In this episode, Tracy examines the growing trend of Gentle Parenting through a biblical lens, showing how compassion without correction can miss God’s bigger plan for shaping a child’s heart.
--
The PursueGOD Family podcast helps you think biblically about marriage and parenting. Join Bryan and Tracy Dwyer on Wednesday mornings for new topics every week or two.
Find resources to talk about these episodes at pursueGOD.org/family.
Help others go "full circle" as a follower of Jesus through our 12-week Pursuit series.
Click here to learn more about how to use these resources at home, with a small group, or in a one-on-one discipleship relationship.
Got questions or want to leave a note? Email us at podcast@pursueGOD.org.
Donate Now
--
Gentle Parenting has gained significant popularity in recent years as a parenting philosophy rooted in empathy, emotional connection, and positive discipline. It’s roots come from Alfred AdlerAdvocates promote its compassionate, respectful approach to child-rearing as an alternative to authoritarian or punitive parenting styles. While aspects of gentle parenting align with biblical calls for kindness, patience, and love, there are significant theological and biblical concerns that challenge some of its foundational assumptions. This article explores the principles of gentle parenting, the underlying views about human nature, and examines where it diverges from biblical truth from an evangelical perspective.
The Principles of Gentle Parenting
At its core, gentle parenting emphasizes a few key principles:
- Connection Over Control: Gentle parenting prioritizes forming a strong emotional bond with the child over exerting control. It believes that a connected parent-child relationship is the foundation for healthy behavior, promoting cooperation rather than compliance based on fear.
- Empathy and Emotional Awareness: Gentle parenting encourages parents to understand and validate their children’s emotions. The idea is that emotional intelligence and self-regulation come through modeling empathy, not through punishment or suppression of emotions.
- Positive Discipline: Gentle parenting replaces punitive measures (like spanking or time-outs) with positive discipline. Misbehavior is viewed as an opportunity to teach and guide rather than punish. Natural consequences and open communication are favored over strict rules or punishments.
- Respect for Autonomy: This philosophy treats children as autonomous individuals deserving of the same respect as adults. Children are given choices and involved in decision-making processes, even from a young age, to foster a sense of independence.
- Modeling Desired Behavior: Parents are encouraged to model the behaviors they wish to see in their children. Instead of disciplining through authority, parents demonstrate patience, kindness, and self-control, expecting their children to learn by example.
Underlying Assumptions About Human Nature
The principles of gentle parenting rest on certain assumptions about human nature that, while appealing, often conflict with the Bible’s teachings on humanity’s fallen state and the need for discipline. Biblical parenting embraces the timeless truth of God’s Word instead of the changing ideas of popular culture. When evaluating Gentle Parenting, be sure to do it through the lens of the Bible.
1. Children: Inherently Good or Sinful?
One of the main assumptions behind gentle parenting is that children are inherently good or morally neutral. Misbehavior is often viewed as a result of unmet needs, developmental immaturity, or a lack of understanding. This view suggests that with enough nurturing, empathy, and guidance, children will naturally grow into compassionate, well-behaved individuals.
The Bible teaches that all humans, including children, are born with a sinful nature. Psalm 51:5 says, “Surely I was sinful at birth, sinful from the time my mother conceived me.” Romans 3:23 declares that “all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” While gentle parenting tends to see misbehavior as primarily situational or developmental, the Bible is clear that rebellion, defiance, and disobedience are manifestations of the sin nature present in all of us.
Proverbs 22:15 Folly is bound up in the heart of a child, but the rod of discipline drives it far from him
Therefore, while it is important to nurture and guide children, parents must also recognize the need for correction and discipline to address sin. Failing to acknowledge the sinful tendencies of children can lead to permissiveness and a neglect of the God-given responsibility to train children in righteousness.
2. Authority: Autonomy or Submission?
Another key assumption is that children are autonomous individuals whose choices should be respected as much as possible. Gentle parenting promotes the idea that children’s autonomy should be honored, and their opinions and preferences should be given weight, even from an early age. The focus is on collaboration rather than control.
The Bible calls for children to submit to their parents’ authority (Ephesians 6:1) and for parents to exercise authority in love. God has established the family with clear roles and responsibilities, and parental authority is part of His design for the family structure.
Ephesians 6:1 Children, obey your parents in the Lord, for this is right. 2 “Honor your father and mother” (this is the first commandment with a promise), 3 “that it may go well with you and that you may live long in the land.”
Gentle parenting, with its emphasis on collaboration and autonomy, can unintentionally undermine the biblical concept of authority, which teaches that children are to learn obedience and respect for their parents.
In contrast to the idea that children’s autonomy should be prioritized, Scripture instructs parents to “bring them up in the training and instruction of the Lord” (Ephesians 6:4). This involves not just nurturing but also setting clear boundaries and requiring obedience as part of spiritual formation.
3. Discipline: Cruel or Loving?
Gentle parenting operates on the belief that discipline should not involve punitive measures that cause pain, discomfort, or emotional distress. Instead of consequences that might bring short-term discomfort, gentle parenting advocates for teaching and guiding in ways that maintain the child’s sense of emotional safety and comfort.
The Bible consistently teaches that discipline, including corrective discipline, is an essential aspect of parenting. Proverbs 13:24 states, “Whoever spares the rod hates their children, but the one who loves their children is careful to discipline them.” Hebrews 12:6 affirms, “The Lord disciplines the one He loves, and He chastens everyone He accepts as His son.”
Discipline is a form of love and care, not cruelty. It helps children learn the consequences of sin and rebellion and points them toward godly behavior. Gentle parenting’s emphasis on avoiding punishment or discomfort at all costs can leave children without the necessary boundaries and correction they need to grow in wisdom and godliness.
“But misuse shouldn’t prevent right use. The presence of some dangerous drivers on the roads shouldn’t put a stop to all driving, and the existence of some abusive parents shouldn’t stop other parents from using punishment rightly”. Gospel coalition
Proverbs 3:11-12 My son, do not despise the Lord's discipline or be weary of his reproof, for the Lord reproves him whom he loves, as a father the son in whom he delights.
Takeaway
Gentle parenting offers a compassionate and empathetic approach to child-rearing that resonates with some biblical principles, such as kindness, patience, and love. However, from an evangelical perspective, its foundational assumptions about human nature, authority, and discipline fall short of the Bible’s teachings. Scripture teaches that children, like all humans, are born with a sinful nature and that discipline, including correction, is a vital part of their moral and spiritual formation.
While parents should always aim to model Christlike love and grace, they must also embrace their God-given authority to train, correct, and discipline their children. True biblical parenting incorporates both grace and truth, just as God deals with His children—with both lovingkindness and firm discipline.
