packets. Here
they are from your sensors.
210
:
00:10:31
Can I send that off? Over.
211
:
00:10:32
Go learn Run Gateway
to get it to the internet.
212
:
00:10:34
Meshtastic is out of the box.
213
:
00:10:37
Not 100% optimized
for this kind of internet based traffic.
214
:
00:10:41
They use an mQTT server,
but the traffic is
215
:
00:10:45
largely unencrypted
or essentially unencrypted.
216
:
00:10:48
Since everybody shares
217
:
00:10:49
the same key on the public channel,
it ultimately can go off to the internet.
218
:
00:10:53
But a lot of the nodes are configured
themselves to either not do that
219
:
00:10:56
or to do it.
220
:
00:10:57
Uplink only, which is a real difference
between the LoRaWAN infrastructure
221
:
00:11:00
that, well, doesn't have an SLA
or anything
222
:
00:11:03
is designed to do bidirectional traffic
to the internet.
223
:
00:11:07
So I think it could be really interesting
if we could have a way
224
:
00:11:11
to build LoRaWAN gateways
that could receive Meshtastic packets,
225
:
00:11:15
so that if you're in
one of these situations
226
:
00:11:17
where you don't
have a perfect line of sight to a sensor,
227
:
00:11:20
you can maybe use this intermediary hop
in order to get where you need to go.
228
:
00:11:24
That's one of them.
229
:
00:11:25
The second one.
230
:
00:11:26
And this this touches
a little bit on a talk that I gave to,
231
:
00:11:29
the IoT working group a few weeks back. Is
232
:
00:11:32
LoRaWAN
233
:
00:11:33
networks
are growing, and they have this incredible
234
:
00:11:36
global reach,
and they're all in the unlicensed stance.
235
:
00:11:40
And there's this incredible opportunity
now brought on by companies like Space-x
236
:
00:11:46
to do satellite projects,
which are inherently risky and expensive.
237
:
00:11:50
But the price has been coming down
so much over the last few years.
238
:
00:11:53
It's it's not even funny.
239
:
00:11:56
There's a whole community of people who do
Lora based satellites using basically
240
:
00:12:00
the ham radio frequencies on Lora point
to point project name is Tiny Gascon.
241
:
00:12:05
It's for tiny ground station.
242
:
00:12:07
It's really cool.
243
:
00:12:08
And what what this community has done is
they've set up a bunch of receivers
244
:
00:12:12
using Lora hardware.
Same kind of hardware.
245
:
00:12:14
So you use on Meshtastic
or for a LoRaWAN node.
246
:
00:12:17
But all that they do
is they receive packets
247
:
00:12:19
from these low-Earth orbit satellites
people have sent out,
248
:
00:12:21
and then they relay them to the internet.
249
:
00:12:23
You know what
I think would be really cool?
250
:
00:12:25
And what could be an interesting
opportunity to bridge these two worlds
251
:
00:12:28
is if you had a satellite project that
implemented some version of Meshtastic,
252
:
00:12:33
right now, aside from 1 or 2 long shore
commercial operations, Lacuna Space,
253
:
00:12:38
this one of them, swarm, was before
they bought out by space.
254
:
00:12:41
I don't know if it's still operating.
255
:
00:12:43
The satellite constellations they use
Lora are either amateur satellites,
256
:
00:12:46
the beacon only,
or they're these commercial things
257
:
00:12:50
that haven't haven't
fully been implemented yet.
258
:
00:12:52
I think it'd be really cool
if you could build a Meshtastic satellite
259
:
00:12:55
that could relay traffic, but use LoRaWAN
for the distributed ground station
260
:
00:12:59
for the downlink.
261
:
00:13:00
And I'm working in the background
on maybe getting a project
262
:
00:13:04
like that off the ground.
263
:
00:13:05
I'm really excited about it.
264
:
00:13:07
For listeners,
you might also be excited about that.
265
:
00:13:10
Is there a good way for them
to reach out and contact you?
266
:
00:13:13
Absolutely.
267
:
00:13:14
So you can find me on the Helium Twitter.
268
:
00:13:17
I'm a member of the IoT working group.
269
:
00:13:19
Usually I'm hanging out on discord.
270
:
00:13:21
You can always find me on
Nick Hawks Gristle Kings discord.
271
:
00:13:24
My name is Star Watcher.
272
:
00:13:26
Goes way back to my helium days.
273
:
00:13:28
You can you can ping me over there.
274
:
00:13:30
And if you see one of my testing
high altitude balloon projects
275
:
00:13:35
beckoning weird things over Meshtastic
in different countries, then that's.
276
:
00:13:38
That's probably me too.
277
:
00:13:41
Yeah,
I probably should have started this off,
278
:
00:13:43
but I always get so excited
just to basically listen to your dog,
279
:
00:13:47
because tell me a little bit
about the helium or the LoRaWAN
280
:
00:13:50
and Meshtastic work that you've done.
281
:
00:13:52
So basically,
my background way back in the day was I
282
:
00:13:56
did a lot of space physics research
using high altitude balloons.
283
:
00:14:00
So stratospheric balloons that you would
you would send up,
284
:
00:14:03
and then we would take X-ray pictures
of the northern lights.
285
:
00:14:06
And my research was on mapping out
basically the number of the number of what
286
:
00:14:11
and the number of particles that come in
and swirl around, and the northern
287
:
00:14:15
lights over Canada, where I live,
the way I got involved in LoRaWAN
288
:
00:14:19
was that we needed a downlink system
for all of these balloons.
289
:
00:14:22
It's incredibly difficult.
290
:
00:14:23
These things can fly for days.
291
:
00:14:24
They can cover hundreds of kilometers.
It's a challenge.
292
:
00:14:27
And while we were doing way back was
we were paying hundreds of dollars
293
:
00:14:32
every single flight, use an iridium
satellite modem in order to basically make
294
:
00:14:36
a phone call like an analog phone
call, and send data over it, which works.
295
:
00:14:41
It functioned,
but more than half the power budget for
296
:
00:14:45
this thing was taken up by that iridium
iridium satellite modem.
297
:
00:14:49
It drew, you know, at around five volts,
easily a couple of amps, steady state.
298
:
00:14:55
And so the the whole payload
was just lined with batteries, which,
299
:
00:14:59
which were just to power this modem.
300
:
00:15:01
And then I found
301
:
00:15:02
and this was maybe around 2020
when things really started taking off.
302
:
00:15:06
I found this project called helium,
which is Lower Man.
303
:
00:15:08
And I hadn't heard of that before,
and I bought this board off.
304
:
00:15:12
It was
I think it was a go team or something.
305
:
00:15:15
One of the Esp32 Lora boards
everyone uses. Yep.
306
:
00:15:18
And I was sending packets immediately
over like tens of kilometers
307
:
00:15:22
within the city because the infrastructure
had been set up for it
308
:
00:15:25
and it it cost pennies.
309
:
00:15:27
So we switched over all of our flights
to these things, saved a ton of mass,
310
:
00:15:31
really simplified the whole operation,
and saved a ton of cost as well.
311
:
00:15:36
Just by using these Lora radios
and these distributed ground stations.
312
:
00:15:40
So that's that's
kind of how it all got started for me.
313
:
00:15:42
And then I took some of that experience
and spent some years working for helium.
314
:
00:15:46
Now Nova Labs, helping
them build out their their infrastructure
315
:
00:15:50
and do do the data science associated
with that.
316
:
00:15:53
The Meshtastic stuff
came a little bit later.
317
:
00:15:55
I was sitting having lunch
with an engineering friend of mine
318
:
00:15:58
one day, and we we basically we said,
is there any reason that we couldn't have
319
:
00:16:02
the equivalent of a small satellite either
running LoRaWAN or running Meshtastic,
320
:
00:16:08
that sits at a constant altitude
and just goes from that and around
321
:
00:16:12
and around the world,
322
:
00:16:13
there are ways
that you can set these balloons up
323
:
00:16:15
so that you don't you can't generally
get them back, but you can park them
324
:
00:16:18
at 15 or so kilometers,
and they sit in the jet stream.
325
:
00:16:22
And it turns out that this totally works.
326
:
00:16:24
So I threw together a tiny Meshtastic node
that was solar powered and put it on.
327
:
00:16:30
It's called a super pressure balloon.
328
:
00:16:32
It's basically a take on a weather balloon
that it stops
329
:
00:16:35
rising past a certain point,
330
:
00:16:36
so it doesn't just go up, burst,
and then land,
331
:
00:16:38
and you pick the thing up off the ground,
it gets stuck.
332
:
00:16:41
It's a little tricky to pull off a lot of
a lot of variables to get exactly right.
333
:
00:16:44
But when you do it,
334
:
00:16:46
I think the record right now is
the guy's got one
335
:
00:16:48
that's been going around the world
for over a year now.
336
:
00:16:51
It's on its like 30th lap,
which is which is crazy.
337
:
00:16:54
That's my Meshtastic one.
338
:
00:16:56
We had launched it and it was
it was so disappointing.
339
:
00:16:59
I was absolutely crushed by this
because this thing was so hard to build.
340
:
00:17:03
Flight looked great.
341
:
00:17:04
And then the antenna broke off
right after it got off the ground.
342
:
00:17:07
And you can't get it back.
You can't really get it back.
343
:
00:17:09
You get one one chance at this.
344
:
00:17:11
So I, I tracked it for maybe 20,
30km or so
345
:
00:17:15
and then then didn't receive the signal.
346
:
00:17:17
I thought, well, that's, that's a wrap.
347
:
00:17:18
And what am I going to do now? Right.
348
:
00:17:20
But two weeks later,
I get a random message
349
:
00:17:23
from somebody on Reddit
and they said, I don't understand this.
350
:
00:17:27
There's this balloon with this weird name,
351
:
00:17:29
and I think I called it
Kirby three Kirby the Pokemon.
352
:
00:17:32
It just seemed to set right.
353
:
00:17:34
Okay, needed a call sign for this thing.
354
:
00:17:36
It was over the UK
and they had just received
355
:
00:17:39
this random packet in the middle of the UK
on the right frequency,
356
:
00:17:43
and it was relaying packets
from all over the place there.
357
:
00:17:46
It was crazy because I sent this thread
and I said, oh my God,
358
:
00:17:49
this is something that I set off weeks ago
and you're telling me it
359
:
00:17:52
actually survived it actually worked
and it did even worth a busted antenna.
360
:
00:17:56
Someone was able to pick it up,
which kind of got me thinking.
361
:
00:17:59
If that little experiment works so well,
I wondered whether it would be possible
362
:
00:18:03
to send more of these things.
363
:
00:18:04
Like you could imagine
sending 10 or 20 of them.
364
:
00:18:07
They're not very expensive,
365
:
00:18:08
and trying to set up what's like,
what's the price of that thing
366
:
00:18:11
all in, I mean,
including that the balloon is cheap.
367
:
00:18:13
You get these things for $2.50
from Alibaba.
368
:
00:18:16
These days,
the little balloons are nothing
369
:
00:18:18
bored with the Raspberry Pi Pico
and then any off the shelf Lora chip.
370
:
00:18:22
You know, 510 bucks.
371
:
00:18:24
The tricky part was the firmware.
372
:
00:18:26
So as this thing goes around the world,
right, it crosses different Lora regions.
373
:
00:18:30
And so you need to be smart
about sending your frequency to the
374
:
00:18:33
the new one that you
show up in based on the GPS.
375
:
00:18:36
But once you've
376
:
00:18:37
got that down,
it seems to work really well.
377
:
00:18:40
And so have you sent up another one or.
378
:
00:18:41
No, it was just too tricky to do it
the second time.
379
:
00:18:43
We just haven't gotten to it.
380
:
00:18:45
I have sent up two since then
and neither of them has worked,
381
:
00:18:48
and I am 90% sure it's because I switched
to using a different Lora chip
382
:
00:18:52
without a temperature compensated
oscillator, and I think it froze.
383
:
00:18:56
But we're going to go back
to the old design
384
:
00:18:58
and see whether we can get this working
with the new, new iteration of Meshtastic.
385
:
00:19:02
And for this project in particular,
what I'd love to do is have two modes
386
:
00:19:07
where the device boots up
when it gets some sun on the solar panels.
387
:
00:19:10
It can be a Meshtastic repeater, but send
the downlink to laboratory over LoRaWAN.
388
:
00:19:15
You know, use all of those base stations,
just like I did in the past to track it,
389
:
00:19:18
and then maybe put it
on a community map or something
390
:
00:19:21
so that people would know
where these things are,
391
:
00:19:23
whether they could connect to them,
and they're up at 15km high.
392
:
00:19:27
So it's 15,000m, let's see.
393
:
00:19:30
And planes are flying at 35,000ft,
which is 10,000m.
394
:
00:19:34
So these are well above
where planes are flying generally.
395
:
00:19:37
Yeah, exactly.
396
:
00:19:38
And that's that's one of the main concerns
when you're doing ballooning stuff.
397
:
00:19:41
Right. It's worth
spending a couple of minutes on that.
398
:
00:19:44
Back in the day when we were flying this
399
:
00:19:46
with those iridium modems,
these things weighed kilograms.
400
:
00:19:48
And it doesn't matter
where they are in the sky.
401
:
00:19:50
You got to make sure that the airplanes
know where they are and how to avoid them.
402
:
00:19:54
The cool thing about Lora and LoRaWAN is
how miniaturized you can make everything.
403
:
00:19:58
The total mass of that one that I sent
it worked was less than ten grams.
404
:
00:20:03
All what?
405
:
00:20:04
Absolutely like negligible payload mass.
406
:
00:20:06
You build these things stupid lights
407
:
00:20:08
that you can hit that equilibrium
where that balloon doesn't pop.
408
:
00:20:11
So it's it's really
409
:
00:20:14
think of releasing a party balloon.
410
:
00:20:16
That's that's more than what
this thing is.
411
:
00:20:18
I think the other thing is,
and this this may
412
:
00:20:21
help, is I've been looking at these
AR VR glasses.
413
:
00:20:24
I ordered a pair of these Myntra
glass glasses.
414
:
00:20:27
They have the camera and the microphone
on them and they're saying they're 49g.
415
:
00:20:31
So I weighed my regular glasses
that I wear and they were 29g.
416
:
00:20:35
And so what you're telling me is that this
thing that's doing all of this messaging
417
:
00:20:40
is it travels around the world, weighs
less than a third of a pair of eyeglasses.
418
:
00:20:45
Exactly, exactly.
419
:
00:20:46
It's it's the hardest part.
420
:
00:20:48
You've got to get the software right,
421
:
00:20:49
but also the hardware can weigh
almost nothing.
422
:
00:20:51
If you're going to do this
this long duration flight.
423
:
00:20:54
So the risk of these things is is very,
very low.
424
:
00:20:56
And the amateur radio
425
:
00:20:57
guys have been doing this for years,
and there's never really been an incident
426
:
00:21:01
except for one, you know,
haven't taken down a jetliner yet earlier.
427
:
00:21:04
There's never
there's never been, closets of,
428
:
00:21:07
you know, slamming into an airplane
or anything like that.
429
:
00:21:10
But one was shot down and I actually knew
the guy who'd had that happen.
430
:
00:21:13
So the amateur radio term for
these things is a pico balloon.
431
:
00:21:17
It's just the canonical term
people have invented for it.
432
:
00:21:21
This thing is made of mylar, which has
this metallic aluminum coating on it.
433
:
00:21:25
So they're not impossible
to see the radar.
434
:
00:21:28
And if anyone in the audience
435
:
00:21:29
remembers a couple of years back, there
was this really cool Chinese spy balloon.
436
:
00:21:34
It wasn't really a hoax. It was something
that was actually happening.
437
:
00:21:37
So right off the tail of that,
there was this immense intrigue.
438
:
00:21:41
Not really paranoia,
but I call it intrigue over,
439
:
00:21:44
you know, mysterious balloons
showing up in the middle of nowhere.
440
:
00:21:47
And there was this one,
there was a ham radio version of that.
441
:
00:21:50
So it was sending telemetry out over
just HF, just tracking where it was.
442
:
00:21:54
Flew over northern Saskatchewan, I believe
443
:
00:21:56
it was one of the Canadian provinces
middle of nowhere.
444
:
00:22:00
And somebody picked this up on radar.
445
:
00:22:02
And the US sent in F-22 Raptor
446
:
00:22:04
up to shoot this thing down
with Sidewinder.
447
:
00:22:08
And they did. And that's very compelling.
448
:
00:22:10
The way that this was figured out
449
:
00:22:12
was that exactly the way
that this was figured out
450
:
00:22:15
was that this guy was in our
Pekoe ballooning group CIO channel.
451
:
00:22:19
They said, hey, guys,
something really weird happened.
452
:
00:22:20
Like it was working great.
It was the middle of the day.
453
:
00:22:23
And then here's
where the last telemetry was.
454
:
00:22:25
As I'm someone just post a copy
of the news article that shows the X marks
455
:
00:22:29
the spot where this airplane was the
that shot the thing down.
456
:
00:22:32
I think we we probably used
maybe a $400,000 missile or something
457
:
00:22:36
to blow up a ham radio balloon
458
:
00:22:38
that may have cost the guy,
you know, in total, 10 or 20 bucks.
459
:
00:22:42
That sounds like America,
if that is that historic conduct warfare,
460
:
00:22:45
can you imagine working as,
you know, a pilot?
461
:
00:22:47
I guess in the military, this is a
completely different world than I live.
462
:
00:22:50
And and getting that call.
So please get going.
463
:
00:22:53
We need to go and take care of a UFO.
464
:
00:22:55
Go and go and shoot the thing
where you put slings and missiles
465
:
00:22:57
that exact like, exactly like there are
there are worse things to do, I guess.
466
:
00:23:02
No kidding.
467
:
00:23:03
Well, thanks so much for coming on.
468
:
00:23:04
It's always awesome to to hear it
so it's easy to get off on these tangents.
469
:
00:23:07
And I know we're going to talk
470
:
00:23:08
some more balloons off line here,
but thanks a ton for coming on and kind
471
:
00:23:11
clearing up the Meshtastic versus
LoRaWAN debate.
472
:
00:23:13
Thanks, dawg.
Yeah of course. Always a pleasure, Nik.
473
:
00:23:17
That's it for
this episode of The Business of Laurel.
474
:
00:23:20
And if you want to go deeper
and actually deploy devices,
475
:
00:23:23
the Médio Scientific
Console is the fastest way to do that.
476
:
00:23:27
And honestly, it's
also the best way to support the show.
477
:
00:23:31
When you use the console, you're not just
listening, you're participating
478
:
00:23:34
in the same real world LoRaWAN work
we talk about here every week.
479
:
00:23:38
You can get started with the free trial
480
:
00:23:40
at meteoscientific.com Huge
thanks to the sponsor of this show.
481
:
00:23:44
The Helium Foundation, for supporting open
LoRaWAN infrastructure worldwide.
482
:
00:23:49
Check them out at helium.foundation.
483
:
00:23:51
And if the show has been useful,
a quick rating or review on Apple Podcasts
484
:
00:23:55
or wherever you listen.
485
:
00:23:55
This really helps
486
:
00:23:56
people find it and helps the show grow
so we can help more people.
487
:
00:24:00
I'm Nik Hawks with MeteoScientific.
488
:
00:24:02
I'll catch you on the next episode.