Artwork for podcast Reading Under the Covers: A Romance Novel Podcast
3 Books to Read If You Like Elsie Silver
Episode 18613th March 2025 • Reading Under the Covers: A Romance Novel Podcast • Under the Covers Book Blog
00:00:00 00:09:05

Share Episode

Shownotes

If you love Elsie Silver but have read all her books, don’t worry—I’ve got you covered! In today’s episode of Reading Under the Covers, a romance novel podcast, I’m sharing three amazing backlist romance books that capture the same small-town charm, swoony cowboys, emotional depth, and high-stakes equestrian drama that we love from her books. Whether you’re into grumpy single dads, rodeo cowboys, or intense horse-riding competition, these recs will keep your TBR full.

Want even more recommendations? I’ve got nine books on my blog post breaking these down by theme! Check it out here: 👉 Read the Full Guide

Books Mentioned in This Episode:

If You Love Equestrian Romance:

  • Leaping Hearts by Jessica Bird (J.R. Ward) - A strong-willed heroine, a broody ex-champion trainer, and a high-stakes horse-riding competition. Perfect for fans of: A Photo Finish & Off to the Races. Grab this book on Amazon

If You Love Small-Town Cowboy Romance: 

  • Long Hard Ride by Lorelei James - A rodeo cowboy hero, a small-town heroine stepping out of her comfort zone, and SO. MUCH. HEAT. Perfect for fans of: Flawless & Heartless. Grab this book on Amazon

If You Love Grumpy Single Dads:

  • Down Too Deep by J. Daniels - A heartbroken widowed dad, a caring single mom, and the ultimate found-family romance. Perfect for fans of: Heartless (hello, Cade lovers!). Grab this book on Amazon

💬 Let’s Chat!

What’s your favorite Elsie Silver book, and which of these recommendations are you adding to your TBR? Let me know in the comments, on the blog, or on social media!

Thanks for listening!

🎧 Enjoyed this episode? Leave a review! It helps other romance readers find the podcast. 💖

These notes contain affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.

Visit the Blog: https://www.underthecoversbookblog.com/ and https://www.mysterylandia.com

Stay Connected:

Email: Send your inquiries and feedback to hello@underthecoversbookblog.com

Get Involved:

Want to start a podcast? Check out my host.

Transcripts

Francesca:

Welcome to Reading Under the Covers, a romance novel podcast

2

:

where we chat, fangirl, and maybe

even swoon over our latest reads.

3

:

I'm Francesca from Under the Covers Book

Blog, and today I am talking about what

4

:

to read if you like Elsie Silver but

you've already read all of her books.

5

:

So if you're listening to this,

chances are that you're a little bit

6

:

obsessed with Elsie Silver's books.

7

:

And honestly, it makes total sense.

8

:

She does small town romance

really, really well.

9

:

And whether it's the rugged cowboys,

the single dads, grumpy heroes, or

10

:

that high stakes equestrian drama,

she is just the perfect mix of

11

:

steam, heart, and emotional depth.

12

:

But what happens when you've blazed

through all of Chestnut Springs, Gold

13

:

Rush Ranch, and Rose Hill, and you

need something else that hits the same?

14

:

That's what today's episode is all about.

15

:

I have categorized books by three major

themes when it comes to Elsie Silver's

16

:

books, and I actually have a blog post

that goes into more book recommendations.

17

:

I'm going to be talking about three,

so I have picked one book from each of

18

:

those major themes, and you can find

two more books from each theme on our

19

:

blog at underthecoversbookblog.Com.

20

:

I'm going to leave that linked in

the description down below as well.

21

:

So you can go and check out

even more recommendations.

22

:

But today here on the podcast, I wanted

to focus on books that are backlist

23

:

titles, they're oldies and goodies.

24

:

And honestly, I don't think I see

them recommended enough, especially

25

:

as it relates to books that you

would read after Elsie Silver.

26

:

So we're here to discover some new

favorites and I've got a nice mix

27

:

of new and old as well on the blog.

28

:

So if you're ready for that,

let's just get started.

29

:

Now the first category is if

you love the equestrian romance.

30

:

So let's start there because if you loved

Gold Rush Ranch, then you already know

31

:

that the addictive horse riding and high

stakes competition and all of that tension

32

:

between the riders, it's so exciting.

33

:

And the book that I'm going to

propose that you read if you

34

:

like that is Leaping Hearts by

Jessica Bird, which is actually J.

35

:

R.

36

:

Ward as well.

37

:

So Leaping Hearts was actually J.

38

:

R.

39

:

Ward's debut novel.

40

:

For those that don't know, she is very

popular right now writing paranormal

41

:

romance under the pen name J.

42

:

R.

43

:

Ward, but she actually started off

writing contemporary romances, and

44

:

because of her life experiences, they

usually do revolve around equestrian

45

:

romances and some other things like that.

46

:

I actually read this several

years ago when I had already

47

:

binged through all of the J.

48

:

R.

49

:

Ward books that I already love,

obviously the Black Dagger Brotherhood,

50

:

but I was pleasantly surprised to find

that I actually really did enjoy a

51

:

lot her contemporaries and especially

Leaping Hearts was really, really good.

52

:

Now, what is Leaping Hearts about?

53

:

It follows AJ Sutherland.

54

:

She's an ambitious young woman that's

trying to prove herself in the very

55

:

ultra competitive world of show jumping.

56

:

She sets her sights on an

unproven stallion, one that

57

:

no one else believes in.

58

:

And she is determined

to make him a champion.

59

:

But there's a catch because

of course, there always is.

60

:

And to pull this off, she needs

the help of Devlin McLoud, he's a

61

:

grumpy, brooding, former champion who

walked away from the sport after a

62

:

career ending accident, and he wants

nothing to do with training again.

63

:

But AJ is not the type

to take no for an answer.

64

:

So of course, the more time they spend

together as they train the stallion,

65

:

the more the sparks start flying.

66

:

So why is this a perfect choice

to read if you love Elsie Silver?

67

:

We have a strong willed heroine who

refuses to back down, a hero who's a

68

:

little bit broken but secretly soft, a

high stakes competition and that rider

69

:

and trainer dynamic, and a little bit of

that I hate you but I want you energy.

70

:

I think if you loved A Photo Finish

or Off to the Races, then this

71

:

book is going to give you all the

same heart pounding tension and

72

:

the swoony, slow burn chemistry.

73

:

Now, if you're more into the small

town cowboy romances from Elsie

74

:

Silver's book, then I need to

introduce you to my personal queen

75

:

of cowboy romance, Lorelei James.

76

:

I know a lot of you discovered Elsie

Silver through the Chestnut Spring

77

:

series and now basically Cowboy

Romance is your entire personality.

78

:

I'm not judging you because same

here, except for me that entry to

79

:

Cowboy Romance and my Cowboy Romance

era was thanks to Lorelei James.

80

:

Now Lorelei James has a couple of

series that you can dive into, but

81

:

I'm going to give you the OG series,

which is the Rough Riders series.

82

:

I suggest you start here if you

binge through all the many many

83

:

books that are in that series.

84

:

She does have another series, it's

called the Blacktop Cowboys series,

85

:

which I also really enjoy as well, but

I'm telling you, go with the original.

86

:

These are much spicier books, and they

have a great sense of found family

87

:

as well as family vibes as well.

88

:

So, what is the first book

in the Rough Rider series?

89

:

It's called Long Hard Ride.

90

:

It kicks off one of the hottest, wildest

cowboy romances you're ever going to read.

91

:

So it follows Channing Kincaid.

92

:

She is a small town girl who's

been playing it safe her whole life

93

:

until she decides that she's ready

to cut loose and have an adventure.

94

:

And that adventure is joining a group of

rodeo cowboys on the road as they travel

95

:

from town to town competing in bull

riding and chasing the adrenaline rush.

96

:

And then we have Colby McKay.

97

:

Remember when I told you that

we're focusing on a family here?

98

:

Well, the McKay family you're gonna

get to know really, really well.

99

:

Colby is a hot, dominant, take no BS kind

of cowboy and he makes it very clear that

100

:

Channing is not just along for the ride.

101

:

He wants her and he's

not shy about showing it.

102

:

Now this book is steamy.

103

:

When I say steamy, it is so, so steamy.

104

:

It's wild.

105

:

It's packed with all of the

small town cowboy drama that

106

:

you could possibly ask for.

107

:

And why is it perfect to read

If You Love Elsie Silver?

108

:

Well, we have our rodeo cowboy hero.

109

:

He is confident and slightly

cocky but with lots of charm.

110

:

A small town heroine that is

breaking out of her comfort zone.

111

:

Plenty of found family within

the rodeo crew themselves.

112

:

And so much heat.

113

:

Like, if you thought that

Heartless was steamy, this one?

114

:

So much further, if you're craving

more bull riding cowboys like

115

:

Rhett from Flawless, then this is

the book that you need to pick up.

116

:

And believe me when I tell you

that this series just gets better

117

:

and better and better and better.

118

:

And finally, let's talk about the

single dad romance because Elsie

119

:

Silver has done some incredible,

grumpy, emotionally unavailable

120

:

single dads like Cade from Heartless.

121

:

And sometimes you just need a

romance that hits that perfect mix of

122

:

broody hero and found family vibes.

123

:

Am I right or am I right?

124

:

So if you're looking for those grumpy

single dads, then Down Too Deep by J.

125

:

Daniels is the book that

you need to add to your TBR.

126

:

It follows Nathan Bell.

127

:

He's a widowed single dad

who is completely drowning in

128

:

grief and the responsibility

of raising his daughter Marley.

129

:

He's lost, overwhelmed, and

doesn't know how to connect with

130

:

her until he meets Jenna Savage.

131

:

She's a single mom of twins

who knows exactly what it

132

:

takes to love and nurture kids.

133

:

Now when Jenna offers to help take care

of Marley while Nate figures things out,

134

:

he reluctantly agrees, and of course

it doesn't take long before he realizes

135

:

that he's completely falling for her.

136

:

Now, why do I think that this is perfect

for you to read if you love Elsie Silver?

137

:

Well, we have our single dad hero, who

is emotionally closed off, but so soft

138

:

underneath, and a strong, caring heroine

who brings him back to life, the heavy

139

:

focus on family healing and second

chances, which is also perfect, and

140

:

major found family energy with this one.

141

:

If you love a good slow burn

romance with deep emotional payoff,

142

:

then this book is just perfect.

143

:

It's got tension, heart, a grumpy dad

that's learning how to love again.

144

:

I mean, who is not swooning

right now for that?

145

:

And those are three incredible books

that are just going to scratch that

146

:

Elsie Silver itch, whether you're into

the equestrian romance, a grumpy cowboy,

147

:

or a single dad who need a little bit

of help opening up their hearts again.

148

:

But if you're still looking for more,

don't worry, I've got you covered.

149

:

I do have nine books total, these

included, on the blog, and I'm going to

150

:

leave that guide linked in the description

down below so you can check that out

151

:

as well and get more recommendations.

152

:

As always, if you want to expand your

TBR even further, you can always head to

153

:

the blog at underthecoversbookblog.Com

154

:

and check out all of our recommendations.

155

:

And of course, make sure that you

subscribe to our free Substack so you

156

:

don't miss any of the content that

we post across all of our platforms.

157

:

If you're looking for more mysteries

and thrillers, you can also visit

158

:

our sister blog, mysterylandia.com.

159

:

And if you're watching this on YouTube,

don't forget to like this video,

160

:

subscribe to the channel and hit that bell

notification so you never miss an update.

161

:

Now it's your turn.

162

:

Let me know what's your favorite

Elsie Silver book and which of these

163

:

recommendations you're going to be adding

to your TBR if you haven't read them yet.

164

:

I'd love to hear from you

leave me a comment on the

165

:

blog, on YouTube or wherever.

166

:

You can find all of our socials in

the description box down below as well.

167

:

Thanks so much for hanging with me today.

168

:

I hope you find something amazing to read

and I will see you guys in the next one.

169

:

Bye!

Links

Chapters

Video

Watch

More from YouTube

More Episodes
186. 3 Books to Read If You Like Elsie Silver
00:09:05
185. Dramione Fanfiction That Became Published Books
00:11:08
184. What to Read This Week | Book Releases – March 10-16, 2025
00:11:50
183. 3 Kindle Unlimited February 2025 Hidden Gems Favorites
00:15:14
182. New Romance & Mystery Books You Need to Read | March 3-9 New Releases
00:09:56
181. Mood Reading 101: How to Pick the Perfect Book Based on Vibes
00:14:31
180. New Romance Book Releases: Spicy Fairytale Retellings, College & Small-Town (Feb 27 - Mar 2)
00:13:16
179. Books That Celebrate Black Joy | Romance, Mystery & Fantasy
00:35:24
178. New Romance Book Releases This Week: February 17-23, 2025
00:17:29
177. Murder for Valentine’s – 9 Must-Read March 2025 Mystery Books
00:13:26
176. New Romance Books This Week (Feb 10-16, 2025)
00:10:33
175. Are These REALLY the Best 100 Romance Books? Our Hot Takes!
00:38:55
174. Must-Read Romance Book Releases This Week (Feb 3–9, 2025)
00:13:02
173. Bookish Tea: The TikTok Ban, AI-Written Books, & Where Bookish Creators Are Heading
00:48:14
172. Must-Read New Book Releases January 27 - February 2, 2025
00:10:38
171. My Favorite 2024 Kindle Unlimited Reads
00:25:54
170. Regency, Fantasy, Cozy Mystery: Romance Book Releases for January 20–26, 2025
00:09:56
169. New Fantasy Romance, Gothic, Thriller and more | New Releases for January 13 thru January 19, 2025
00:09:11
168. New Romance Releases You Need This Week! (January 6 - 12, 2025)
00:17:12
167. Most Anticipated Romance Books of 2025 | Upcoming Must-Read Releases
00:17:48
166. Romance New Releases: Spicy Fantasy, Cozy Paranormal, and YA Sports Romances – December 31, 2024
00:13:16
165. 8 Tips for Reading Goals You'll Actually Stick To
00:19:00
164. 5 New Books You’ll Love This Week (Dec 23-29, 2024)
00:12:41
163. 5 New Books You’ll Love This Week (Dec 16-22, 2024)
00:14:39
162. Black Dagger Brotherhood Re-Read: Dark Lover by J.R. Ward
00:39:36
161. Hot Off the Presses: 5 New Books You’ll Love This Week (Dec 9-15, 2024)
00:15:05
159. Romanceopoly 2025 Reading Challenge Announcement
00:14:49
158. Hot Off the Press: New Releases December 2 - December 8, 2024
00:14:56
157. Hot Off the Press: New Releases November 25 - December 1, 2024
00:14:07
155. Spicy Holiday Novellas and Holidays in LA with Kelly Reynolds
00:51:47
154. Hot Off the Press: New Releases November 18 - November 24, 2024
00:14:23
152. Holiday Gift Guide for Bookworms
00:18:00
151. Hot Off the Press: New Releases November 11 - November 17, 2024
00:14:46
150. Latest Kindle Unlimited Favorites - Sept and Oct 2024
00:24:43
149. Hot Off the Press: New Releases November 4 - November 10, 2024
00:11:08
147. Medical Romance Books with Laura | Romanceopoly 2024 Recommendations
00:21:21
146. Hot Off the Press: New Releases October 28 - November 3, 2024
00:18:03
144. Books Like the Mindf*ck series by S.T. Abby
00:23:43
143. Hot Off the Press: New Releases October 21 - October 27, 2024
00:21:58
141. 8 Most Anticipated Holiday Romances of 2024
00:24:50
140. Hot Off the Press: New Releases October 14 - October 20, 2024
00:14:45
138. Orc Romance Books with Becky from TSTL Podcast
00:32:44
137. Hot Off the Press: New Releases October 7 - October 13, 2024
00:10:49
135. Cozy Mysteries at the Bookstore - Romanceopoly Autumn Recs with Laura
00:28:22
134. Hot Off the Press: New Releases September 30 - October 6, 2024
00:12:04
132. Latinx Author Book Recommendations [Most on Kindle Unlimited]
00:20:54
131. Hot Off the Press: New Releases September 23 - 29, 2024
00:15:45
129. Kindle Unlimited Book Recommendations - August 2024
00:22:25
128. Hot Off the Press: New Releases September 16 - 22, 2024
00:14:37
126. All Time Best Witch Books (In My Opinion)
00:21:11
125. Hot Off the Press: New Releases September 9 - 15, 2024
00:09:01
123. Paranormal Arranged Marriage Fantasy Book Recommendations
00:17:05
122. Hot Off the Press: New Releases September 2 - 8, 2024
00:10:54
120. New Adult Sports Romance | Romanceopoly Recommendations
00:12:56
119. Hot Off the Press: New Releases August 26 - September 1, 2024
00:12:07
117. Captive Romance Books | Mafia Book Recs with Laura
00:28:05
116. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for August 19 - 25, 2024
00:09:02
114. July 2024 Kindle Unlimited Books
00:23:41
113. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for August 12 - 18, 2024
00:11:22
111. Best Books of 2024 So Far
00:37:37
110. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for August 5 - 9, 2024
00:13:32
108. Funny Urban Fantasies - City Lane Romanceopoly Recs
00:17:55
107. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for July 29 - August 4, 2024
00:10:06
105. Evolution of a Romance Reader with Ang from PNR Book Lovers
00:54:50
104. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for July 22 - 28, 2024
00:10:33
102. Southern Romance Books
00:19:48
101. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for July 15 - 21, 2024
00:11:18
99. Romanceopoly 2024 Mid Year Update
00:33:42
98. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for July 8 - 14, 2024
00:09:05
96. Announcement: Novel Nights
00:30:16
95. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for July 1 - 7, 2024
00:12:48
93. The Best Kindle Unlimited Books We Read in June 2024
00:28:10
92. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for June 24 - 30, 2024
00:12:22
90. Interview with Kristen Ashley
00:44:41
89. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for June 17 - 23, 2024
00:13:17
87. 💌 You've Got Mail 💌 Epistolary Penpal Romance Books | Romanceopoly Recommendations
00:16:05
86. Hot Off the Press: New Releases for June 10 - 16 2024
00:13:57
84. Summer Reading with Victoria from Bibliolifestyle
00:35:16
82. 🎪 Best Romance Books set at a Circus 🎪 Romanceopoly Recs
00:17:53
80. Vintage Romance Books with Cheyenne
01:03:22
79. Bridgerton Season 3 First Impressions
00:14:36
78. Asian Romance Authors You Should Read Right Now
00:21:53
76. Non-Greek Mythology Fantasy Books - Romanceopoly Recs
00:13:08
74. Meet the Podcasters
00:58:40
72. Love Lines to Lifelines - Romance Authors That Write Thrillers
00:12:53
70. Book Signing Tips with Laura from What to Read Next
00:41:18
68. trailer Reading Under the Covers - A Romance Novel Podcast Re-Brand Trailer
00:04:27
67. Hoopla & Libby Library Card Tips with Laura from What to Read Next Podcast
00:29:56
66. Soldier Street: Ex Military Romantic Suspense Set Outside of the US
00:13:18
65. Books to Read in Winter + Nostalgic Catch Up Edition
00:51:26
64. 2024 Reading Resolutions + Romanceopoly is Back!
00:21:42
1. Romanceopoly Reading Challenge - 2023 Announcement
00:12:59
28. Shield of Winter by Nalini Singh
00:46:45
27. Best (and Worst) Books of 2021
01:34:33
26. Heart of Obsidian by Nalini Singh
00:52:33
25. Tangle of Need by Nalini Singh + Psy/Changeling Novellas
00:54:13
24. Interview with Nalini Singh
01:10:40
23. Claimed by J.R. Ward
00:54:04
22. Interview with Juliette Cross and Funny Paranormal Recommendations
01:06:08
21. Kiss of Snow by Nalini Singh
00:56:42
21. Gladiator by Anna Hackett + Warrior Heroines
01:25:54
20. Play of Passion by Nalini Singh
00:41:22
19. Book Recommendations: Gemini
00:49:07
18. Bonds of Justice by Nalini Singh
00:50:45
17. Immortals After Dark Chat with Lit Wallflowers Podcast
01:21:50
16. Blaze of Memory by Nalini Singh
00:42:23
15. Book Recommendations: Taurus
00:59:04
14. Branded by Fire by Nalini Singh
00:56:44
13. Veronica's Dragon by Ruby Dixon + Dragon Shifter Recs
00:59:40
12. Hostage to Pleasure by Nalini Singh
00:55:19
11. Book Recommendations: Aries
01:03:29
10. Mine to Possess by Nalini Singh
01:02:48
9. Vampire Romance Recommendations with L.H. Cosway
01:08:32
8. Caressed by Ice by Nalini Singh
00:49:23
7. Book Recommendations: Pisces
00:57:19
6. Visions of Heat by Nalini Singh
00:43:03
5. Wicked All Night by Jeaniene Frost
01:01:55
4. Urban Fantasy Recommendations with Hailey Turner
00:43:20
3. Book Recommendations: Aquarius
00:53:20
2. Slave to Sensation by Nalini Singh
00:50:46
1. Season 2 of The Fangover is HERE!
00:42:43
31. Home for the Holidays by Jeaniene Frost
00:27:38
30. Wicked Bite by Jeaniene Frost
00:56:30
29. The (Alien) Nanny for Christmas by Amanda Milo
00:28:50
28. Shades of Wicked by Jeaniene Frost
00:40:49
27. Clean Sweep by Ilona Andrews
00:29:20
bonus EIT Readalong Announcement!
00:06:08
26. Into the Fire by Jeaniene Frost
00:31:23
25. Don't Hex and Drive by Juliette Cross
00:37:25
24. Bound by Flames by Jeaniene Frost
00:32:16
23. Serpent & Dove by Shelby Mahurin
01:04:24
22. Up from the Grave by Jeaniene Frost
00:35:52
21. Odd Thomas by Dean Koontz
00:31:10
20. Twice Tempted by Jeaniene Frost
00:46:38
19. The Jackal by J.R. Ward
00:39:22
18. Once Burned by Jeaniene Frost
00:40:53
17. Wicked Abyss by Kresley Cole
00:44:30
16. One Grave at a Time by Jeaniene Frost
00:33:51
15. Carnage by Sandra R. Neeley
00:35:44
14. This Side of the Grave by Jeaniene Frost
00:49:50
13. Edge of Darkness by Lara Adrian
00:37:13
12. Eternal Kiss of Darkness by Jeaniene Frost
00:46:13
11. Rhapsodic by Laura Thalassa
00:57:03
10. First Drop of Crimson by Jeaniene Frost
00:38:34
9. Marcun by Sadie Carter
00:18:28
8. Destined for an Early Grave
00:43:33
7. Fighting Destiny by Amelia Hutchins
00:56:48
6. At Grave's End by Jeaniene Frost
00:44:54
5. When He's Dark by Suzanne Wright
00:49:11
4. One Foot in the Grave by Jeaniene Frost
00:44:20
3. Iron and Magic by Ilona Andrews
00:39:00
2. Halfway to the Grave by Jeaniene Frost
00:28:03
1. Never Have I Ever
00:20:58
The Fangover Podcast Teaser
00:02:09