Artwork for podcast Systematic Geekology
Dunder Mifflin's Finest: A Deep Dive into Michael Scott
TJ Episode 46412th March 2026 • Systematic Geekology • anazao ministries
00:00:00 00:45:55

Share Episode

Shownotes

TJ Blackwell and Andy Walsh dive deep into the quirks and complexities of Michael Scott from "The Office", unveiling the layers behind this iconic character who often straddles the line between hilarity and cringe. They explore how Michael’s desperate need for friendship shapes his questionable management style, revealing that his antics stem from a tragic backstory filled with loneliness and a longing for connection. The duo shares their experiences with the show, discussing how Michael’s evolution reflects not only the growth of the character but also the changing dynamics at Dunder Mifflin. With a blend of insightful analysis and casual banter, they dissect Michael's relationships with iconic characters like Jim and Dwight while touching on the show's cultural impact. Listeners can expect a relaxed yet thought-provoking conversation that both challenges and celebrates the legacy of "The Office" and its unforgettable characters.

Michael Scott, the beloved yet cringe-worthy character from "The Office", takes center stage in this episode of Systematic Geekology, as TJ Blackwell and Andy Walsh dive into the complexities of his character. They kick things off by reminiscing about their personal connections to the show, highlighting how Michael, portrayed by Steve Carell, is the epitome of the Peter Principle – a classic case of being promoted to one's level of incompetence. In their laid-back banter, the hosts explore Michael's growth throughout the series, delving into how his early antics often bordered on inappropriate and cringe-worthy, making it hard for viewers to root for him right away. Yet, as they dissect his relationships with other characters, notably Jim and Dwight, they illustrate how Michael’s desperate need for friendship and acceptance drives his often misguided attempts at camaraderie. The conversation wanders into the influence of other characters on Michael's development, particularly Todd Packer, whose lack of scruples serves as a double-edged sword for Michael. Packer's toxic masculinity and crude humor highlight Michael's struggles with identity and leadership, as he tries to navigate the thin line between being a friend and a boss.

Blackwell and Walsh also touch upon the cultural impact of "The Office", noting its evolution from a mere sitcom to a cultural phenomenon that resonates with audiences even today. They emphasize how the show reflects the absurdities of office life, encapsulating the humor and heartbreak of striving for human connection in a corporate world. In wrapping up their insightful discussion, the hosts encourage listeners to reflect on their own experiences with office dynamics, all while playfully debating which Dunder Mifflin manager they would prefer to work under. With a mix of nostalgia, humor, and thoughtful analysis, this episode not only celebrates Michael Scott’s character but also prompts deeper questions about mentorship and the complexities of workplace relationships, making it a must-listen for both "The Office" aficionados and new fans alike.

Takeaways:

  1. Michael Scott, the quintessential cringe-worthy boss, embodies the Peter Principle as he showcases maximum incompetence while desperately seeking friendship and approval from his employees.
  2. The transformation of Michael Scott from an unlikable character to a more relatable figure is a testament to the show's growth and writing, making it a classic in American television.
  3. The relationship dynamics between Michael, Jim, and Dwight illustrate how contrasting personalities can influence personal growth and workplace camaraderie in unexpected ways.
  4. Despite his many flaws, Michael's character offers a humorous yet tragic exploration of loneliness and the lengths one might go to in order to connect with others.
  5. The Office's cultural impact is reminiscent of modern hits like Stranger Things, showing how certain shows can dominate conversations and become ingrained in popular culture.
  6. Michael Scott's journey emphasizes the importance of mentorship and the consequences of dysfunctional leadership styles, as he learns how to balance friendship and authority.

.

Be sure to check out our merch, find extra content, and become an official member of Systematic Geekology on our website:

https://systematic-geekology-shop.fourthwall.com/

.

Check out this year's annual theme, "The Faces Behind Us":

https://player.captivate.fm/collection/dd903597-98be-49ed-998c-5cdaf73b6af4

.

Check out other episodes with Andy:

https://player.captivate.fm/collection/c86f7a67-357b-4324-bf95-e42cedb9932a

.

Listen to every episode with TJ:

https://player.captivate.fm/collection/f4c32709-d8ff-4cef-8dfd-5775275c3c5e

Mentioned in this episode:

Check out our Fourthwall site for quite literally everything to do with our show!

All SG merch, extra content, our youtube page, SG memberships, tips / donations, etc. can all be found at this one convenient spot!

SG on Fourthwall

The Anazao Podcast Network

Be sure to check out the network website to see other podcasts trying to engage honestly with Scripture, Theology, Pop Culture, Martial Arts, Science, and more!

Anazao Podcast Network

Follow us on Instagram and BlueSky to keep up to date!

Follow our show on our socials to keep up to date and get some exclusive content and fun memes!

Systematic Geekology

Our show focuses around our favorite fandoms that we discuss from a Christian perspective. We do not try to put Jesus into all our favorite stories, but rather we try to ask the questions the IPs are asking, then addressing those questions from our perspective. We are not all ordained, but we are the Priests to the Geeks, in the sense that we try to serve as mediators between the cultures around our favorite fandoms and our faith communities.

Join our Facebook group and Discord Server

Find our Facebook group, "Priests to the Geeks", then join our Discord server with this link to continue on the conversation with us!

Discord

Transcripts

Andy Walsh:

I declare podcasting welcome, systematic ecologists. You're here for another episode of Faces Behind Us. And we are going to be talking about Michael Scott of the Office today.

I am Andy Walsh and I am joined by tj. How you doing, tj?

TJ Blackwell:

Great. Thank you for asking.

Andy Walsh:

You're very welcome. And about what have you been geeking out lately?

TJ Blackwell:

I don't know how tapped into the. The gaming sphere you are, But Resident Evil 9, Resident Evil Requiem came out yesterday, so that it is. It is phenomenal.

It's the best Resident Evil game, in my opinion, Since Resident Evil 4. Okay. Reasons he bias notwithstanding, of course.

Andy Walsh:

Sure, sure. All right. Awesome. Well, since we're talking sitcoms, I will. I've been excited about the Scrubs revival.

The first two episodes of that landed this week, and they were about what you would expect from returning to the world of Scrubs 20ish years later. That was fun. And a new show, the Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins with Tracy Jordan and Daniel Radcliffe, who.

Who would have ever had on their bingo card, Daniel Radcliffe starring in an NBC major network sitcom. But here we are, and it is very good and very entertaining.

TJ Blackwell:

That sounds so phenomenal. I. I want to see that. That sounds.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. So Tracy Jordan is a disgraced former NFL star and Dana Ratcliffe is a.

A somewhat pretentious documentary filmmaker who also has had a change of fortune in his life. And so they are both trying to find some redemption. Hence the fall and rise. Reggie Dinkins being Trace Jordan's character, he's

TJ Blackwell:

got the perfect build for disgraced, pretentious documentary maker.

Andy Walsh:

Yes. You kind of just sort of look at him and go, yeah, I get what we're doing here.

TJ Blackwell:

I buy it. That makes perfect sense.

Andy Walsh:

Yes. With all respect to Danny Radcliffe, who seems lovely as an actual person.

All right, so that's what we are geeking out on because we are systematic ecologists, after all.

And if you want to hear more of our systematic geeking, and maybe we'll talk about those shows or that game or other things in the future, please remember to rate and review the show wherever you get your podcasts or wherever you're watching this so that it gets boost in the algorithm so that you can find those future episodes and other people can find them as well. We also want to thank one of our financial supporters, Amber Riley, for her contributions. Thank you so much.

And if you would like your own shout out, you can become an official member of Systematic Systematic Geekology.

Just find the link in the description or the show notes for wherever you're listening or watching this and there will be a link there and that will have all the details on how you can sign up or you can make a one time contribution or otherwise support us if you're not quite ready to become a regular member. And as I mentioned, this is a Faces Behind Us episode. That's our annual theme for this year and we've got a special shirt for that.

So while you're over on the website, check out the shirt and see if you want to support that while you're out and about. There is also a playlist for this entire Faces Behind Us series. You can find that in the description as well.

Be sure to check that out if you want to see all of the other episodes that we've done and keep track of forthcoming ones as well. But remember that one of those episodes a month will only be available to those free or paying members of the podcast.

So if you want to become a member, if you. To make sure that you get all of the episodes. So that's the business of podcasting. Let's get into the business of paper. We're talking the Office.

he Office sitcom in the early:

He makes the pointy haired boss from Dilbert seem competent and friendly and likable. When we first are introduced to him, he just, you know, he seems like the epitome of the Peter Principle.

He has been, he has been promoted to his level of maximum incompetence. And, and that is on full display. Yep.

TJ Blackwell:

He grows a lot though.

Andy Walsh:

He sure does.

TJ Blackwell:

He grows a lot. And most of the characters do.

Andy Walsh:

Yes. As one might hope for a show that lasted nine seasons, I think.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, six good ones.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. By some metrics, possibly coinciding with the departure of Michael Scott vec. But yeah, so he is, he's the manager.

We, you know, the rest of the characters primarily are employees of his in, in their little paper office. Some salespeople, some accounting people, some folks whose job description defies explanation or at least mentioning on the show.

And yeah, you know, it's, it's a sort of slice of life office comedy that I think struck a chord with a lot of people for kind of highlighting just the sort of inanity of office culture. At the time.

And also featured a very popular office romance between Jim and Pam as the receptionist and sales, one of the salespeople who are initially just good friends and then romance blooms, as it often does, and these kinds of things. That's kind of the, you know, the, the setup of the show. What are you, what's your history with the office? Did you watch it as it came out?

I'm gonna guess no.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, not quite. We didn't have cable, so no. But I would catch it every now and then. It would be on. It wasn't. I wasn't particularly interested in it.

Neither of my parents had office jobs, so, like, they weren't really that interested in it. My mom was a lab tech, my dad does floors. Just not quite for us.

But I was a part of that seemingly massive group of people who really got into the show when it got put on Netflix, because, you know, I'd never seen it well, you know, other than an episode or two here and there. So when it got put on Netflix, I was like, oh, this is my chance. So I watched it once and then I watched it twice in a third time and a fourth time.

eep most nights. So at around:

Andy Walsh:

Okay, cool. Yeah, so I was around when it, when it first aired. I remember, you know, the promos and so forth.

And, you know, I think my wife and I checked out like maybe the second or third episode we gave a try and just kind of were turned off by the cringiness of the Michael Scott, Steve Carell's character, and the sort of general vibe of the show. That first season, for whatever reason, was only six episodes. It was kind of one of those mid season replacements.

TJ Blackwell:

That was a test.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. And it was.

It was a remake of a British sitcom that had been successful in the UK and that, you know, I think it gotten a sort of a cult following in the US as it started to become possible to. To follow such things across the pond through DVDs and other things.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah. And also I'm glad you mentioned it because that, like, little test, first season, the first season, I wouldn't say is good. The characters are great.

Diversity day. I mean, it's funny, but man, you could not put that on TV today.

It's the only show that I can think of that had a fairly rough first season and then, in my opinion, immediately fixed all of those problems.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, so that's what I was trying to get to is that, yeah, it had those six episodes that were kind of blueprinted by the British sitcom, including the pilot episode is pretty much a direct remake of the same script. And then it goes away for the summer, as TV shows did back in the day and came back, and yes, it had significantly retooled.

And so word of mouth kind of said, hey, this show is actually pretty good. You should check it out. And so I think we did go back and rewatch those episodes because I think you could go to NBC.com or something like that.

And they were still trying to figure out what to do with the web and. And TV shows. So there were.

This was the era of, like, they'd make little shorts for the web and, you know, a fake Dunder Mifflin website and all those kinds of things. So we checked out those episodes and then started watching, you know, the second season, and then we were hooked.

And so we were watching, you know, as the episodes aired pretty much from that point on, and then, you know, the odd rerun and different things now and again. And then during the pandemic, we were looking for some comfort watches, and so we went back and watched through the entire show, start to finish.

So, you know, I'd say we've probably seen the whole thing twice through and then, you know, some episodes more than that over the years.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, and some episodes less. I don't know about you, but I always skip at least one episode on a rewatch.

Andy Walsh:

Fair enough.

TJ Blackwell:

And if you. If you know the show, then you probably know which one I'm talking about.

And if you don't, I'm going to make you watch it and you'll know when you find it.

Andy Walsh:

There you go. Yeah, so. And a big. A big part of that change between the first and second seasons is the Michael Scott character.

Perhaps least importantly, but very noticeably, Steve Carell, his look changes significantly. Steve Carell, in the interim, became a movie star and got it. Got a glow up, let's say.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, that's the funniest part. Season two starts and he has a full head of hair all of a sudden. Yeah, that is always so funny to me.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. And, you know, at the risk of.

At the risk of seeming shallow, you know, I think it does perhaps even change the perception of the character a little bit, or it certainly, I think, helps with the softening of the character and trying to make him a little bit more relatable, because I think that was one of the big realizations is that you just couldn't make a character that unrelentingly unrelatable or unlikable on an American sitcom, you needed everybody to have just a little bit of something that you could connect to. And so season two starts the humanizing of Michael Scott. But let's talk a little bit about Michael Scott as he starts.

How do we think Michael Scott came to be the character who we meet in that first season? Who are some of the folks that we learn are part of his backstory?

TJ Blackwell:

Well, as far as in the show, what we know is Ed Truck. We know Ed Truck is very formative for young Michael Scott working at Dunder Mifflin. Outside of the show.

It's based almost entirely on Ricky Gervais, you know, just kind of entire personality, which is a little coarse for American audiences, especially at the time. So that is one of the reasons that it doesn't go over so well. I think Ricky Gervais is really funny most of the time.

He definitely has his less redeemable moments. Throughout the show we learn about a couple of other major influences on, on young Michael Scott, but I think Ed Truck is the earliest.

And then I want to say it's in season one is, I think the first last time he mentions Chris Rock when he copies a Chris Rock bit.

Andy Walsh:

Word for word. Indeed.

TJ Blackwell:

Word for word. And I mean that inadvisably. Inadvisably word for word. And pretty much everyone in his office and Wayne Gretzky and Todd Packer.

So all of those are up there actually pretty early, but most of those come throughout the show.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. So let's unpack a little bit why you bring this up.

So Ricky Gervais played the equivalent character in the British version of the Office and was one of the co creators of the show. Right, one of the writers and. Yeah, so that's where his influence comes from.

Like I said, his script for that pilot episode is used for that first episode of the American Office. Ed Truck is the previous manager at Dunder, at that branch of Dunder Mifflin, the Scranton, Pennsylvania branch of the Dunder Mifflin office.

So he was, you know, he had Michael Scott's job previously and kind of mentored Michael.

But also, you know, I think we learned that a significant part of why Michael is the way that it is as a reaction against the way that Ed Truck managed the Office.

Yeah, you know, he was, he was more of a straight laced manager, you know, the typical kind of I'm, I'm the boss and we're going to keep things professional and so forth. And Michael didn't, didn't care for that way of working and wanted to.

Wanted to create an office where he was everybody's friend and, you know, and family to some degree, as we see forward.

TJ Blackwell:

And he tries hard.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, elaborate on that. What does he try?

TJ Blackwell:

What doesn't he try?

Andy Walsh:

Well, that true.

TJ Blackwell:

What doesn't he try?

But the first several seasons of the show are absolutely filled with Michael coming up with some new way to either ingratiate the office to him or befriend them in some way. It's a lot. It can be a lot.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, try hard is definitely a word that comes to mind. But, yeah, there's no joke that he won't tell, no stunt that he won't attempt.

Sometimes it borders on bribery with raises or prizes, or that, you know, he's not above buying people's affection. He's definitely, you know, the poster boy for the mindset that any attention is good attention.

TJ Blackwell:

Yep. He'll even overlook, like, severe neglect.

You know, malpractice isn't exactly a word you can use in a paper company, but whatever Kevin was doing, that's malpractice.

Andy Walsh:

It may apply in the case of accountancy.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah. It's fraud, for sure.

Andy Walsh:

Sure.

TJ Blackwell:

And the show addresses that, which is pretty funny.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. And so. And, you know, and as the show goes on, we kind of see that.

We see some glimpses into his childhood that suggest that, you know, he was pretty. Pretty lonely as a child. I'm not sure that we learned much about his parents.

Maybe I'm forgetting, but I don't think we really much learn much about his home life other than we see that we see he makes an appearance as a child on a. On a local, like, public television children's program.

To me, the obvious connection was Romper Room starring Miss Molly was a New Jersey, New York area children's program. But I imagine there were comparable programs in many TV markets around the country in the 70s.

I guess would it would have been, you know, the time frame when he would have been that age. Maybe early 80s. Yeah, early 80s is when I was watching Romper Room. Yeah. So the show where different kids appear every week as.

As guests, as part of the audience and get to interact with a host who is, you know, a young woman who, you know, has a.

As a motherly or nurturing kind of vibe for, you know, some puppet shows and, you know, kind of a Mr. Rogers thing might be the, you know, but with a. With a live audience kind of vibe.

And he makes an appearance on the show and, you know, just talks about how he wants everybody to Be his friend and he hopes, you know, he imagines having many, many friends growing up, but you know, seemingly stemming from a significant loneliness in his life at that time.

And yeah, so I think that's part of the explanation that we're meant to understand is that he's just desperate for friendship but doesn't know how, maybe doesn't know how to make connections. And so we just will try anything and everything.

TJ Blackwell:

His character really is tragic. Like when you just think about who he is and who he wants to be, he really is a tragic character. You just kind of feel bad for him.

You just ends up borderline manipulating the, the all of his subordinates into. Into being his friend.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, yeah. And that's, you know, that's the.

I think one of the most awkward things about the show early on and why it was I think difficult to get into getting out of the gate. There was just, yeah, that sense of this. This is completely inappropriate. It's an abuse of power and for, for the, the thinnest of benefits. Right.

It would seem that, you know, he's getting the most meager amount of friendship out of this desperate, desperate behavior. You know, and the part that, that I find that the most difficult to. To kind of reconcile with that, you know, this kid who just.

Who wants to be everybody's friend and seems very sweet or the guy who visits a classroom of students and tells them that he expects to be able to pay their college tuition when they graduate high school. He seems like a very. In those moments, he seems somewhat empathetic and a bit too naive and innocent to be the sort of again, misogynistic racist.

No joke. There's no line for. To cross for his jokes all you know, he will find every line and transgress it. And it's hard to reconcile those two things.

What are your thoughts about how besides just they had to reconcile the different inconsistencies in the writing but in the universe of the show, how do you understand those. All those aspects of Michael Scott?

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, well, I think they justify it because even in the beginning it's implied that he is a good salesman. As it goes on, he gets to showcase a few times that he really is just a crack job salesman.

Like he is one of the best at sales and he just can't sell himself, which sucks. But it does play it very earnest. He is super desperate. He wants to be like everyone else. He wants everyone else to like him.

It just kind of really sucks to watch from a sympathetic point of view at least. But he does prove that he at least somewhat earned his position as a manager, you know, through. Through sales excellence.

And then somewhere along the way, he realized that he could abuse his station to have friends.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. I wonder also, you know, we see. So one of the characters you showed there was Todd Packer. Right. Who is also, you know, if.

If anything, an even less scrupulous teller of jokes and. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

TJ Blackwell:

I don't think we can say anything that Todd said on the show.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, we will not be repeating any of his lines, but. Yeah, just a difficult person to find redeeming qualities to. As portrayed.

And I wonder, in trying to kind of meld all these different ingredients of Michael Scott, I was wondering how much is Todd Packer's influence there? They were working together. They were salespeople together. And perhaps, you know, given their.

Given their personalities, were they both kind of outsiders? Michael Scott, because he just seemed awkward and. And lacking confidence and just so desperate for friendship that.

That, you know, would turn people off. And Todd Becker just being this, you know, reprehensible character if.

If they wound up kind of falling in with each other just, you know, because they were both, you know, loners or outsiders. And if Michael Scott kind of picked up bad habits from Todd Packer just by wanting to be his friend or wanting to plea to make him happy or whatever.

And Todd Packer had no filter, no reason not to encourage that sort of thing.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah. And Todd is the kind of guy who absolutely would have had no problem taking full advantage of Michael Scott.

Just the desperate young guy who needs friends. They were like, sales partners. So Todd had all the time in the world to just shape him.

I don't think he would have had any problem being like, yeah, I'll let this kid follow me around and worship me while I be a generally reprehensible person.

Andy Walsh:

Right. Yeah.

TJ Blackwell:

But I do think a lot of that he gets off of. He gets off. The Todd Packer mentality eventually just takes a long time.

Andy Walsh:

It does. I. Do you think there are specific people that maybe help him in that direction?

TJ Blackwell:

I do. It's Jim and Dwight probably the best influences for Michael Scott. And it's weird, a lot of these episodes, the faces behind us, it's.

It's not a character that we see this much actual growth in. It's like, in my opinion, it is the biggest strength of the Office is how much the characters change.

Because not only in the show do they change a ridiculous amount, but also in real life. Almost every actor on the show got absurdly popular, especially Steve Carell, because of the 40 year old virgin.

And then whatever else I remember what else he did something I think Despicable

Andy Walsh:

Me comes along at some point in the run of the.

TJ Blackwell:

Oh my gosh, movie's so much older than I think you're right. It's like 29 or something. Something like that. It's a good movie. But Jim and Dwight help him just become a real person.

You know, they have their own flaws for sure, but they're, they're both very real people. Well, Jim's a very real person. I don't think most people know someone like Dwight. I'm not saying he doesn't exist.

I just think most people don't know someone like Dwight. But you can see it as, you know, they spend more time and with Michael Scott that they go closer together. Michael grows more like each of them.

And that kind of plays off of how good he is at sales because neither of them really ever take him seriously until they get to see him run a sale. Like, oh, he's incredible. And of course, over time they just kind of become endeared to this generally pathetic man who just really needs a friend.

So I think they help him a lot.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, I think it's interesting. I think, I think Dwight's maybe a little bit more complicated because, you know, Dwight is himself desperate for advancement in the company.

And so he's one of those people that sees, well, you know, I need to curry the favor of the, of the person above me to, to be promoted and to be advanced.

And so in that regard, maybe he enables some of Michael Scott's worst impulses at times because he doesn't want to, to contradict the boss or, or anything like that. But yeah, at the same time, I think you're right that there are some positive influences there as well. And I think they both need some leadership.

They need some management, they need to be managed and he is their manager. And yet he doesn't seem to know the first thing about how to do that.

And his whole management style seems to be defined largely by, well, I'm just going to do something I don't want to do what, what Ed Truck did.

And the fact that they need some, some structure, some management and so forth at different times, I think maybe puts him in a position where he has to figure out, oh, I need, I need something a little bit more substantive than just, I don't want to be like a Truck or I just want to be everybody's friend. I need to actually figure out how to, how to be a boss.

TJ Blackwell:

He also, he gets A lot out of like Dwight becoming a much more well adjusted and normal person. I think seeing that slowly happen allows Michael to do the same.

Andy Walsh:

Right.

TJ Blackwell:

Because they have a fun little triangle. You know, Jim and Dwight kind of hate each other and Jim kind of hates Michael. Michael absolutely idolizes Jim and kind of hates Dwight.

Dwight's pretty much the only person who. He doesn't want to be his friend, which is interesting because he's so desperate.

He just doesn't want that friend because he can tell most people don't like Dwight and Jim is just a cool, hot guy.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. There's also the element of, you know, we maybe come to appreciate some of Michael Scott's quirks as Jim and Dwight come to appreciate them.

You know, there's the episode where Jim has to, to manage for a day and, and realize that he finds himself falling into some of the same patterns that Michael Scott does in terms of trying to, to coax people into doing different things with different carrots, so to speak.

And yeah, just, you know, and you can, you can see him realizing, oh, maybe there is a reason why, why Michael does things the way that he does sometimes, and maybe there is some benefit to it or there is a value to doing things the way that he does them and that allows us to maybe see that there was something worthwhile there. Or it's a clever retcon, actually. There was a reason why he did these things when really it was just nonsense at the time.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, it's good writing, if you ask me. Sure.

Andy Walsh:

You know. Right. You got to work with the constraints that you set up and figure out how to.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, I don't think they really expected it to become like the biggest show on television.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, I don't, I don't know quite how to, how to get across in, in today's terms just how big the cultural impact of the Office was. You know, we just don't have network television that everybody watches anymore the way that, that we did.

You know, I wouldn't, I don't know that I can say this is the last such show, but certainly it is one of, you know, the Office and Lost were kind of the. And maybe something like Modern Family. I don't know.

You know, there's maybe a couple other examples, but yeah, that's sort of some of the last hurrahs of the, the monoculture of, of network television.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah. I think the, the closest thing to explain to like a younger person listening to this is it. It was like Stranger Things.

Everyone talked about the Office. Everyone had seen the Office it was. It was just constant for years. Years.

rted watching it until, like,:

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. And then it, you know, it. It got that boost as sort of being one of the big first, big streaming, you know, killer apps, you know, not. Not.

Not the first one necessarily, but it was definitely one of those properties that, you know, everybody's kind of waiting where, you know, where is it going to wind up on streaming to check it out again or check it out for the first time?

TJ Blackwell:

school. I started college in:

Andy Walsh:

Okay.

TJ Blackwell:

And I feel like half of my class had Dunder Mifflin stickers on their laptops.

Andy Walsh:

Wow.

TJ Blackwell:

It was crazy.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. That is. That is remarkable, you know, for a group of.

Group of people that had no experience working in offices or very minimal experience working in offices.

TJ Blackwell:

It's just funny. It's well written.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah.

TJ Blackwell:

Well, it's sharp. It can be very sharp. Can be very silly.

Andy Walsh:

Yes. So this is my first Faces behind this episode. You mentioned that you've been on several of these.

TJ Blackwell:

All of them so far.

Andy Walsh:

Okay.

TJ Blackwell:

Every one of them.

Andy Walsh:

So we're moved to talk a little bit about, I guess, how we identify good mentors and bad mentors. Good influences and bad influences. You know, there's a part that wants to say, just avoid anybody who reminds you of anyone from the office. Right.

But that's perhaps not quite so constructive.

TJ Blackwell:

Mostly. I don't know. It is kind of one of those shows where everyone is kind of a little bit problematic.

I mean, Jim, I think most people would consider to be the most normal character on the show. And he's still like a borderline sociopath.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. The pranks against White come early and often in the sorcery seasons.

And really, with on the rewatch, I found myself going, wait, what did Dwight do to deserve this? How did Dwight learn this?

The best explanation I've come up with is that I think the early, you know, the time period when the show premiered, we were kind of at a peak of sort of cool detachment and cynicism and the earnestness that Dwight displays for wanting to do a good job and wanting to be promoted and just generally being earnest and enthusiastic about all these different things. That was. That was about one of the worst crimes that you could commit. Right. The.

Everybody wanted to be the cool, detached Jim who didn't care about anything and was, you know, approached everything With. With a hint of irony or. Or heavy dose of irony.

TJ Blackwell:

And.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, so I think. I think we were. I think it just kind of was obvious at the time. Well, Dwight.

Dwight's crime is he cares too much, and he needs to be taken down a peg to kind of loosen him up.

And I think in more contemporary moments where I think we've swung a little bit more towards actually earnestness and caring about things and being sincere, have their place and have their merits, I think from that perspective, it's harder to approach the office and understand why Dwight is treated the way that he is and why that isn't anything other than just bullying.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah. Some of those pranks are, like, generational, though, so those pranks are so good. Where he wraps his desk.

He turns his desk into just, like, wrapping paper. Like, there's not even cardboard boxes in them. It seems right.

Andy Walsh:

He does it right. He makes it look like he has wrapped up the desk in wrapping paper. But in fact, he's. It's. It's a. It's a faux desk. It's just a desk shape.

TJ Blackwell:

Just the paper. It's so funny.

Andy Walsh:

No, they're absolutely very clever. Just, again, terrible things to actually do to an actual human being.

TJ Blackwell:

Absurd. He replaces himself with one of his actor friends. That's a level of gaslighting that I don't think any character in anything has ever tried to reach.

Andy Walsh:

Yes. And I love that Randall park still gets mileage out of that. You know, you still see the memes of, this is John Krasinski. What are you talking about?

TJ Blackwell:

It's pretty funny.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah.

TJ Blackwell:

And then Dwight's like, okay, kiss Pam. He just does it.

Andy Walsh:

Mm.

TJ Blackwell:

That's. That's hilarious.

Andy Walsh:

Oh, yes. Solid comedy. Terrible humaning, horrible person.

TJ Blackwell:

So, yeah, generally, I would say avoid the people in your life if they remind you of someone from the office, especially the really problematic ones. Ryan Howard. Stay away from that person. Stay really far away from that person.

I don't remember Mindy Kaling's character's name, because by the time I started watching Kelly. Kelly Kapoor, by the time I started watching, she was already Mindy Kaling to me. I don't know what from. Maybe it was the Mindy Project. Maybe it was.

But anyway, most of the people in the office suck. Stanley's a good role model. Show up to work, do your job, sleep a little. Yeah, you deserve it.

You deserve to take a nap at work every once in a while.

Andy Walsh:

Sure. Oscar also seems like a pretty good. You know, he's. He's serious about his accounting he takes his. His work seriously.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah. He probably has the hardest job in the office. Yes. Working next to Kevin, who made up a number to balance his books.

Gotta be the hardest thing you can do as an accountant.

Andy Walsh:

Yes. You know, and still maintains, you know, is still sociable enough that he isn't the pariah that Dwight is. So. Yeah, maybe. Maybe be Oscar.

If you feel like you have to be someone from the office, aim for the Oscar Stanley coordinates.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, there's a coincision there.

I mean, you can mix of those two, but as far as people who actually inspire Michael Scott, I think the only one that I could earnestly say that you should try to emulate is Wayne Gretzky. Of course, my favorite Michael Scott quote is that you miss 100% of the shots that you don't take. Wayne Gretzky, Michael Scott.

That's pretty much all they say about. About him in the show. But I really wanted to make this collage.

I'm not gonna go super in depth on how dominant Wayne Gretzky was for his entire career, but I could.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, he is. He was a phenomenal talent in the sport.

It boggles my mind every time I think about the fact that he would be the leading point scorer in hockey just based on his assists.

TJ Blackwell:

Yep.

Andy Walsh:

And yet he was also the. The leading goal scorer for. For many years. Right up until

TJ Blackwell:

last year.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah.

TJ Blackwell:

Ridiculous. Absolutely ridiculous.

Andy Walsh:

Yes. Perhaps recently, you know, some.

Some things have also come up that maybe he's not entirely somebody want to emulate also, but certainly as a hockey player, if you could be like Wayne Gretzky. Be like Wayne Gretzky.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, if you. You know, if you can.

Andy Walsh:

Right, right. Sure.

TJ Blackwell:

Just, you know, I recommend being the best at the world in whatever you try to do, if at all possible.

Andy Walsh:

Right. You know, if somebody gives you that option.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, you take that option.

Andy Walsh:

All right, so then we will wrap up our conversation here.

There's certainly, obviously, a lot more that could be said about the Office, a show again, that ran for six to nine seasons, depending on how one chooses to. To retcon reality.

TJ Blackwell:

Or five, if you just want to count. Two, three, four, five.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah, you could. You could give the first one. I missed two. Fair. Yeah. So we're gonna. We're gonna wrap up here.

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah, I do know. I think what our extra question should be. Unless. Okay, you do have one.

Andy Walsh:

I had one, but I. I would love to hear yours, because I'm not.

TJ Blackwell:

Bonus.

Andy Walsh:

A bonus.

TJ Blackwell:

Get a bonus. If you had to work from one of the Scranton Dunder Mifflin managers Which one would you choose?

Andy Walsh:

Oh, that's. Yeah, that's a better question than mine. So let's go with that one. Which. Which of the actual Dunder Mifflin managers is the least objectionable?

TJ Blackwell:

Yeah.

Andy Walsh:

All right, so stay. Stay tuned or become a member rather to be able to hear our answers to the bonus question.

In the meantime, go ahead and rate through and review the show wherever you're getting your podcasts so that you will see more of our future episodes and other folks will be able to tune into fantastic episodes like this. Thank you again to Amber Riley for your financial support.

Feel free to check out the link in the show description or the show notes to find out how you can become a financial supporter like Amber.

Get your own shout out, be able to buy the merch, be able to get the bonus questions, be able to get the bonus episodes in this Spaces Behind Us series, which you can see all those in the playlist next up, I believe, unless the things come out in a slightly different order, but according to the schedule, the next episode that will be out will be on Paragon and bit down or something along those lines with Christian, TJ and John are the scheduled folks. We'll see who actually is able to show up. These things are always a little bit.

TJ Blackwell:

It was all three of us.

Andy Walsh:

Oh, it was. Oh, that's right. You've already recorded them. So excellent. So we know. In fact. Yeah, we're ahead. Timey wimey. Yeah. So look for.

Look for that episode that will be one of those fourth wall exclusives.

So become a free member or a paid member so that you can hear what those folks already had to say and will have said in the future about that series of books. Right? Yes. Series of books.

TJ Blackwell:

Yes.

Andy Walsh:

Yeah. So thanks for joining us and tune in to future Faces Behind Us episodes. And remember that if you're going to geek, do it systematically. Sa.

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube

More Episodes
464. Dunder Mifflin's Finest: A Deep Dive into Michael Scott
00:45:55
462. Onward: A Magical Dive into Disney / Pixar's 'COVID Era'
00:53:20
457. One Piece Live Action: Expectations, Surprises, and Pirate Shenanigans
00:53:48
456. The Faces Behind the Bots: Who Inspired Your Favorite Transformers?
00:58:40
453. Emotions in Technicolor: Exploring the Depths of Absolute Martian Manhunter
00:54:34
450. Geeks on a Roll: Crossing the Omniverse in Style!
01:09:00
448. The Faces Behind Zuko: Exploring the Influence of Iroh and Ozai
01:22:26
bonus Emulating Icons: What DC Characters Mean to Us
01:16:46
446. Laughing Through Theology: A Geek’s Guide to Humor and Faith
01:05:02
444. From Wookiees to Dragons: Crafting the Perfect Companion Squad
01:06:19
437. Assassins vs Templars: The Final Showdown!
00:55:48
430. Space Wars and Politics: The Gundam Conflict Unpacked
01:02:10
427. Minority Report: Choosing Beliefs or Just Chosen?
01:05:18
bonus Kong vs. Zilla: The Ultimate Kaiju Showdown
00:32:21
423. Garlic, Germs, and Good Vibes: Unpacking I Am Legend
00:49:21
419. Appendices and Epilogues: The Hidden Gems of Your Favorite Books
00:52:31
418. Sailing Through Dressrosa: Our One Piece Review Adventure!
00:55:52
415. Kaiju Clash: DC & Marvel vs Godzilla Showdowns
00:42:33
412. Big Hero 6: The Heartfelt Adventures of Hiro and Baymax!
00:51:45
408. Delving into the Significance of Punk Hazard in One Piece
00:43:40
402. Top 3 Sports Anime: A Deep Dive into the Best of the Genre
01:15:45
400. What If Church Embraced Comic Con Culture?
00:45:12
398. Duel of the Fates: A Critical Examination of an Alternate Star Wars Episode 9
01:05:25
bonus Unmasking the Mystery: A Deep Dive into the 2002 Film Scooby-Doo
00:29:25
396. Ironheart and Jurassic World: A Deep Dive into New IPs
00:56:07
bonus Exploring the Curious Case of Flubber: A Deep Dive into Disney's Rotten Gem
00:31:14
391. Unveiling the Complexities of Identity in 'What If . . . Marc Spector Was Host to Venom?'
00:58:05
bonus Kronk's New Groove: The Zero Percent Mystery of Animation's Forgotten Sequel
00:28:52
390. Navigating the High Seas of Morality: Pirates vs World Government in One Piece
00:39:43
388. Exploring the Emotional Depth of 'The Last of Us': A Comprehensive Review
01:20:25
387. From Frogs to Dreams: An Analytical Review of 'Princess and the Frog'
00:53:42
384. The Evolution of the Straw Hats: Insights into the Time Skip and Fish-Man Island Saga
00:41:46
382. The Politics of Star Wars: Insights from 'The Rise and Fall of the Galactic Empire'
01:22:32
bonus The Erdtree and Its Symbolism: A Celebration of Arbor Day in Elden Ring
00:44:17
372. Finding the Good: Unpacking the Legacy of Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan
00:48:56
368. Ratatouille: The Rat That Redefined Culinary Dreams
00:34:44
bonus Wednesday Addams: Individuality Amidst Darkness and Family
00:32:37
366. Marineford: The Heart-Wrenching Battle for Freedom and Family
01:10:22
364. What If 'The Office' Existed in Today's Corporate World?
00:47:19
bonus Binge-Watching the Absurd: Our Insight into A Series of Unfortunate Events
00:37:17
359. Unraveling the Latest Buzz: Spider-Man, Cobra Kai, Solo Leveling, and Invincible
00:59:22
357. Navigating the Waters of One Piece: Insights into the Sabody and Impel Down Arcs
00:49:44
353. The Comedy and Depth of Dandadan: A Discussion with Mark Flower
00:59:29
bonus From Halo to Fable: The Characters We Look Up To in Xbox History
01:03:52
bonus The Icons We Love: Emulate or Immolate?
01:09:55
344. Why Lilo & Stitch Sequels Are Better Than You Remember
00:45:18
342. What makes a hero, Epic?
00:57:34
341. Could Dead Space really happen?
00:45:21
bonus Who are the greatest Sega and Arcade Game Characters?!
00:47:47
339. Could the child of Satan work for the Church?
00:42:44
336. What if the hosts of Systematic Geekology were in Star Fleet?
00:46:50
331. Our Top 3 Gen 6 Games!
01:08:02
329. What can the Elder Scrolls teach us about religious syncretism?
00:50:38
327. Are you thankful for dungeon cuisine?
01:04:20
326. Would you shoot the Devil?
00:58:30
315. Which religions are represented in The Dresden Files?
01:03:56
310. Will you miss the Going Merry?
00:38:51
308. What is the Church of Unitology?
00:52:25
307. All Reading Counts: Astra Lost in Space
01:06:31
304. What does it mean to be Spirited Away?
00:51:55
303. What if Godzilla attacked South Park? (again)
00:54:31
301. What are Triforce politics?
00:56:30
296. What makes Treasure Planet so beautiful?
00:49:44
293. Is this pod extra ordinary?
00:53:36
292. Did your youth pastor write Brother Bear?
00:49:45
bonus Are penguins the best surfers?
00:22:06
291. What made the house of Usher fall?
00:47:35
bonus How was Mary Poppins so groundbreaking?
00:26:54
283. Who was Disney's best motley crew?
00:48:12
280. Will Thorfinn become a Christian?
00:43:33
279. What if Count Dooku trained Obi Wan?
00:59:33
278. Should Mulan be considered a Disney Princess?
00:42:09
273. Why should we read A Wrinkle in Time?
00:47:57
271. Can we disagree well over Star Wars: The Last Jedi?
01:29:18
270. What can the pantheons from D&D teach us about our own faith?
01:03:44
268. Can the Straw Hats beat a god?
00:46:29
bonus Do we need World Government?
00:49:59
265. Godzilla x Kong, Solo Leveling, and Ark: The Animated Series
00:54:02
bonus Is Fallout right about the nature of war?
01:03:46
257. Does Harry Potter have a savior's complex?
00:55:05
256. Dune & Avatar: The Last Airbender
01:04:35
bonus Theology Beer Camp: How to Read Pop Culture
01:29:04
bonus Theology Beer Camp: Star Wars & Religious Studies
01:20:45
bonus Theology Beer Camp: Middle Earth, Hope, and Despair
01:14:10
252. How can Gundam teach us about the evils of war?
01:26:10
249. Who is NIKA in One Piece?
00:44:33
245. Do superheroes like camping?
00:30:00
239. Who first kills Luffy?
00:45:52
bonus Holiday Party: Epiphany & The Life of Brian
01:04:41
bonus How could the Grinch or Bumble find redemption?
01:01:55
231. Could super powers bring happiness?
00:45:53
230. Why should we read more short stories?
01:20:03
bonus Why didn't the Grinch steal Christmas?
00:25:31
bonus Have you ever eaten something so delicious it made your clothes fall off?
00:29:46
221. The Politics of Attack on Titan
01:11:49
217. Do the gods of the Stephen King universe invoke fear or hope?
01:24:00
216. Why is Ratigan so underrated?!
00:40:42
215. bonus What is the best Disney soundtrack?
00:30:52
211. How did the Jedi receive their calling?
01:17:48
206. Ahsoka & One Piece
00:45:55
195. (LIVE) How are ghosts & demons portrayed in our comics & manga?
00:46:37
bonus (LIVE) How many other planets have we actually had equipment on?
00:02:27
193. (LIVE) What if we found plant life on other planets?
00:43:01
bonus Are pirates hedonists?
00:05:31
197. How did a pirate ride change the world?
00:50:54
190. Why isn't Luffy afraid of death?
00:32:34
bonus Can Joy exist without Sadness?
00:33:49
bonus Could this all be just a dream?
00:30:46
180. Who is Darth Bane?
00:40:39
174. (LIVE) Hmm... What else do we geek out on?
00:52:03
173. Who created the Pokémon world?
00:41:44
171. (LIVE) How are Angels like Aliens?
00:57:44
170. How did the Land of Ooo come to be?
00:36:23
168. How long can "Star Wars: The Knights of the Old Republic" go on?
00:26:46
167. How does the Jedi Exile compare to Revan?
01:06:02
160. Blood & Honey, Pokémon TCG, and Resident Evil 4
00:57:30
bonus ONE SHOT: Why do resurrections matter?
01:10:07
158. Are the live-action Disney remakes good?
00:50:29
155. Is it okay to brainwash a sith?
00:33:21
bonus Why did Blackbeard put up with Stede Bonnet?
00:31:23
154. Batman, South Park, and Apex Legends
00:51:16
147. How quantum are you feeling today?
00:43:45
bonus Is "The Witcher" an HBO series?
00:21:11
145. Why do we love Critical Role so much?
00:49:43
144. How controversial can "The Three Caballeros" REALLY be?
00:50:37
bonus What does "The Last of Us" reveal about our desires?
00:36:57
140. What if we REALLY did find life on another planet?
00:56:42
139. The Witch from Mercury, One Piece Odyssey, and The Last of Us
00:40:46
138. What makes Mortal Kombat great?
00:27:34
137. Bad Batch, One Piece Odyssey, and Chasing Waves
00:32:27
133. Avatar: The Way of Water, Tulsa King, and Bad Batch S2
00:42:31
131. What if John Constantine was Hogwarts' professor of the Dark Arts?
00:33:28
bonus Is Elf a good movie?
00:38:07
128. Did Netflix make the best Pinocchio?
00:40:32
bonus Is Tim Allen REALLY Santa?
00:38:43
127. Where is Perelandra?
00:37:12
126. Who is Ahsoka Tano?
00:43:29
125. Willow, Pokemon, Wednesday, and Jojo's Bizarre Adventure
00:39:15
118. Was Pinocchio the perfect animated film?
00:28:17
117. Who will become the king of the pirates?
00:37:02
113. What is your favorite rejected dwarf name?
00:23:26
bonus Are you un poco loco for Coco?
00:35:07
110. What is your favorite book series?
00:34:27
108. Should there be more Hocus Pocus films?
00:32:42
107. How much magic can there be in a card game?
00:42:37
bonus What are your favorite magic words?
00:26:25
104. What makes something canon?
00:44:39
100. Who is your favorite Star Wars character?
00:40:52
97. How powerful is your jewelry?
00:24:10
89. Why do we love D&D?
00:37:38
88. Is "Treasure Planet" perfect?
00:42:50
86. How awesome is Mortal Kombat?
00:49:24
bonus What can "Phantom Menace" teach us about taxes?
00:32:23
79. What's the best anime to start with?
01:01:50
78. Where is Buzz Lightyear of Star Command?
00:31:37
76. Should we let dinosaurs remain extinct?
00:30:30
75. What is Gundam Wing?
00:48:44
bonus Could you be an avatar of Khonshu or YHWH?
00:36:06
68. Who is the Last Ronin?
01:02:43
64. Why do we love Godzilla?
00:46:47
63. Would clones have souls?
00:57:43
59. What's with Master Chief's head?
00:43:18
53. What are the 5 greatest Green Lantern moments of all time?
00:47:38
51. Are our souls hollowing?
00:37:39
49. Should we seek revenge on demons?
00:46:53
48. Have you ever dropkicked a zombie?
00:43:34
42. (Pokémon) Is Arceus a God of Time or of Space?
00:45:49
35. What Does Your RPG Character Say About You?
00:29:30
34. What's Your Favorite Star Wars Planet?
00:45:10
31. (The Book of Boba Fett) How Can We Heal From Our Own Sarlacc Pitts?
00:45:22
23. Can Gaming be Worship?
00:38:53
21. Who is Boba Fett?
00:44:39
20. What Can Pirates Teach us About Faith?
00:31:21
8. What is Your Role in the Universe?
00:38:12
bonus What Makes Sci-Fi so Compelling?
00:10:24
bonus BONUS: Who Are the Priests to the Geeks?
00:37:44
4. What's with the Fear of D&D and Anime?
00:53:35
3. Is "Revenge of the Sith" a Good Movie?
00:37:08