TW: Homophobia, suicide and depression
James McIntosh taught himself to knit with chopsticks and string when he had been so low in mood that he couldn't leave his bed. He now credits knitting with saving his life.
See the transcript for this episode on the captivate player
James is the owner of McIntosh yarn, see their website
Follow James on Instagram: @knitmcintosh
Yarns, patterns and research discussed in this episode:
Erika knight men’s knits Men'sKnits A New Direction by Erika Knight - Yarn etc...
Pussy hat project (including the critique that it is not inclusive for all races and gender identities) Pussyhat - Wikipedia
Information on mindfulness: Mindfulness- NHS (www.nhs.uk)
Evidence on mindfulness for depression: mindfulness depression | Search results page 1 | Evidence search | NICE
Ravelry: Hue Shift Afghan pattern by Kerin Dimeler-Laurence
Betsan Corkhill Stitchlinks.com
Why I Knit Podcast disclaimer
For the purpose of this disclaimer ‘We’ refers to Dr Mia Hobbs and the ‘Why I Knit’ podcast.
The views expressed in this podcast belong solely to the speaker and do not reflect the views of Dr Mia Hobbs.
The aim of the podcast is to explore the opinions and experiences of the interviewees and not to disseminate factual information. We take no responsibility for and do not verify any facts mentioned by interviewees on the podcast and assume no liability for any of the views or statements made by interviewees on the podcast. The podcast is designed for general use and is not designed to constitute professional advice or a professional service.
We assume no responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions in the content of this podcast. The information contained in this site is provided oan "as is" basis with no guarantees of completeness, accuracy, usefulness or timeliness.
The links to websites provided in the show notes are for information only and we assume no responsiblity for the websites accessed via these links.
Mentioned in this episode:
Knitting for Self-Care at Christmas
Visit our website to download the FREE bonus episode of Self-Care One Stitch at a Time focussed on Christmas. Download it now at https://creativerestoration.org/christmas/
Hello, and welcome to the Why I Knit podcast. My name
Mia Hobbs:is Dr. Mia Hobbs and I'm a clinical psychologist who's
Mia Hobbs:passionate about knitting and its benefits for our mental
Mia Hobbs:health. Each week on the podcast, I interview a different
Mia Hobbs:knitter about why they knit and how it benefits their mental
Mia Hobbs:well being. This week on the podcast, I'm talking to James
Mia Hobbs:McIntosh, the owner and founder of Macintosh yarn, and also the
Mia Hobbs:author of Knit and Nibble. You can find a link to James's
Mia Hobbs:website and any of the patterns in yarns we discussed in the
Mia Hobbs:show notes alongside more information on mindfulness and
Mia Hobbs:the evidence base for it. Please note that during our
Mia Hobbs:conversation, we talk about depression, homophobia and
Mia Hobbs:bereavement, but also lots about knitting
Mia Hobbs:them Hi, James, welcome to the podcast.
James McIntosh:Thank you. It's good to see you. How are you?
Mia Hobbs:I'm good. Thanks. How are you doing?
James McIntosh:I'm busy on a sleeve at the minute doing a
James McIntosh:good, lovely raglan jumper trying to trying to recover from
James McIntosh:second sleeve syndrome. Have you ever had it?
Mia Hobbs:I have. I've definitely had second sock
Mia Hobbs:syndrome, I would say more than second sleeve, I do tend to knit
Mia Hobbs:top down raglans. And then you've got it's all attached.
Mia Hobbs:And I feel like it's easier to see. I just need to do it. But
Mia Hobbs:second, socks, definitely.
James McIntosh:I'm doing a bottom up jumper. And really
James McIntosh:nice bright one. Because I just want more colour in my life at
James McIntosh:the moment. Yeah, what I've always find is with we second
James McIntosh:sleeve is a problem. So I've come up with a new idea. And I
James McIntosh:think it's quite clever. So do the ribbing on the cuff on one
James McIntosh:and then on the other, right. And then there's two sets of
James McIntosh:increases as you go so do the first set on one sleeve. And
James McIntosh:then the second, the first one on the other one and then the
James McIntosh:second and then knit to so many centimetres and one and the same
James McIntosh:to the other. And then, you know, take off your four
James McIntosh:stitches and each row and then move up to the first decrease.
James McIntosh:And then that's how I'm doing that. So I'm doing
Mia Hobbs:so like kind of two at a time.
James McIntosh:Two at a time tango
Mia Hobbs:That sounds very clever. So you beat the the
Mia Hobbs:second sleeve syndrome. So you'd have to do the same thing over
Mia Hobbs:again. Also, I'm not great at remembering. I know in theory,
Mia Hobbs:I'm following a pattern but making sure the increases are
Mia Hobbs:exactly the same on the second one. I'm not sure that always
Mia Hobbs:happens.
James McIntosh:That's because you write them out. Right? Yeah.
James McIntosh:Row numbers and I put plus two or minus two next to the row
James McIntosh:number and I just stroke them out as I go.
Mia Hobbs:That's definitely sensible. process. I would love
Mia Hobbs:to hear James where your story with knitting began.
James McIntosh:began five years ago. Okay. I would have never
James McIntosh:met in my life. I always loved to a handknit jumper. There is
James McIntosh:something special about a hand knit jumper.
Mia Hobbs:Even before you started you were an appreciator
Mia Hobbs:of that
James McIntosh:Oh I loved a good jumper. You see, the
James McIntosh:problem was I became very famous very young very quickly and won
James McIntosh:more world awards than I could arguably mentally cope with at
James McIntosh:the time. And I say that no looking back. I'm 43 and a half
James McIntosh:at the moment. You see what I've learned is the half is really
James McIntosh:important. You know, because I'm not 44 It's not that I'm turning
James McIntosh:seven. It's not 44 I, my degree was in home economics and food
James McIntosh:marketing. And I worked in the Good Housekeeping Institute and
James McIntosh:the Cordon Bleu cookery schools. And then I went freelance and my
James McIntosh:first client and oh, we lasted for years together was Aga
James McIntosh:cookers. I was worked my way up to being the global ambassador
James McIntosh:for Aga. And I launched Aga all over the world, America, across
James McIntosh:Europe, Canada, and I was the man that brought Aga to China. I
James McIntosh:worked freelance and I also presented Food TV in China. I
James McIntosh:was the only Westerner that I think has ever done it. I used
James McIntosh:to get 100 million viewers a week on my TV shows. And I mean
James McIntosh:the numbers are
Mia Hobbs:Yeah, you got even conceive of that kind of numbers
Unknown:1.8 billion people. Yeah. And I got less than 10% of
Unknown:them watching my shows. So yeah, yes it wasn't quite Saturday
Unknown:Kitchen. No. So it was huge. I brought all of the business home
Unknown:to my native Northern Ireland and from a farm in the middle of
Unknown:nowhere, but I live in London and Peckham in the posh part, as
Unknown:we call it. And I brought all the business home. And it was
Unknown:very clear that because I'm gay, that the business wasn't welcome
Unknown:in Northern Ireland in Northern Ireland and I have letters from
Unknown:senior elected Northern Irish officials denying meetings
Unknown:denying investment and I Oh, it was just awful. And they
Unknown:publicly shamed me. And they hung me out to dry and they
Unknown:sullied my name. And one day, I just couldn't function anymore.
Unknown:I collapsed. And I could not move my leg down the bed for a
Unknown:few weeks. My head was very dark, it did not make sense. I
Unknown:did not know what to do. And if I didn't know what to do, I
Unknown:didn't have the energy to do it. I was diagnosed with what was
Unknown:called a moderately severe depressive episode, I spent a
Unknown:full year in bed. There was little I haven't watched on
Unknown:Netflix in that year, five years ago. Because I couldn't do
Unknown:anything else. Until I decided, oh, let's try knitting. Well, I
Unknown:found a pair of chopsticks and a bit of string in the flat.
Unknown:looked on YouTube. Learnt how to cast on Thomas my other half
Unknown:came home from work. Thomas is a doctor. We'll chat about him in
Unknown:a bit. Yeah, I remember wiggling this cast on something or other
Unknown:at him. I did this today love and he goes brilliant. Let's get
Unknown:the wool,
Mia Hobbs:so he ran with it. He what? Because yes, he asked me
Mia Hobbs:did why was it knitting? Do you think?
James McIntosh:Because what else can you do in bed when you
James McIntosh:stuck home all day? So you see, I
Mia Hobbs:was like you tried other things. And then that was
Mia Hobbs:the one that stuck in
James McIntosh:I was so scared. So anxious, so afraid. And my
James McIntosh:head was so black with depression. I couldn't leave my
James McIntosh:bed. I couldn't leave the bedroom. It was the it was
James McIntosh:overwhelming. Anyway, Tommy got me beige alpaca and the big 12
James McIntosh:millimetre needles you know, we bought an Erika Knight book on
James McIntosh:men's knits and we knit a jumper and I couldn't read a pattern
James McIntosh:really at that point. No. I still have the jumper it's a god
James McIntosh:awful thing as I quoted to Knitting magazine once 15 sizes
James McIntosh:too big. You look like a Von Trapp child with hand knitted
James McIntosh:curtains for your garb. It's horrible.
Mia Hobbs:But it sounds like it served a very significant
Mia Hobbs:purpose.
James McIntosh:Oh, yes. It's at the back of my wardrobe. But it
James McIntosh:allowed me to love myself again. I when I first put that awful
James McIntosh:thing on a creation that I had made. Even though it was beige,
James McIntosh:I looked in the mirror and I thought I made this I am worth
James McIntosh:something that I made for me. And you know, that beige allowed
James McIntosh:me to start to get a wee glimpse of colour back into my world. I
James McIntosh:was going to the Maudsley hospital every Thursday, I never
James McIntosh:really expected to be an outpatient of the Maudsley
James McIntosh:hospital. But you know, it was brilliant. They put me on a year
James McIntosh:of psychodynamic psychotherapy. Why did these words need to
James McIntosh:ssound so clinically? electrolyzing. You know, like,
James McIntosh:yeah, like lobotomy. But it was nothing like that. I mean, if
James McIntosh:they've called it self improvement, or something like
James McIntosh:that, I would've found it easier to go. But I had a therapist who
James McIntosh:was brilliant. She was tough. She was tough. And she helped me
James McIntosh:realise that many times in life, I was not wrong. Because I was
James McIntosh:different. Because I'm gay, in my native Northern Ireland, that
James McIntosh:my thoughts and my feelings were worth something. And that I was
James McIntosh:worth something. So I came home one night and what what I really
James McIntosh:appreciated about psycho dynamic psychotherapy was, you would do
James McIntosh:you hour, I was a Thursday I went, and then you'd have a
James McIntosh:whole week to think about what you've done in that hour to come
James McIntosh:back and complain next week. And then she would ask you why you
James McIntosh:were complaining? And are you were feeling that the key to it
James McIntosh:was that week in between? I would do a bit of my knitting at
James McIntosh:home. And I realised that as a stitch is tangible, and vital in
James McIntosh:a knitted project. So my feelings are tangible to me. And
James McIntosh:if that stitch wasn't there, the whole thing would unravel.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah, that's true.
James McIntosh:And it would fall apart. So my thoughts and
James McIntosh:my feelings were worth something to me and part of me. And I
James McIntosh:joked one night and said this is knititation. Nothing for
James McIntosh:fidgeters. I've got this busy brain. It's always busy. It was
James McIntosh:always too fast. And I can't sit there do this meditation
James McIntosh:malarkey or this mindfulness?
Mia Hobbs:I think you tried to do that had you before?
James McIntosh:Oh, yes, yes. I'll tell you about that in a
James McIntosh:second? That doesn't work. But one stitch and then another
James McIntosh:allows a sense of calm, it stops me fidgeting. So, I realised if
James McIntosh:I knit consciously and mindfully, which means no
James McIntosh:television, no radio, consciously feeling my feet on
James McIntosh:the floor, my bum in the seat, my back in the chair, the
James McIntosh:needles, the wool flowing through my fingers, and accept
James McIntosh:those feelings and sensations in my body without judging,
James McIntosh:analysing or changing them, or evaluating them, just accept
James McIntosh:them. Yeah. That it will not solve the world's problems, but
James McIntosh:it will help me solve mine. And that I will be able to cope.
James McIntosh:Well I got out of bed, I got my life back. But the bit in the
James McIntosh:middle of all of this is Thomas my other half. Thomas is a
James McIntosh:senior consultant physician in a large central London teaching
James McIntosh:hospital. And he's also a fellow of the Royal College of
James McIntosh:Physicians. Thomas's inpatients are geriatrics and his
James McIntosh:outpatients are related to autonomics. That's faint
James McIntosh:blackouts and dizzy spells to you and me. Well, Thomas, is
James McIntosh:very into his mindfulness. He's the only NHS consultant that we
James McIntosh:know of, that has taken mindfulness outside of
James McIntosh:psychiatry, and into clinical medicine. And Thomas uses
James McIntosh:mindfulness to treat chronic illness and chronic pain. And he
James McIntosh:may he may practices mindfulness for three hours a day, every
James McIntosh:day. Wow. Yeah, I know. We've just celebrated 10 years
James McIntosh:together last week.
Mia Hobbs:Congratulations.
James McIntosh:Thank you It is an achievement. Yeah. So Thomas,
James McIntosh:for every night and morning, I have watched him do an hour of
James McIntosh:mindfulness before bed, when he wakens up and an hour at
James McIntosh:lunchtime. And I have seen the fruits of this in his life, in
James McIntosh:my life, and in our lives together, but I couldn't do
James McIntosh:this. And he would go Oh, James you have to do this we tried the
James McIntosh:mindful movements. You know, we do the lower cobra on the floor.
James McIntosh:And yeah, I wasn't having any of this it didn't work for me. As
James McIntosh:we say in Northern Ireland. It did not float my boat. Yeah. The
James McIntosh:knitting. malarkey works for me. Hmm. And knitting as a form of
James McIntosh:mindfulness, not as a distraction technique works.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah. And how did you guys was that a combination of
Mia Hobbs:the two of you like was that Thomas adding his mindfulness
Mia Hobbs:slant? It sounds like when you're doing it like that, it is
Mia Hobbs:a very specific way of doing knitting. It's not about you
Mia Hobbs:know how most people do knitting watching TV or, you know, it is
Mia Hobbs:a very, much a mindfulness method of knitting. It's very
Mia Hobbs:specific.
James McIntosh:Yeah, I mean, I get out of bed in the morning.
James McIntosh:Yeah, I make myself a cuppa. And I sit in my office and just do
James McIntosh:hours knitting. Okay? And that's
Mia Hobbs:doing it mindfully, like, Thomas, does this
Mia Hobbs:meditation?
James McIntosh:Yeah, you know, then I watch the news after
James McIntosh:that. And, you know, the news is on a loop at that time in the
James McIntosh:morning, so you're not gonna miss much. And if you what I
James McIntosh:learned was if I set my mind correctly at the start of the
James McIntosh:day, the rest of the day flows. Now, what's really interesting
James McIntosh:about my story, is there is no evidence that's been peer
James McIntosh:reviewed, or anecdotal that we have found that shows how
James McIntosh:knitting or mindfulness can get you out of depression. Right.
James McIntosh:There is evidence to suggest that mindfulness based stress
James McIntosh:reduction MBSR Yeah. Will delay will reduce the statistics of
James McIntosh:someone who's had moderately severe and severe depression
James McIntosh:from suffering again, right. Okay. What this has done for me
James McIntosh:is it got me better. This is my story. We cannot say this
James McIntosh:medically. But this is my testimony and my story, and I am
James McIntosh:alive and I am well and I am healthy because of knititation.
James McIntosh:I lost my business over what happened. I've been able to
James McIntosh:start a business. It's doing brilliant. Yeah, I mean,
James McIntosh:McIntosh Wool, I hand dye all the wool myself. It's pure,
James McIntosh:beautiful British wool. I do. Deramores, Do you know Deramores
James McIntosh:the wool retailer, well they've just started to stock me, and
James McIntosh:we're doing a whole campaign about living life with more
James McIntosh:colour, but how to have more colour in your life, this colour
James McIntosh:is like colours health colour is healing, the more colour I can
James McIntosh:surround myself with, hmm, the better because it helps me stay
James McIntosh:alive.
Mia Hobbs:So that's another therapeutic part of the knitting
Mia Hobbs:process surrounding yourself. Yeah, I mean, I certainly have
Mia Hobbs:times when I'm like, I need to knit with pink and yellow.
Mia Hobbs:Because that's what I want to be around you just about you have a
Mia Hobbs:long relationship with a knitting project when it's a big
Mia Hobbs:garment. Don't you like it its in your hands, in your life?
James McIntosh:You see, you may have the luxury of that. I
James McIntosh:don't. I have to be fast? Yeah. Do you know how many tension
James McIntosh:squares I have to knit for the shop or retailer to see it.
James McIntosh:Anytime a new fibre comes to me, I need to play with it. So I I'm
James McIntosh:doing a sleeve a day at the moment. So that is quite I know.
James McIntosh:so yes, I have my meditation, my mindful knitting first thing in
James McIntosh:the morning. And then I do a lot of reading on the computer while
James McIntosh:I am speed knitting to get garments for photography. Yeah.
Mia Hobbs:And has your relationship with knitting
Mia Hobbs:changed now that it's I don't know, when the yarn brand
Mia Hobbs:started. How long ago was that?
James McIntosh:You see what happened was I got better. And
James McIntosh:then Thomas and I decided to go on holiday. And we we went we
James McIntosh:decided to go to pride in Tel Aviv. Okay, the plane landed in
James McIntosh:Tel Aviv. We can go on the phone and Thomas's mum had dropped
James McIntosh:dead.
Mia Hobbs:Oh, no, I'm sorry to hear that.
James McIntosh:Well, Thomas is German. What do we do? Stay
James McIntosh:here, go back to London go to Germany. We did not know what to
James McIntosh:do. She died at home. The police took six weeks in Germany just
James McIntosh:to make sure all was okay. And it was just awful. We went to
James McIntosh:Jerusalem. It was a beautiful city to go to when you're in
James McIntosh:that sort of situation. We have the funeral in Germany. And the
James McIntosh:day after my mum was diagnosed with late term ovarian cancer.
Mia Hobbs:Oh, I'm so sorry.
James McIntosh:Nine months to the day. The Thomas's mother
James McIntosh:passed mine did and it was the first week of lockdown. There
James McIntosh:were no flights from London to Belfast. I held my knitting
James McIntosh:tighter. I was the only one I remember in Heathrow terminal
James McIntosh:five that day. When I got home, my mom who was 71 looked 95.
James McIntosh:There was no morphine available. My mother screamed for hours in
James McIntosh:my arms, because the health system in Northern Ireland had
James McIntosh:collapsed.
Mia Hobbs:So sorry,
James McIntosh:We were not allowed a funeral. We were not
Mia Hobbs:Yeah. So you really have kind of kept yourself going
Mia Hobbs:allowed neighbours. We were not allowed family. We were not
Mia Hobbs:allowed support. We were on our own. And my knitting stayed in
Mia Hobbs:my hands. And that stitch was a breath and the next one was a
Mia Hobbs:with the knitting through all of that trauma.
Mia Hobbs:scream of pain and the next was a loving memory. And if it w
Mia Hobbs:sn't for that knitting, but I have not been depressed since
Mia Hobbs:managed to get through this hor endous tsunami. I did not get de
James McIntosh:I mean, the best credit, a lot of it was there
James McIntosh:ressed again. I then managed to ive up smoking by stopping by k
James McIntosh:itting. I'd smoked for 23 ye rs. 20 a day. I am six month
James McIntosh:and two weeks smoke and nicot ne free. Do I see the health
James McIntosh:enefits? Yeah, don't cough on t e pillow every morning. And th
James McIntosh:t wee bit on my finger's not y llow anymore. There's mor
James McIntosh:to this knitting malarkey than meets the eye. So when I st
James McIntosh:rt my business, I started Macint sh Wool two years ago, but I h
James McIntosh:d to take a year out because f Mum. Oh sure. Yeah. And
James McIntosh:ou know, it's a blessing. And we just want to spread the
James McIntosh:good news about knitting. And e, human and tell people it's
James McIntosh:okay to cry. It's okay to bre k down. Just hold something in
James McIntosh:our two hands and make a s itch because that s
James McIntosh:was somebody in the Olympics, who decided to do my marketing
James McIntosh:for me. I wasn't the only wee boy knitting You know, there was
James McIntosh:another one. I just stopped back and I just thought he'd gone.
James McIntosh:But I've never seen items as fast in my life as what was
James McIntosh:coming off a certain Instagram profile. Hey, yeah.
Mia Hobbs:So yes, Tom Daley was doing the marketing for you. Did
Mia Hobbs:you like I did get hundreds of your friends who don't have
Mia Hobbs:nothing to do with knitting sending you. Have you seen this
Mia Hobbs:at the olympics?
James McIntosh:you seen this? Have you seen this? Yes. Yes,
James McIntosh:just because he looks better than me with his top off is not
James McIntosh:my problem
Mia Hobbs:the rest of us just don't do it in speedos.
James McIntosh:So no knitting has saved my life. Well, I would
James McIntosh:have committed suicide by now without it. Men don't talk men
James McIntosh:can't talk. And I was watching a lot of the parliamentary Select
James McIntosh:Committee yesterday. About Yorkshire cricket. Oh, yes. And
James McIntosh:I was very interested to hear the guy who was racially abused.
James McIntosh:He said, for a lot of my life. I went along with things they
James McIntosh:said, because they told me it wasn't racist. And I know that
James McIntosh:from homophobia in Northern Ireland. It was okay, all my
James McIntosh:life for people to call me a poof or a fruit. And I had to
James McIntosh:accept that was okay. And it's only now that we are getting the
James McIntosh:freedom to say I am worth something. Don't call me that.
James McIntosh:Knitting has given me the strength for that.
Mia Hobbs:Wow. So that's amazing.
James McIntosh:Oh, we'll get great jumpers too.
Mia Hobbs:But you know, the other stuff, you know, and I
Mia Hobbs:think it can take some time to go back over all those memories
Mia Hobbs:and think actually, that wasn't okay. Yeah.
James McIntosh:I don't like doing moss stitch because
James McIntosh:there's too much back and forwards. And I use that as
James McIntosh:anger management.
Mia Hobbs:And, I mean, does does the type of knitting make a
Mia Hobbs:difference to you? Do you? Does it matter whether it's like you
Mia Hobbs:said moss stitch or stockinette or a pattern or colour work or,
Mia Hobbs:or not particularly?
James McIntosh:It depends what I do I There is not enough in
James McIntosh:the market for men. It is really hard to get a nice pattern for a
James McIntosh:bloke you know, the market, it's barren for it. I wrote a book on
James McIntosh:it, Knit and Nibble, but apart from that, there's not much. Um,
Mia Hobbs:there was a men's Knitting magazine for a while. I
Mia Hobbs:don't know if it's still around.
James McIntosh:Rib. No it's gone.
Mia Hobbs:Oh, has it?
James McIntosh:You know, then we had I tried to stick to
James McIntosh:blokes and gender neutral. I will expand into other things
James McIntosh:but I'm a small company, you know, and I'm only just starting
James McIntosh:to get knitting patterns together now for my brand. Yeah,
James McIntosh:I can't stand intarsia I just can't those bobbins get all
James McIntosh:messed up. I just don't want that in my life. Yeah. Other
James McIntosh:people seem to like it. Yeah, do love a good bit of fairisle. I
James McIntosh:mean, a multicoloured stranded yoke can just bring so much joy,
James McIntosh:it can tell a story. And you can knit your mood in it. You know,
James McIntosh:your pattern repeats. I hate doing the mathematics for
James McIntosh:knitting. But Thomas does that. For me. He's great with a
James McIntosh:calculator, and he enjoys that
Mia Hobbs:for patterns do you mean for developing patterns.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah, yeah. Right, like calculating yards and that kind
Mia Hobbs:of thing.
James McIntosh:I mean, if he can do morphine doses and stuff
James McIntosh:that's important in hospital in his head and he can, he can do
James McIntosh:shaping of garments as well. I just don't enjoy that bit.
Mia Hobbs:Does he knit?
James McIntosh:No, I've banned him from knitting.
Mia Hobbs:Okay. It's your thing.
James McIntosh:That's my thing. He doesn't have time to be
James McIntosh:honest. He does crochet which I'm trying to learn. Okay. Do
James McIntosh:you crochet?
Mia Hobbs:Well, I have and I do occasionally. And if I was
Mia Hobbs:making a toy or something 3D, I might choose crochet over
Mia Hobbs:knitting, maybe because I've done a couple because I wanted
Mia Hobbs:the thing to give to somebody or something. And I don't find it
Mia Hobbs:as I don't choose it. anywhere near as often as knitting. I
Mia Hobbs:also think in terms of the physical action, I would get
Mia Hobbs:more kind of RSI type pain. If I did it. And I think I prefer the
Mia Hobbs:fabric of knitting personally.
James McIntosh:I'm trying to learn crochet at the moment. And
James McIntosh:if any listeners would like to come I will cook lunch if you'd
James McIntosh:show because every online video I've looked on how to do a
James McIntosh:granny square the I get lost? No. Okay. I'm not daft I've got
James McIntosh:a Master of Arts Degree. Yeah, I can follow things, but they show
James McIntosh:you once. And then they go really fast and finish. Oh,
James McIntosh:okay. I need to see what the treble is again, please. Slow
James McIntosh:down!
Mia Hobbs:I think we, you know, I started knitting before. I
Mia Hobbs:think YouTube was a thing, but I think it is much easier
Mia Hobbs:generally to learn from because I think I learned from a book.
Mia Hobbs:But much easier to learn from seeing somebody and I've had a
Mia Hobbs:couple of people who've asked me to teach them to knit over zoom
Mia Hobbs:and I'm thinking really would be quite challenging. I think it's
Mia Hobbs:better to watch a video produced by somebody who has a proper
Mia Hobbs:camera that's on their hands. For example.
James McIntosh:I For Oh, for three years until lockdown, I
James McIntosh:haven't re-started. I ran a knitting group in Peckham. Okay.
James McIntosh:Yeah, we get up to 96 came. I mean, it was. Yeah. But
James McIntosh:everybody needed to learn to knit. Right? Yeah. So you start
James McIntosh:with a tension square. If you can get your tension, you can go
James McIntosh:on to a hat. Well, it was 96 drop stitches. Well I gave up,
James McIntosh:okay, if I bought everybody a Jager bomb at the bar. 96
James McIntosh:dropped stitches.
Mia Hobbs:They were all new knitters, were they? Oh, wow.
Mia Hobbs:That's, I mean, that's a lot. I'm running a therapeutic
Mia Hobbs:knitting group in a primary school. And I've found eight new
Mia Hobbs:knitters, you know, a lot. They are children. So they've
Mia Hobbs:obviously got other, you know, I have to also help them find the
Mia Hobbs:scissors or allow them to go to the toilet and that kind of
Mia Hobbs:thing. But, yeah, I think you do need an element of one to one
Mia Hobbs:support when you're just starting, don't you and then
Mia Hobbs:once you've got the flow of things, I think the other thing
Mia Hobbs:that's challenging over Zoom is sometimes you do just need to
Mia Hobbs:hand your knitting to somebody who knows what on earth has
Mia Hobbs:happened when it's gone wrong. And get them to help you
James McIntosh:we're actually recording this over zoom, as do
James McIntosh:you want this sleeve, because theres a dropped stitch you can
James McIntosh:see it as you're interviewing.
James McIntosh:There's a dropped stitch is there? No
James McIntosh:Of course there is, I'll fix it up later at the end. It's for
James McIntosh:photography. No you do. And th re is something caring about
James McIntosh:eaching someone to knits, you k ow, there is I am inter
James McIntosh:sted in your well being let m work with you. It's about a fri
James McIntosh:ndliness. It's you can talk bout things that are perso
James McIntosh:al. And talk about things that re deep. You can talk about
James McIntosh:life love, and you know, wash n cold water, dry flat and ri
James McIntosh:se and repeat. Yeah, life is tho e stitches.
Mia Hobbs:Do you feel like people talk more in a knitting
Mia Hobbs:group kind of environment? Because I suppose I wonder
Mia Hobbs:whether the lack of kind of intense eye contact and people
Mia Hobbs:kind of talk as they work on something. And sometimes that
Mia Hobbs:makes people more likely to share something because they're
Mia Hobbs:busy with their hands.
James McIntosh:One lady came to knitting group one night, her
James McIntosh:husband died that morning. She just wanted to be at her
James McIntosh:knitting group. Yeah, because she knew she could talk. And
James McIntosh:what an honour an honour it is. To start something with somebody
James McIntosh:will tell you that. I just gave her the biggest hug.
Mia Hobbs:I've found you know, it's a way of giving someone
Mia Hobbs:comforts it's really hard, isn't it when someone's been through a
Mia Hobbs:bereavement from the outside to know what.
James McIntosh:tell me about it from the inside.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah, exactly. And that's a whole nother story. But
Mia Hobbs:even from the outside thinking, how can I be helpful to this
Mia Hobbs:person, but I guess sitting alongside them and knitting
Mia Hobbs:without,
James McIntosh:at a time, one stitch at a time. It's not a
James McIntosh:race unless you own the wool company
Mia Hobbs:And has that changed how you feel about the knitting.
Mia Hobbs:James. I'm wondering.
James McIntosh:I have my knitting. Yeah, and I have my
James McIntosh:work knitting
Mia Hobbs:Okay, so that's separate.
James McIntosh:Yeah. Work is about coloured blocks and stitch
James McIntosh:patterns. My knitting is about a jumper for me. Yeah. No. As we
James McIntosh:talk, I've sent some stuff out to designers. And I'm absolutely
James McIntosh:shocked that a two skein shawl has been knit in three days. And
James McIntosh:when we come off this interview, I'm going to have a look to see
James McIntosh:what it is because I've been sent a picture of it. They can't
James McIntosh:wait. I don't know how Brian Smith Designs has knit that
James McIntosh:fast.
Mia Hobbs:Wow. That's very fast.
James McIntosh:I know.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah. Is knitting ever unhelpful for your mental
Mia Hobbs:health?
James McIntosh:No, no, no, because, you know, his best bet
James McIntosh:is if you get really peeved off with a pattern, yeah, you just
James McIntosh:put it in the bag. I've got 72 of them. My PhDs my project half
James McIntosh:dones. Oh, I haven't found it. I have knit everywhere. I mean,
James McIntosh:everywhere. Around the world, knitting. There is no problem
James McIntosh:getting needles on a plane. I have.
Mia Hobbs:I used to worry a lot about that though. I did bring a
Mia Hobbs:crochet hook once because I was thinking well, they're not
Mia Hobbs:surely they're not going to take that off me.
James McIntosh:I just cry at security. Don't take my needles
James McIntosh:away. And I've knit in nightclubs I used to knit in the
James McIntosh:Royal Vauxhall Tavern and discos to get things finished. i Oh,
James McIntosh:the night bus used to be really good the N63 night bus in
James McIntosh:London. Yeah, I've knit everywhere. Do you know you only
James McIntosh:ever get a smile and you are just sending love from your
James McIntosh:knitting needle to somebody else? And there was one night
James McIntosh:and these blokes got on the N63 Night bus Thomas and I were
James McIntosh:coming home from a Night Club and let's just say they looked
James McIntosh:like they were well oiled gentlemen with alcohol. Yeah.
James McIntosh:And he was a big bruiser. And there was a fight about to
James McIntosh:start. And he looks at me and he goes, my granny used to do that,
James McIntosh:can I feel your balls? I said, Excuse me. I said, my Merino. He
James McIntosh:calmed down, he sat beside me. And he said, that wool just
James McIntosh:feels like what my granny used to knit for me. And she was
James McIntosh:really, kind to me.
Mia Hobbs:That's amazing.
James McIntosh:I was about to die.
Mia Hobbs:It diffused everything
James McIntosh:Do you know what knitting makes you smile, it
James McIntosh:gives people hope. And I think specially, during and after the
James McIntosh:pandemic, especially with the climate crisis. You know, we
James McIntosh:need to look at our fibres carefully now, I know not
James McIntosh:everybody can afford new wool. But we need to consider manmade
James McIntosh:fibres carefully. We need to consider what the petrochemical
James McIntosh:industry makes, we need to consider making yarns out of
James McIntosh:kerosene. And we need to be careful about this. Because the
James McIntosh:fossil fuel it takes to make them and they don't biodegrade.
James McIntosh:And we need to look at this and it is I don't have an answer.
James McIntosh:Yeah. I know the price of hand dyed pure British wool, yeah,
James McIntosh:not everybody can afford that.
Mia Hobbs:Yes, it's expensive.
James McIntosh:It is. And I'm not yarn shaming. I'm looking at
James McIntosh:a debate. There's also a medical research paper that's out you
James McIntosh:can it's very easy to Google and it shows where there is acrylic
James McIntosh:fibre in human lung tissue, okay. Right. This is this is
James McIntosh:serious, you know. But we have to look at this sensibly, we
James McIntosh:have to look at microplastics but all this will start to
James McIntosh:happen. You know, COP26, I must say to get as far as they did
James McIntosh:with so many nations and so many cultures and so much invested
James McIntosh:financial interest for countries. I was impressed
James McIntosh:knitting, for me is mental health, but knitting is life. It
James McIntosh:is family, it is society, it is environment. It is industry, it
James McIntosh:is economics, it is farming, it is food production. It is it is
James McIntosh:politics. Knitting is not just one thing.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah, you can make, I don't know demonstrate your
Mia Hobbs:values, I suppose. And make choices about your politics by
Mia Hobbs:what yarn you choose and what fibres you're using and
James McIntosh:what Pussy hat you wear. And that I am proud of
James McIntosh:you know, the pussy hat whenever Trump was a little bit crude
James McIntosh:with his as he called locker room talk. unexcusable
James McIntosh:ignorance.
Mia Hobbs:Do you want to just explain for people who don't
Mia Hobbs:know about that? Because it was a few years ago now, isn't it
Mia Hobbs:when Trump was elected
James McIntosh:When Trump was elected He said the most
James McIntosh:disgusting thing about females about why he wanted to grab
James McIntosh:them. And he excused it by saying it was a locker room
James McIntosh:talk. Well, I'm sorry. That was degrading, misogynistic, and
James McIntosh:just, quite frankly, disgusting. So the ladies in America decided
James McIntosh:right can, we do best knitting. But they do other things better.
James McIntosh:So what they were doing was actually playing to the
James McIntosh:stereotype and just saying, don't mess with us. So they
James McIntosh:developed what was termed the pussy hat is what we would know
James McIntosh:Shapeways as a tea bag hat. So a large rectangle folded over and
James McIntosh:it was in pink. And they used a yarn originally from a wonderful
James McIntosh:company I know very well in South America called Malabrigo.
James McIntosh:And they developed this and they wore it in their 1000s to the
James McIntosh:rallies to protest against Trump. And if something so
James McIntosh:innocent as knitting can make a colourful sea of statement
James McIntosh:across the world, what hope is there for us in those stitches
James McIntosh:and how blessed are we to knit those stitches?
Mia Hobbs:Yeah. So it really is knitted politics.
James McIntosh:It's knitted life is visibility to the to the
James McIntosh:invisible in society. It is saying I am here. This is my
James McIntosh:statement, and you will see me I will knit because I am worth
James McIntosh:something like those knitted stitches are worth something.
James McIntosh:Oh, I'm all for knitting. Yeah.
Mia Hobbs:And it's so important and it has been throughout your
Mia Hobbs:life in so many different ways, doesn't it? Yeah. Yeah. And I
Mia Hobbs:always ask on the podcast about a significant project. If you
Mia Hobbs:wouldn't mind telling me it sounds like there's been a lot.
James McIntosh:There was one.
Mia Hobbs:There's one. Okay.
James McIntosh:There was one. I grew up with a lady called
James McIntosh:Kerry. And she she married a friend of ours called Dean on
James McIntosh:the farm next door. And when mum died, she came with a casserole.
James McIntosh:And she jumped out of the car and said James. I know there's
James McIntosh:COVID I am giving you a hug, because you need one. Kerry came
James McIntosh:to see me every day. And it was lockdown. And I wanted to say
James McIntosh:thank you when I got back to London, and I knit a blanket.
James McIntosh:it was known as a Hue Afghan Shift blanket. Okay, I can't
James McIntosh:remember who designed it. I can look it up on Ravelry. Okay. And
James McIntosh:it was mitre squares that joined together, it was huge. And it
James McIntosh:made a cross in the middle and an just a display of colour from
James McIntosh:top to bottom corner to corner is gorgeous. And I knit it for
James McIntosh:Kerry one stitch at a time. It was all done in garter stitch.
James McIntosh:So I could put my grief and my tears into that without having
James McIntosh:to think Yeah. And as this grew, and as the colours grew, I
James McIntosh:realised that the end there was a beautiful yellow cross in the
James McIntosh:middle of it. And then this was my grief blanket, I called it
James McIntosh:and you know what? The most important bit of that blanket
James McIntosh:was giving it away. And I gave it to Kerry. And I was just
James McIntosh:like, I had to give my mum away. My tears and the pain and my
James McIntosh:feeling and my anger and my happiness and my sad and my
James McIntosh:worry and My strength. And every fibre of what I was struggling
James McIntosh:with, I put into that blanket.
Mia Hobbs:And that's amazing actually James the bit about
Mia Hobbs:giving it away because I've heard a few other people talk
Mia Hobbs:about significant projects and getting them through
Mia Hobbs:bereavements.
James McIntosh:Yeah, you have to give it away, and then it's,
Mia Hobbs:but I haven't heard anyone else who's given it away.
Mia Hobbs:And that's really interesting that you know, the parallel with
Mia Hobbs:having to give your mum away
James McIntosh:Grief has to be shared. Grief has to be shared
James McIntosh:because there were many people who loved my mum. I mean, mum,
James McIntosh:mum was a home economics teacher. She was a farmer's
James McIntosh:wife. She ran the ladies group in church, she ran the, the
James McIntosh:infants and babies and toddlers group in church and mum was the
James McIntosh:community. And we were not allowed a funeral. Do you know
James McIntosh:what that was? Like? We were allowed 10 minutes in the
James McIntosh:garden. So I had to do something for Kerry, who loved my mum too
James McIntosh:who I had to do something to make this all, it will never be
James McIntosh:okay. Yeah, but I had to set Mum free in my heart. Yeah. And I
James McIntosh:did it. And I gave it away because the metaphor of if you
James McIntosh:really love someone, you set them free is not about love and
James McIntosh:two teenagers falling out when they're going out. It's about
James McIntosh:losing, deeply losing. But you know, my mum's still with me I
James McIntosh:chat to her every day. We talk about the stitches.
Mia Hobbs:Was she a knitter?
James McIntosh:Oh, yes. Okay.Oh, yeah. Oh, mum, knitting
James McIntosh:and crocheting crafts. And our mum was stunning at it and
James McIntosh:embroidery. And yeah.
Mia Hobbs:Do you think maybe that planted a seed for you?
Mia Hobbs:Like maybe that was why your brain went to that place when
Mia Hobbs:you were needing something you could do in your bed?
James McIntosh:Oh, no. Mum said to me quite clearly. Boys don't
James McIntosh:do that. It's okay. So mum came over in the middle of my
James McIntosh:depression and brought her to John Lewis. And that's how it
James McIntosh:all started really. So yeah. Mum Mum helped me a lot with it. And
James McIntosh:for Knit and Nibble. Mum did some of the some of the jumpers
James McIntosh:for me, but
Mia Hobbs:Okay, so you did knit together later on?
James McIntosh:Well, she did it in Northern Ireland. I did it
James McIntosh:here, pray the Lord for FaceTime. And yeah, away we go.
James McIntosh:Yeah. So yeah. This hasn't been too heavy a podcast for you.
James McIntosh:It's
James McIntosh:not at all I think it's it's just amazing how important
James McIntosh:knitting has been and how you've also really used it very
James McIntosh:deliberately, mindfully, intentionally for like you said,
James McIntosh:keeping yourself going, saving your life, managing some really
James McIntosh:difficult times discrimination, bereavement, you know, making
James McIntosh:political protest, protest, you know, it's really, but knitting
James McIntosh:is all of those things. And like you said, it is, you know,
James McIntosh:exactly, so I think it's really and probably not many of us
James McIntosh:think about all of those things that often and I guess that is
James McIntosh:part of the podcast is thinking about actually, a lot of
James McIntosh:knitters really feel it is very significant to them. So I don't
James McIntosh:think you're going to be alone in having, you know, like I
James McIntosh:said, bereavement something that's come up very often when
James McIntosh:people talk about significant projects. But I think you've
James McIntosh:definitely thought about all of these things and the role of
James McIntosh:knitting a lot more than most people and articulated those
James McIntosh:thoughts.
James McIntosh:I've got on my knitmcintosh.com website, I've got a little bot.
James McIntosh:So when I'm not there, you know, you can type in questions and
James McIntosh:the bot will give you answers that are pre programmed in.
James McIntosh:Yeah. And a lot of people use it. And what we've noticed, when
James McIntosh:I get up in the morning, if I'm not there to answer the
James McIntosh:questions, I get an email with what people have typed. So I can
James McIntosh:get back to them. You know, people tell me their stories,
James McIntosh:people tell me about the worry that the can't be with their
James McIntosh:husband who's had a heart attack and how they're nothing's kept
James McIntosh:on going. And there's something viral happening privately viral,
James McIntosh:that by me being able to tell my story, other people are telling
James McIntosh:there's that people are finding freedom, and they're nothing and
James McIntosh:talking about it. And this is all good. This is wonderful
James McIntosh:therapy. This is then I am here, and then they can wear it. They
James McIntosh:can wear their story, in bright colours and be proud of it. And
James McIntosh:rightly so.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah. And I think it's something certainly from my
Mia Hobbs:conversation with Betsan Corkhill, who
James McIntosh:Oh Betsan is wonderful, she helped me start
James McIntosh:my journey.
Mia Hobbs:And she talks a lot about therapeutic knitting. And
Mia Hobbs:the way she started was by discovering this filing cabinet
Mia Hobbs:at a Knitting magazine or crafting magazine that where
Mia Hobbs:they had all of these letters from people who'd, who were
Mia Hobbs:writing about the significance of their story with knitting,
Mia Hobbs:and it was a filing cabinet that she discovered and turned into,
Mia Hobbs:you know, the catalyst for the rest of her career, really. But
Mia Hobbs:now, I guess it's happening more online, so other people can
Mia Hobbs:share and interact with those stories more, I think, whereas
Mia Hobbs:previously when they sat in a physical filing cabinet, maybe
Mia Hobbs:that was more difficult.
James McIntosh:What I love most about Betson was how She
James McIntosh:struggled to get research published on knitting So she
James McIntosh:changed it quite sensibly to instead of calling it knitting
James McIntosh:into a bilateral rhythmic psychosocial intervention. Of
James McIntosh:course, everybody wants to fund a bilateral rhythmic
James McIntosh:psychosocial intervention and give it money, you know, well
James McIntosh:done, you Betsan.
Mia Hobbs:James I always ask about knitting high and low,
Mia Hobbs:they can be deep and meaningful or entirely frivolous, whatever
Mia Hobbs:comes to mind for you.
James McIntosh:I think you've dealt with the lows. I think
James McIntosh:I've told you about the love. That's the highs. Yeah. And I
James McIntosh:don't know, I think I've covered that well. I have knit all over
James McIntosh:the world. Oh, knitting high lying in the Dead Sea. Which was
James McIntosh:the day after Thomas's mum died. And I was lying in the Dead Sea.
James McIntosh:Knitting
Mia Hobbs:Yeah. Wow. And how did you keep it dry?
James McIntosh:I put it on my tummy.
Mia Hobbs:And you were that boyant?
James McIntosh:,you're only going up to your knees and walk
James McIntosh:in backwards. And you just sit down? Yeah. And it throws you
James McIntosh:over. So my whole tummy was dry,
Mia Hobbs:and you were knitting there? Yeah, extraordinary.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah, definitely sounds like a knitting like a once in a
Mia Hobbs:lifetime.
James McIntosh:No it makes me sound like I'm weird. And I need
James McIntosh:to go back to the Maudsley for more.
Mia Hobbs:Sounds like you're very dedicated knitter just
Mia Hobbs:depends on what spin you put on it James. Indeed, do you find it
Mia Hobbs:and you end up striking up conversations with random people
Mia Hobbs:because they see you knitting?
James McIntosh:The most Random? Honestly, I mean, who else knits
James McIntosh:in a night club, I mean there was a very famous gay nightclub
James McIntosh:back in the 90s. called Heaven. Yeah, it's still going well,
James McIntosh:there was a certain sound of music in the 90s naughties in
James McIntosh:Heaven. And they were doing a tribute to it at the Royal
James McIntosh:Vauxhall Tavern one night, but I had a photography sample to do
James McIntosh:and I haven't heard this music in years. And I really wanted
James McIntosh:to go out and just be it. You know? 20 something again? Yeah.
James McIntosh:So I was clubbing doing my knitting I think to get it
James McIntosh:finished, and do you know what it worked.
Mia Hobbs:Are there any places where you feel like the knitting
Mia Hobbs:has helped you? I don't know feel okay in a place. I don't
Mia Hobbs:own a doctor's waiting room or that it's helped. I don't know
Mia Hobbs:whether it helped him that night bus whether you felt
James McIntosh:my biggest phobia is injection needles. is
James McIntosh:cruel phobia to have. It's awful. Getting COVID Jobs was
James McIntosh:not easy. was not easy. I had to get quite a bit of diazepam from
James McIntosh:a doctor. It was it was not Thomas, by the way. It was not
James McIntosh:easy. During my depression, I needed some dental work done.
James McIntosh:And I couldn't but Christine who goes to my knitting group. She's
James McIntosh:a dentist, okay. And I sit in her chair knitting. While she
James McIntosh:does my dental injections and that's how we do it. Wow.
Mia Hobbs:And that helped enough to get you to manage it
James McIntosh:i still scream like a two year old. So you're
James McIntosh:killing me, but it just didn't do it. He just, I can do it.
James McIntosh:Yeah, I don't like it, but I can do. And I do have a shake after
James McIntosh:my body just shakes after having injection, but I can still get
James McIntosh:it done. Yeah. And everybody's got something like this.
James McIntosh:Everybody. I was scared about giving up smoking. The thought
James McIntosh:of being not being a nonsmoker. But the thought about giving up
James McIntosh:something that I'd done habitually for 20 odd years.
James McIntosh:Yeah, it did scare me. But knitting just. A stitch is a
James McIntosh:breath stitch, A stitch is tangible. So I am and if I can
James McIntosh:make this stitch, I can do whatever I need to do.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah, that's amazing
James McIntosh:that answer your question does?
Mia Hobbs:And it feels kind of, I don't know whether it's
Mia Hobbs:slightly frivolous to ask this question when you've offered so
Mia Hobbs:much. But I always end with asking the greatest gift that
Mia Hobbs:knitting has given you for the rest of your life. And I guess
Mia Hobbs:for you, maybe it's difficult to pin down because it's
James McIntosh:Oh, no. That's easy. My greatest gift through
James McIntosh:knitting? Yeah, is a song that the late and very great Whitney
James McIntosh:Houston sang. And that is once I have learned to love myself, it
James McIntosh:is the greatest gift of all. And when I've got that no one, no
James McIntosh:matter how hard they try, with homophobia with whatever, they
James McIntosh:cannot take away my dignity, because through knitting, I have
James McIntosh:found me.
Mia Hobbs:And that's the ultimate. It is. Yeah, the key
Mia Hobbs:to all of the other things.
James McIntosh:I have peace in myself. You know, and that's,
James McIntosh:that's not an easy thing to find. No. But I've done that
James McIntosh:through knitting.
Mia Hobbs:Yeah, that's amazing. Thank you so much for sharing.
James McIntosh:Thank you for having me.
James McIntosh:It was an absolute pleasure to talk to you. And can you just
James McIntosh:let us know? Because I'm sure there'll be lots of people who
James McIntosh:want to find out about your yarn and your books, and
James McIntosh:my knititation
James McIntosh:Exactly. So just tell people what are the best ways to get in
James McIntosh:touch or to find out what you're up to?
James McIntosh:would just come and see me online at knitmcintosh.com.
James McIntosh:That's knit K.N.I.T. mcintosh.com. At KnitMcIntosh on
James McIntosh:all the socials. Come and see me drop me an email. I normally say
James McIntosh:Hello, nice and friendly.
Mia Hobbs:Thank you so much, James.
James McIntosh:Pleasure. Thank you, Mia.
Mia Hobbs:Thank you for listening to the Why I Knit
Mia Hobbs:podcast. If you'd like to find out more about therapeutic
Mia Hobbs:knitting you can follow me on Instagram
Mia Hobbs:@knittingistherapeutic. Or check out my website
Mia Hobbs:therapeuticknitting.org. To be notified when a new podcast is
Mia Hobbs:released. Please subscribe on your podcast app.