Speaker:
00:00:08
Today's guest
2
:
00:00:09
on MeteoScientific's
The Business of LoRaWAN is Josh Douglas,
3
:
00:00:13
COO and co-founder of CPTI, a company
building perovskite
4
:
00:00:17
based energy harvesting designed to change
how we power connected devices.
5
:
00:00:21
We met at CES, where Josh showed me
a nanomaterial solar layer, thin enough
6
:
00:00:25
to go on almost any surface and capable
of harvesting energy from indoor light,
7
:
00:00:29
off angle light, and wavelengths
traditional silicon struggles to capture.
8
:
00:00:33
In this conversation, we talk about what
perovskites actually are,
9
:
00:00:36
why conventional silicon panels
leave energy on the table,
10
:
00:00:39
and how higher energy density
can unlock more frequent reporting,
11
:
00:00:42
additional sensing,
and even edge AI in LoRaWAN deployments.
12
:
00:00:46
We also get into the real world issues
lifetime limitations, commercialization
13
:
00:00:51
hurdles, and how CPTI is bridging the gap
from lab science to digital listings
14
:
00:00:55
and deployable hardware.
15
:
00:00:56
This episode is sponsored
by the Helium Foundation
16
:
00:00:59
and is dedicated
to spreading knowledge about LoRaWAN.
17
:
00:01:01
If you'd like to try Helium’s
publicly available global LoRaWAN for free
18
:
00:01:05
and support
the show, sign up at metsci.show/console.
19
:
00:01:09
Now let's dig in the conversation
with Josh Douglas.
20
:
00:01:13
Josh,
thanks so much for coming on the show.
21
:
00:01:15
Welcome. Thank you. Good to be here.
22
:
00:01:17
I'm excited to have you on.
23
:
00:01:18
We're going to talk about perovskite.
24
:
00:01:19
We met in Las Vegas at CES.
25
:
00:01:22
And you had
26
:
00:01:23
show me this pretty cool material
that I think of as like a solar panel.
27
:
00:01:26
You can maybe put on anything,
but I thought we'd start with the
28
:
00:01:29
tell me a little bit more about what
this stuff is, and why people in IoT
29
:
00:01:33
and LoRaWAN might want to pay attention
to it.
30
:
00:01:34
Totally. What this stuff is. So.
31
:
00:01:36
So what
what we're building at CTI is perovskite
32
:
00:01:39
based energy harvesting perovskite.
33
:
00:01:43
It's a family of materials.
34
:
00:01:44
It's really
35
:
00:01:45
a few different kinds of materials,
but it's most infamous for solar cell
36
:
00:01:49
spectrum for for photovoltaics
and current photovoltaics.
37
:
00:01:53
Current solar,
which I know you're quite used to.
38
:
00:01:55
Nick is really good at, I think, cheap.
39
:
00:01:59
Frankly, at current solar, it's
very cost efficient
40
:
00:02:03
and it's
kind of built this industry around it,
41
:
00:02:06
but it is is fairly inefficient
at actually harnessing energy.
42
:
00:02:11
It only is responsive
to basically one wavelength of light
43
:
00:02:16
and needs to absorb that light,
at a pretty direct angle.
44
:
00:02:20
It needs to be pretty spot on to capture
anything material, which I see you nodding
45
:
00:02:25
your head.
46
:
00:02:25
So this is a problem
that I know that you see.
47
:
00:02:28
Yeah.
48
:
00:02:28
Furthermore, current silicon pretty much
needs to be adhered on to glass.
49
:
00:02:33
That's how you really, really harness it.
50
:
00:02:35
So what that means is, as you deal
with, with a cheap certainly,
51
:
00:02:39
but a pretty inefficient material
that has pretty extreme limitations.
52
:
00:02:44
What we're working with, with perovskite,
really, it really changes that dynamic.
53
:
00:02:48
And so as we talk about and I was I can
54
:
00:02:50
I can speak more to what's so cool
about perovskite a few things.
55
:
00:02:54
One is it can really harness
any kind of light.
56
:
00:02:58
So whether it's outdoor light
like in the sun,
57
:
00:03:01
whether it's cloudy
light or even indoor light,
58
:
00:03:04
we can turn all of that
to energy at any incident angle.
59
:
00:03:07
So even if the sun's rising or setting,
even if it's off angle light,
60
:
00:03:11
if it's been bouncing off
a few different substances,
61
:
00:03:14
we can still capture that and turn
that into energy, which is amazing.
62
:
00:03:17
And on top of that, perovskite, as I know
we discussed it's a nanomaterial.
63
:
00:03:21
So it's thinner than a human hair.
64
:
00:03:24
It's very energy dense.
65
:
00:03:26
We can put it really get on any surface
with with minimal added mass.
66
:
00:03:31
Okay.
67
:
00:03:31
So let me make sure I'm understanding that
if I think of solar panels
68
:
00:03:34
and I put up a bunch on these kind of off
grid LoRaWAN gateways
69
:
00:03:37
is it's a big, big piece of glass,
you got to be careful with it.
70
:
00:03:40
Yeah. Relatively inefficient.
71
:
00:03:42
I mean, we're more efficient than when
we started with solar panels in the 50s.
72
:
00:03:45
But still, I forget what it is at now.
73
:
00:03:47
Maybe 20% ish, maybe less. Yeah.
74
:
00:03:50
And then a little bit heavy.
75
:
00:03:52
And then it has to have the sun
hitting it directly.
76
:
00:03:54
So I've always had to basically match the,
the angle to the latitude
77
:
00:03:57
is what I think it
or the way I think of doing it.
78
:
00:03:58
And so with this stuff with perovskite,
you don't have to do any of those
79
:
00:04:03
and you can put it on anything.
80
:
00:04:04
Is there?
I mean there's got to be a downside.
81
:
00:04:05
Is this thing super expensive.
82
:
00:04:07
Like what's the
why would I not use perovskite.
83
:
00:04:09
Why you would not use it is
because it just really hasn't been ready.
84
:
00:04:13
I wouldn't
call it a new class of material,
85
:
00:04:14
but it's one
that's been in the pipeline for a while.
86
:
00:04:18
It's been in the works for some time.
87
:
00:04:20
I did it work on for off site in undergrad
and really it's it's
88
:
00:04:24
come a long way since then
and namely in its performance,
89
:
00:04:29
its efficiency, its lifetime,
all these different things.
90
:
00:04:32
It's it's improved.
91
:
00:04:34
And so the reason why
you haven't used perovskite.
92
:
00:04:36
Yeah.
Just because it hasn't been ready yet.
93
:
00:04:38
We're now beginning to see companies
really commercialize perovskite.
94
:
00:04:43
CPI really leading the way.
95
:
00:04:46
You know what what I will say
to your point is that cost, because it's
96
:
00:04:49
a newer material goes on that
same industry around it like the silicon,
97
:
00:04:53
but because it's an inert material,
it's pretty easy to process that.
98
:
00:04:57
Over time, you will see the the cost fall
dramatically.
99
:
00:05:01
Okay. And what's the cost comparison?
100
:
00:05:03
Now, if I'm buying a whatever,
a little solar panel that I might use
101
:
00:05:06
for an IoT device. Yeah,
a couple inches by a couple inches. Yeah.
102
:
00:05:09
What does it
103
:
00:05:09
same thing look like as far as the energy
that I need to match it in perovskite.
104
:
00:05:14
Yeah, totally.
105
:
00:05:14
So so right now if you say buy or sell off
106
:
00:05:18
digitally, for example, or aero,
our modules are on a surplus
107
:
00:05:23
energy as an be, you know, like like what
we're capturing above and beyond.
108
:
00:05:27
We are getting you anywhere from 5 to 20%
109
:
00:05:31
more energy, more efficiency.
110
:
00:05:34
What that means in practice,
because as you said, most cells currently
111
:
00:05:38
are on the order of 10 to 20% efficient.
112
:
00:05:41
So, so so we are again
depending on your form factor on
113
:
00:05:45
on your latitude or your conditions,
we are upwelling the energy that you're
114
:
00:05:49
that you're able to harness
so we can drive pretty awesome gains
115
:
00:05:53
in energy, which allows you to record
more frequently, which allows you to pack
116
:
00:05:59
more sensing on your node,
which really opens up
117
:
00:06:03
all these different application spaces,
which we haven't seen before.
118
:
00:06:07
I mean, the obvious one is AI
is this giant energy sucking machine.
119
:
00:06:11
What's that? I've got I've got it. Yeah.
Oh yeah.
120
:
00:06:13
That's like, oh, wow, man,
this guy's really been in the closet now.
121
:
00:06:16
So to this AI piece,
it seems like this would fit
122
:
00:06:20
well into the narrative by saying, hey,
you can either use a smaller panel
123
:
00:06:24
because this stuff is more efficient,
or use the same size panel
124
:
00:06:26
and kind of replace what you've got,
and now you've got more energy to use.
125
:
00:06:30
Is that the general storyline here,
126
:
00:06:31
or is there additional pieces to it
that I might be missing just because I'm
127
:
00:06:34
coming into this
for the first time? Totally.
128
:
00:06:36
I mean, you really hit the nail
on the head, which is that
129
:
00:06:39
energy is critical.
130
:
00:06:40
And in many cases
we are stuck with batteries.
131
:
00:06:44
We're stuck with outdated solar.
132
:
00:06:47
And so we've we've really grown
used to these energy constraints.
133
:
00:06:51
Right?
134
:
00:06:52
I like to think of
to go back a year or two or a few decades
135
:
00:06:56
to the Walkman versus the iPod. Right.
136
:
00:06:59
And how the unlock with the iPod
was that you
137
:
00:07:02
carry all these songs in your pocket
that you couldn't before,
138
:
00:07:05
and most people at first
didn't see a need for that.
139
:
00:07:08
Right.
140
:
00:07:09
They thought that carrying
all these albums around in your pocket,
141
:
00:07:12
what's the point
now where you take it for granted? Right?
142
:
00:07:15
That's how we feel with energy
and that we've we don't know how much
143
:
00:07:19
we've been limited because we think in a,
in a very different framework.
144
:
00:07:24
We want to change that paradigm. Right.
145
:
00:07:26
And we know when it comes
to certainly latest, greatest
146
:
00:07:31
machine learning AI,
that's a big driver, right.
147
:
00:07:34
When we talk about edge compute
and we talk about physical AI,
148
:
00:07:38
these are very real, real tailwinds
that we're seeing across Lora,
149
:
00:07:41
that we're seeing across devices,
something that would be a big tailwind.
150
:
00:07:45
But just even in general, right?
151
:
00:07:47
I mean, even if you aren't
adding compute on the edge,
152
:
00:07:49
you want to collect more data,
you want to create.
153
:
00:07:52
And I mean, I'm
I'm based in Silicon Valley,
154
:
00:07:54
so I'm in this world like, you know,
we want to create these role models.
155
:
00:07:57
We want to add autonomy.
156
:
00:07:59
You want to create these frameworks
such that you can add intelligence
157
:
00:08:04
all over the place,
which will take a lot of sensing, a lot of
158
:
00:08:08
data on the C, a lot of computer places,
and all these things take more energy.
159
:
00:08:14
The irony, of course, with all this,
Nick, is, we are surrounded by energy,
160
:
00:08:18
the form of light.
161
:
00:08:19
There's tons of energy all around us,
162
:
00:08:22
but we don't harness it
due to the limitations of our materials.
163
:
00:08:26
Yet this is this is how we figure out CPI,
164
:
00:08:29
and this is what we're really looking
for it to bring to the lower community.
165
:
00:08:34
Okay, cool.
166
:
00:08:34
And if I think about it,
you can't be just a material science nerd.
167
:
00:08:39
You've got to put the whole thing together
and be able to say, hey,
168
:
00:08:42
this is what this material is,
this is how it works.
169
:
00:08:44
And then here's the business case
170
:
00:08:45
and here's how you buy it,
and here's how you install it.
171
:
00:08:47
There's a bunch of different things
you have to do.
172
:
00:08:50
You've worked at Apple in the past.
173
:
00:08:52
So hopefully some of that
174
:
00:08:54
like hey, this thing has to work
easily got imbued into you.
175
:
00:08:57
Talk me through the bridging
the gap between this kind of cool material
176
:
00:09:01
that works and then getting it deployed
in the real world at scale.
177
:
00:09:04
Yeah. That's critical.
178
:
00:09:06
That is what holds back
many exciting innovations across
179
:
00:09:11
science is how to actually bridge
that gap.
180
:
00:09:15
Right?
181
:
00:09:15
Even for for me,
throughout my my own career.
182
:
00:09:19
Again,
I did work on perovskites undergrad.
183
:
00:09:22
I went in thinking I would go off
and get a PhD in material science
184
:
00:09:25
to save the world.
185
:
00:09:26
Learning about perovskites
moved me away from that, not because I
186
:
00:09:30
lacked faith in the material,
but just because I saw firsthand.
187
:
00:09:35
While there was great work happening
in the lab, the actual translation,
188
:
00:09:39
the actual movement from lab to
189
:
00:09:42
market was still unsolved
and still very murky.
190
:
00:09:45
And that's again,
that's how I think about it at CTI.
191
:
00:09:48
And we we have the the opportunity to work
192
:
00:09:51
with these really game
changing materials in perovskites,
193
:
00:09:55
having these best in class chemistries,
really working on the cutting edge.
194
:
00:09:59
And there are so many places to
to put it right.
195
:
00:10:02
And I mean,
we could be on a different podcast
196
:
00:10:05
talking about the opportunity
for perovskites in space on satellites,
197
:
00:10:08
the opportunity
for perovskites on the walls of buildings,
198
:
00:10:13
or of course, in solar farms,
the classic polar application.
199
:
00:10:16
All these markets
have their their own merits and demerits.
200
:
00:10:20
And I'd be happy to talk about those
if you're curious.
201
:
00:10:22
But what what makes us so excited
about again,
202
:
00:10:25
like sensing in LoRaWAN
is that it's energy where you need it.
203
:
00:10:29
And that's where we can make a difference.
204
:
00:10:32
And so for us, it's a matter
of both understanding the material
205
:
00:10:35
but also understanding of the spaces
in which we could apply it, understanding
206
:
00:10:39
how customers could adopt it,
how they can integrate it in,
207
:
00:10:42
and really making it as easy as possible
for people to adopt.
208
:
00:10:46
We don't want to add all these barriers
and gateways.
209
:
00:10:49
We think a lot about how to distribute,
how to get this into people's hands,
210
:
00:10:53
or how to talk about this
in the first place, such that we can get
211
:
00:10:57
people excited and educated
and not be some research project.
212
:
00:11:01
I think about the the guests who have
come on Julian Berlin over at Volvo or,
213
:
00:11:05
you know, from
214
:
00:11:06
from that kind of really high level, like,
hey, these guys are rolling this out
215
:
00:11:09
across giant campuses
to Robert Boggs in Germany, who's
216
:
00:11:14
rolling out in his village to Dean Marsh
in the UK with those guys are listening.
217
:
00:11:18
Where would they go to get perovskite
for their next project and see, like, hey,
218
:
00:11:22
is this going to work?
219
:
00:11:23
Can you just ordered on digit key
220
:
00:11:24
and it's like a swap out with your current
solar panel.
221
:
00:11:27
Is it some different weirdo voltage?
222
:
00:11:29
Is it some like what are the things
that they're going to get the gotcha from?
223
:
00:11:33
And then one of the things where I'm like,
what did I know about this before?
224
:
00:11:35
Yeah, yeah, definitely.
225
:
00:11:37
It's a bit as I was saying prior,
Nick is just that this is a new material
226
:
00:11:42
and that it's really taken time
for industry to meet up with the science
227
:
00:11:48
and to find a way to, to commercialize it
at a we're leading the pack.
228
:
00:11:53
We have undergone certifications.
229
:
00:11:55
We've undergone the testing needed such
that folks can use this.
230
:
00:11:59
We're being listed on the key on arrow.
231
:
00:12:02
All the places that you would want
to purchase are these things, you know,
232
:
00:12:06
and and that's something that
that we think about differently
233
:
00:12:09
than other people is just really trying to
to short that leap.
234
:
00:12:13
Of course, folks are always
235
:
00:12:14
welcome to reach out to us
via our website in the interim.
236
:
00:12:18
And this is just Icom.
237
:
00:12:20
Sibeko. Exactly.
238
:
00:12:22
Dukkha. Okay. Yeah.
239
:
00:12:23
And then when it comes to the voltages,
240
:
00:12:25
the voltages, everything, it's very,
very similar to, to silicon.
241
:
00:12:29
That's so different.
242
:
00:12:29
The thing that, again, really sets
perovskite apart is being able to capture
243
:
00:12:35
different wavelengths of light and
different energies at different angles.
244
:
00:12:39
And so generally with silicon, right,
like on the of curve of the energy
245
:
00:12:44
that it's capturing and what you're using,
generally you really only need
246
:
00:12:48
to capture the peak loads of energy
because it's a it's
247
:
00:12:52
a very steep drop off with silicon
perovskite,
248
:
00:12:55
we actually are more efficient
and lower light conditions.
249
:
00:12:58
And so we are able to harness more energy
and basically makes
250
:
00:13:03
makes more sense to harness energy
at a, at a wider range of voltages.
251
:
00:13:08
And currents and wattage and so on.
252
:
00:13:10
So it's really fast.
253
:
00:13:11
The only, the only difference is not like
this is a whole different paradigm.
254
:
00:13:15
You know, it, it can still work
with the same kind of control.
255
:
00:13:18
Or is the same kind of mix.
256
:
00:13:21
It's just that due to the material
you are inclined to
257
:
00:13:25
to harness more of the energy
and use it for your devices.
258
:
00:13:29
The interesting.
259
:
00:13:30
What's the simplest possible case
where someone would say like, hey,
260
:
00:13:33
I'm just going to swap out this stuff.
261
:
00:13:35
I've got 100 or 1000 or ten or whatever
it is.
262
:
00:13:37
Yeah. What would you say? Like,
hey, just start with this.
263
:
00:13:39
That way you get your feet wet
without getting in over your.
264
:
00:13:42
Yeah, at your neck. Totally.
265
:
00:13:43
That's it. Right.
266
:
00:13:44
Is trying it out.
267
:
00:13:46
And in many cases
you don't need a controller.
268
:
00:13:48
In many cases you can just swap this in
for for your silicon panels.
269
:
00:13:53
If you have some sort of PMI, C or mPPT
that's converting
270
:
00:13:57
voltage that that will will harness
much of the energy as well.
271
:
00:14:01
And then over time there's there's
obviously ways to optimize.
272
:
00:14:04
We're actually working
273
:
00:14:05
on our own reference designs on our own
like dev kids to again
274
:
00:14:09
make it easier for people to adopt
and do harness the RG.
275
:
00:14:13
But there are tons of ways
to optimize and perfect
276
:
00:14:16
and to harness every micro what you know,
but not every application needs that far.
277
:
00:14:22
We don't all need micro watts,
although some of us I say
278
:
00:14:25
that this is the world that does. Yeah,
yeah yeah yeah, for sure.
279
:
00:14:28
I know that with my little balloon project
280
:
00:14:31
we're trying to harvest every piece we can
because it's such a tiny little board.
281
:
00:14:33
Yeah. Let's see, is there
are there any big downsides?
282
:
00:14:35
Like how long does it last?
283
:
00:14:37
Does this thing just crumble
in five years?
284
:
00:14:38
And it's like,
oh, it's cheaper and better,
285
:
00:14:40
but you got to replace every five years.
286
:
00:14:41
Are there any other kind of big downsides
that folks should know about before
287
:
00:14:45
they go racing off to buy out
the entire stock of Digital Hero?
288
:
00:14:48
Yeah. You guys have. Yeah. Of course.
289
:
00:14:50
So so that has been the limiting factor
for perovskite is lifetime.
290
:
00:14:55
So what I was really yeah.
291
:
00:14:57
So back in the day
when when I was a researcher,
292
:
00:15:01
it was on the order of about a month
or two was the lifetime of perovskite.
293
:
00:15:05
Wow. Yeah.
294
:
00:15:05
It was very, very quick.
295
:
00:15:07
It would degrade very quickly.
296
:
00:15:09
Now it's up to around ten year
lifetime okay.
297
:
00:15:13
And then we are best in class at around
15 years lifetime.
298
:
00:15:16
So okay.
299
:
00:15:18
So this is more than enough
for most applications.
300
:
00:15:22
And obviously to
we are often sitting alongside a battery.
301
:
00:15:27
Right. We are harvesting energy
to work with a battery.
302
:
00:15:30
Most batteries are lasting for five
maybe ten years.
303
:
00:15:33
So you don't need to last for 20 years
if the battery is going to fail in ten.
304
:
00:15:37
And anyway, yeah, yeah, that makes sense.
305
:
00:15:40
It's interesting.
306
:
00:15:40
I didn't know
is so short at the start of it.
307
:
00:15:42
Although, yeah, I would say
308
:
00:15:43
if you're listening to this, don't
remember the one month thing.
309
:
00:15:46
Remember the 15 year thing.
310
:
00:15:48
That's the key here.
311
:
00:15:49
I always thought it was cool when people
ask about how long the solar panels last.
312
:
00:15:52
We say
313
:
00:15:53
we don't know because the first ones
314
:
00:15:54
that went up in the late
50s are still running.
315
:
00:15:56
Yeah, but, as you said,
if you're trying to charge a battery
316
:
00:15:59
that died 40 years ago, then who cares?
317
:
00:16:02
Yeah. Okay.
318
:
00:16:03
Well, well, that's like
also the dirty secret of silicon
319
:
00:16:07
of basically every other celebrity. True.
320
:
00:16:10
Is that they also have a lifetime
in a similar range,
321
:
00:16:13
maybe the lasting for 20 years
with only 10% degradation,
322
:
00:16:18
but they are covered under warranty
for 30 years
323
:
00:16:22
for whatever is needed to bank a project
to finance a project.
324
:
00:16:26
And what what happens is that these solar
producers, they sign these warranties,
325
:
00:16:33
thinking
326
:
00:16:33
and planning for the price to drop so much
327
:
00:16:36
that once the customer comes
328
:
00:16:39
knocking and collect on the warranty,
that it'll cost them
329
:
00:16:43
very little to to substitute
out the panels for the blue ones.
330
:
00:16:47
So even though they say 30 years,
that's just a marketing gimmick.
331
:
00:16:52
It's a very funny industry, Lives learn.
332
:
00:16:55
It's it's a nice little gamble
for a business to play.
333
:
00:16:57
Like, hey, by the time we replace these,
it's going to be cheaper.
334
:
00:16:59
Don't worry. Exactly, exactly. Ripping.
335
:
00:17:01
Well, Josh, thanks so much for carving out
time. I know you're busy.
336
:
00:17:03
I know the whole founding thing
is not like a 9 to 5.
337
:
00:17:07
It's more like 12 to 12.
338
:
00:17:09
So thanks for coming on
and talking to us about, Prescott.
339
:
00:17:11
Of course. Thank you for having us.
340
:
00:17:15
That's it for
this episode of The Business of LoRaWAN.
341
:
00:17:18
If you want to go deeper
and actually deploy devices,
342
:
00:17:21
the MeteoScientific
console is the fastest way to do that.
343
:
00:17:24
And honestly, it's
also the best way to support the show.
344
:
00:17:28
When you use the console, you're not just
listening, you're participating
345
:
00:17:31
in the same real world LoRaWAN work
we talk about here every week.
346
:
00:17:35
You can get started with the free trial
at meteoscientific.com.
347
:
00:17:39
Huge thanks to the sponsor of this show,
the Helium Foundation,
348
:
00:17:42
for supporting open LoRaWAN
infrastructure worldwide.
349
:
00:17:46
Check them out at helium.foundation
and if the show has been
350
:
00:17:50
useful, a quick rating or review
on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen.
351
:
00:17:53
This really helps
352
:
00:17:54
people find it and helps the show grow
so we can help more people.
353
:
00:17:57
I'm Nik Hawks with MeteoScientific.
354
:
00:17:59
I'll catch you on the next episode.